♈️

Posted by UnusualVaginalDischarge
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by brianafay
Posted by Shadowcat
Posted by Shadowcat
Oh lol the game is over. Sucks


This isn't a dig at you @dividedwecapricorn, I just wish that it went on for longer.

My heart is broken!!!

How could you kill me ? You're my most beloved mafia host


Actually a witch controlled him and killed you, he was originally gonna kill the janitor

Thank you Witch! 😘

@Zagittarius


who did you clean btw?
click to expand


Sorry Dazed
Posted by UnusualVaginalDischarge
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by brianafay
Posted by Shadowcat
Posted by Shadowcat
Oh lol the game is over. Sucks


This isn't a dig at you @dividedwecapricorn, I just wish that it went on for longer.

My heart is broken!!!

How could you kill me ? You're my most beloved mafia host


Actually a witch controlled him and killed you, he was originally gonna kill the janitor

Thank you Witch! 😘

@Zagittarius


@Zagittarius hasn't responded to a single PM i've sent

account issues i'm assuming.

hope it gets fixed i miss sagluvscorp
click to expand

Hope it gets fixed soon.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by GetMisted
I thought it was a horrible game tbh


The amount of invisible PMs and gamethrowing really made this horrible

It's day 2 and 3 baddies are basically asking to die?
click to expand

It is horrible ... just thank you for hosting
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
I sense heavy sarcasm from all of you


No sarcasm.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by brianafay
Posted by Shadowcat
Posted by Shadowcat
Oh lol the game is over. Sucks


This isn't a dig at you @dividedwecapricorn, I just wish that it went on for longer.

My heart is broken!!!

How could you kill me ? You're my most beloved mafia host


Actually a witch controlled him and killed you, he was originally gonna kill the janitor
click to expand

Thank you Witch! 😘

@Zagittarius
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Role list:

Investigator - LiveAndLove (Doused)
Sheriff - ShinyTauros
Lookout - No
Escort - Capz
Retributionist - Blue_Froggie
Mayor - CaramelizedCoffee
Vigilante - Elle
Vampire Hunter - imbatgirl14
Veteran - Mimi24
Bodyguard - Brianafay (Dead)
Doctor - Getmisted (0 self heals left)
Godfather - starwars
Mafioso - rekt
Janitor - sakuraflowers (2 cleans left)
Consigliere - DepthAndDeath
Survivor - AdmiralCrabbyPatterson
Arsonist - Nikkistar
Serial Killer - shadowcat
Witch - Zagittarius
Jester - VirgoGent
Vampire - UVD

I figured VirgoGent wasnt a townie lol.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
@AfternoonDelights

I suggest that you give Town of Salem a go first (search it up on google).

I understand your point of view, but what I don't get is that Town of Salem has no Normal Townies, but can still work out perfectly, while my version can't despite being similar.

Can you give it a try and tell me why? I'm trying to figure this out as well. And no, Normal Townies isn't the solution to fix this game.


You asking way TOO much from DXP folks.


I'm trying my best to find a solution that doesn't involve random shooting and sparkle motion normal townies.

You need normal townies in there.

What dont you get? If townies ask mafias about their role and the mafias, the mafias will be found out. It is only a matter of time.


What I don't get is how Town of Salem can work out perfectly without a speck of Normal Townies while we can't here in dxp?

Mafia can disguise about their role with some other role that works similarly, such as survivor/sheriff/bodyguard for Godfather.


No, it is not possible to disguise as other roles. The validity of the reports will be brought up, examined, and found out.


Same with baddies disguising as normal townies. What's the point then?

Because the townies in your game all have abilities that cannot be faked by a mafia.

A normal townie dont have abilities.

A mafia claiming a special role townie raises suspicion easily because they cannot do the ability accurately that they claim to have. With a normal townie, they dont have that problem.


... And that's why I came up with a solution.

