delima between cap male or aqua male smgdh

long story short#cap i was wit last yr just got out #and of course ya'll know he came back 2 mama and I couldn't turn my back on him#butt this aqua man I been seein the last few weeks IM totally smitten by plus the cap told me once he got out that he would marry me#we hadnt been intouuch so I didnt know he was gone get out any time soon#also I didnt think we would get back 2gether cuz we had broken up b4 all this with the aqua man#I honestly wanna just keep both of em but know that aint possible, so any opinions—??

I tried bein honest to em both cap man took it all fine aqua man told me theres nothin more to talk about
but i have talked to him since then and its just so confusing cuz I honestly got feelings for em both smgdh

Go with the aqua. The cap is your past. Dump the jailbird and go with the one without the checkered past.