Make it so roles aren't unique (meaning there are more than 1) in the game. With multiple roles (Instead of telling the world that there are 2 investigators, it will be written as 2 Town Investigative roles), the chances of faking it are easier since people would have to guess who the other person is without knowing their actual role. For instance, there is a person who claimed lookout and another claimed sheriff. It can be either since Town Investigative roles include the both of them. This makes hiding easier for mafia I hope.
click to expand


How? Lets say mafia claims sheriff. Peole will ask that who they investigated or who they should investigate. If the mafia lies about a townie being a evil role (when that townie has been confirmed by someone else), that mafia will get caught. I think you underestimate how much of this game goes on in PMs.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
@AfternoonDelights

I suggest that you give Town of Salem a go first (search it up on google).

I understand your point of view, but what I don't get is that Town of Salem has no Normal Townies, but can still work out perfectly, while my version can't despite being similar.

Can you give it a try and tell me why? I'm trying to figure this out as well. And no, Normal Townies isn't the solution to fix this game.


You asking way TOO much from DXP folks.


I'm trying my best to find a solution that doesn't involve random shooting and sparkle motion normal townies.

You need normal townies in there.

What dont you get? If townies ask mafias about their role and the mafias, the mafias will be found out. It is only a matter of time.


What I don't get is how Town of Salem can work out perfectly without a speck of Normal Townies while we can't here in dxp?

Mafia can disguise about their role with some other role that works similarly, such as survivor/sheriff/bodyguard for Godfather.


No, it is not possible to disguise as other roles. The validity of the reports will be brought up, examined, and found out.


Same with baddies disguising as normal townies. What's the point then?
click to expand

Because the townies in your game all have abilities that cannot be faked by a mafia.

A normal townie dont have abilities.

A mafia claiming a special role townie raises suspicion easily because they cannot do the ability accurately that they claim to have. With a normal townie, they dont have that problem.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
@AfternoonDelights

I suggest that you give Town of Salem a go first (search it up on google).

I understand your point of view, but what I don't get is that Town of Salem has no Normal Townies, but can still work out perfectly, while my version can't despite being similar.

Can you give it a try and tell me why? I'm trying to figure this out as well. And no, Normal Townies isn't the solution to fix this game.


You asking way TOO much from DXP folks.


I'm trying my best to find a solution that doesn't involve random shooting and sparkle motion normal townies.

You need normal townies in there.

What dont you get? If townies ask mafias about their role and the mafias, the mafias will be found out. It is only a matter of time.


What I don't get is how Town of Salem can work out perfectly without a speck of Normal Townies while we can't here in dxp?

Mafia can disguise about their role with some other role that works similarly, such as survivor/sheriff/bodyguard for Godfather.
click to expand


No, it is not possible to disguise as other roles. The validity of the reports will be brought up, examined, and found out.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
@AfternoonDelights

I suggest that you give Town of Salem a go first (search it up on google).

I understand your point of view, but what I don't get is that Town of Salem has no Normal Townies, but can still work out perfectly, while my version can't despite being similar.

Can you give it a try and tell me why? I'm trying to figure this out as well. And no, Normal Townies isn't the solution to fix this game.


You asking way TOO much from DXP folks.


I'm trying my best to find a solution that doesn't involve random shooting and sparkle motion normal townies.
click to expand

You need normal townies in there.

What dont you get? If townies ask mafias about their role and the mafias lie and claim roles, the mafias will be found out. It is only a matter of time.
Posted by Blue_Froggie
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
there are enough votes. more then 10

6 for Starwars
7 for Nikkistar




I would really like it if Nikkistar or Starwars have 10 votes.

Then they'll be held up in an hour.


you meant EACH, wow, lol, that's a tough one i thought you meant 10 people 10 votes

what do you mean held up?


Normally they can defend themselves when they're held up, before everyone decides whether they're guilty or not.


so voting alone doesn't get them out, they get to talk about it?


Normally, but since everyone's throwing the game, might as well as jump straight into the second voting stage, which is whether the suspect is guilty or innocent.


why do all of that, we already voting them out. our vote should count as a vote for them to be out

not all of this second voting stage crap

i worked very hard for those nikkistar votes dude


Fine dammit, when votes exceed 10 for any individual, they die.


how many players haven't played their roles or PMed you at all?


Like 6 I believe, Sheriff never told me about checking on someone, while some others are understandable, such as not putting vests on for Survivor or Veteran.


hmm nice

we can't have the 10 votes thing then


Still achievable imo, but teamwork has to be involved at all times.





This is a lot more different than the actual game that its based off of. In that game, nothing like this ever happened.


aww its ok its just a game, most of the roles were cool so are the ideas for voting and the 10 votes thing, you needed to ask others dxp game makers for help as it has to be different that the town of salem



It was designed to be as close as possible (except that there are a lot more discussion, slow paced, and more people as you can only have a maximum of 15 people)


we usually have 16 people, you needed to plan all teams advantages vs disadvantages. roles are great imo I like the mafia powers, but we needed useless townie roles that we could claim and not get caught.


Such as the retributionist and escort? I see them as rather passive roles that you don't always need to prove. Or maybe I should have multiple roles that are the same. The thing about useless townie roles is that an Investigator and Consigliere will quickly realize that people are lying and thus the whole idea of "useless townie roles" is no more than a weak disguise.

Lets say for example ...

@GetMisted (Dazed)- cop
@AfternoonDelights22 (Nights) - slut
me - mafia

With no regular townies, it goes like this very quickly ...
Nights will ask me and Dazed at some point what roles we have. Lets say I claim cop and not knowing who the real one is.

What do you think will happen?

Nights sees two people claiming cop. Then both Dazed and I will be asked who we each investigated last night. Lets say we both chose @feby ... who Nights chose two nights before and confirmed as townie (where Dazed and I did not know).

I make a guess and say feby is guilty. Dazed says the opposite.

What do you think Nights will think, in this case?




Hmmm
He is the slut so he sleeps with you( mafia)?
click to expand

Thats the point. He will be fairly certain that I am mafia.
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
there are enough votes. more then 10

6 for Starwars
7 for Nikkistar




I would really like it if Nikkistar or Starwars have 10 votes.

Then they'll be held up in an hour.


you meant EACH, wow, lol, that's a tough one i thought you meant 10 people 10 votes

what do you mean held up?


Normally they can defend themselves when they're held up, before everyone decides whether they're guilty or not.


so voting alone doesn't get them out, they get to talk about it?


Normally, but since everyone's throwing the game, might as well as jump straight into the second voting stage, which is whether the suspect is guilty or innocent.


why do all of that, we already voting them out. our vote should count as a vote for them to be out

not all of this second voting stage crap

i worked very hard for those nikkistar votes dude


Fine dammit, when votes exceed 10 for any individual, they die.


how many players haven't played their roles or PMed you at all?


Like 6 I believe, Sheriff never told me about checking on someone, while some others are understandable, such as not putting vests on for Survivor or Veteran.


hmm nice

we can't have the 10 votes thing then


Still achievable imo, but teamwork has to be involved at all times.





This is a lot more different than the actual game that its based off of. In that game, nothing like this ever happened.


aww its ok its just a game, most of the roles were cool so are the ideas for voting and the 10 votes thing, you needed to ask others dxp game makers for help as it has to be different that the town of salem



It was designed to be as close as possible (except that there are a lot more discussion, slow paced, and more people as you can only have a maximum of 15 people)


we usually have 16 people, you needed to plan all teams advantages vs disadvantages. roles are great imo I like the mafia powers, but we needed useless townie roles that we could claim and not get caught.


Such as the retributionist and escort? I see them as rather passive roles that you don't always need to prove. Or maybe I should have multiple roles that are the same. The thing about useless townie roles is that an Investigator and Consigliere will quickly realize that people are lying and thus the whole idea of "useless townie roles" is no more than a weak disguise.

Lets say for example ...

@GetMisted (Dazed)- cop
@AfternoonDelights22 (Nights) - slut
me - mafia

With no regular townies, it goes like this very quickly ...
Nights will ask me and Dazed at some point what roles we have. Lets say I claim cop and not knowing who the real one is.

What do you think will happen?

Nights sees two people claiming cop. Then both Dazed and I will be asked who we each investigated last night. Lets say we both chose @feby ... who Nights chose two nights before and confirmed as townie (where Dazed and I did not know).

I make a guess and say feby is guilty. Dazed says the opposite.

What do you think Nights will think, in this case?





Sleep with the Scorpio
click to expand


lmao, no need. The Scorp is more likely to be confirmed as the cop.
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by starwars
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by DividedWeCapricorn
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
there are enough votes. more then 10

6 for Starwars
7 for Nikkistar




I would really like it if Nikkistar or Starwars have 10 votes.

Then they'll be held up in an hour.


you meant EACH, wow, lol, that's a tough one i thought you meant 10 people 10 votes

what do you mean held up?


Normally they can defend themselves when they're held up, before everyone decides whether they're guilty or not.


so voting alone doesn't get them out, they get to talk about it?


Normally, but since everyone's throwing the game, might as well as jump straight into the second voting stage, which is whether the suspect is guilty or innocent.


why do all of that, we already voting them out. our vote should count as a vote for them to be out

not all of this second voting stage crap

i worked very hard for those nikkistar votes dude


Fine dammit, when votes exceed 10 for any individual, they die.


how many players haven't played their roles or PMed you at all?


Like 6 I believe, Sheriff never told me about checking on someone, while some others are understandable, such as not putting vests on for Survivor or Veteran.


hmm nice

we can't have the 10 votes thing then


Still achievable imo, but teamwork has to be involved at all times.





This is a lot more different than the actual game that its based off of. In that game, nothing like this ever happened.


aww its ok its just a game, most of the roles were cool so are the ideas for voting and the 10 votes thing, you needed to ask others dxp game makers for help as it has to be different that the town of salem



It was designed to be as close as possible (except that there are a lot more discussion, slow paced, and more people as you can only have a maximum of 15 people)


we usually have 16 people, you needed to plan all teams advantages vs disadvantages. roles are great imo I like the mafia powers, but we needed useless townie roles that we could claim and not get caught.


Such as the retributionist and escort? I see them as rather passive roles that you don't always need to prove. Or maybe I should have multiple roles that are the same. The thing about useless townie roles is that an Investigator and Consigliere will quickly realize that people are lying and thus the whole idea of "useless townie roles" is no more than a weak disguise.
click to expand

Lets say for example ...

@GetMisted (Dazed)- cop
@AfternoonDelights22 (Nights) - slut
me - mafia

With no regular townies, it goes like this very quickly ...
Nights will ask me and Dazed at some point what roles we have. Lets say I claim cop and not knowing who the real one is.

What do you think will happen?

Nights sees two people claiming cop. Then both Dazed and I will be asked who we each investigated last night. Lets say we both chose @feby ... who Nights chose two nights before and confirmed as townie (where Dazed and I did not know).

I make a guess and say feby is guilty. Dazed says the opposite.

What do you think Nights will think, in this case?



Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by sakuraflowers
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by sakuraflowers
Anyway, I'm heading out. I'll be back later.

@nikkistar

I vote @starwars


sellout. as usual, you vote along party lines.


Shouldn't I be voting for the Godfather?


i know you're mafia, but okay, play along ...
click to expand

Proof? Because the last game when you said that and were also sure of me being mafia, I was the gunsmith.
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by sakuraflowers
Anyway, I'm heading out. I'll be back later.

@nikkistar

I vote @starwars


sellout. as usual, you vote along party lines.
click to expand


Shouldn't I be voting for the Godfather? Townies would want all non townies out, no?
Anyway, I'm heading out. I'll be back later.

@nikkistar

I vote @starwars
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
So if shadowcat hosts the next game I assume uvd cannot play lol


Wait, what happened?