Confusing scorpio man

Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Hi,

I am new here, and need some help with this weird on and off "relationship" I have had with a scorpio man for more than 10 years. We can't seem to stay away from each other, but can't make anything happen either.

Can anybody help me get some clarity on this?

Here are parts of our charts:

Me: (Birthday is January 19 1985)

Sun in Capricorn

Ascendant in Cancer

Venus in Pisces

Mars in Pisces

Moon in Capricorn

Mercury in Capricorn

Saturn in Scorpio

Pluto in Scorpio

His: (Birthday is nov 2 1986 - don't know the time)

Sun in Scorpio

Venus in Scorpio

Mars in Aquarius

Moon in Scorpio

Mercury in Scorpio

Saturn in Sagittarius

Pluto in Scorpio



Thanks in advance!!!
Profile picture of Escorpio90
Escorpio90
@Escorpio90
8 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 40 · Topics: 9


Hello ... I understand, the same thing happens with an ex-girlfriend of mine .. the years go by and there is no way to let go of us but we also can not be together, anyway ... according to what I read this is due to the connections in synastry when venus does aspects to pluto of the other person. Surely some personal planet of yours is touching its pluton with some aspect. These aspects generate obsessions, pluto with venus it becomes impossible to let go, and that they can not return maybe something of a neptune, poorly aspected Saturn.
Profile picture of AgentP911
AgentP911
@AgentP911
11 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 3847 · Topics: 1
Here is your clarity:

You are now 33 years old and have chosen to spend the last ten years ‘on and off’ with a man who is only offering you ‘on and off’. If you’re happy with this then please continue as you were for the next ten years or more.

However, if you are not happy with this arrangement then I suggest you have a good think about what it is you want from your life and picture how you would like it to be.

If you want a more settled relationship with this man that is not ‘on and off’ then I suggest you state your terms to him. If he wants the same thing then great. You can proceed to build on your last ten years and enjoy the next ten years in a loving, stable, and enjoyable relationship (if he and you can provide this for each other etc).

If he isn’t prepared to offer you a relationship then you need to walk away and find someone who does want to offer you a relationship.

For example, if you wanted to buy a red car and only wanted a red car then you wouldn’t settle on buying a blue car. Why compromise on your relationship when you wouldn’t compromise on something less significant such as a car.

Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Posted by Squishy_Marshmallow
Posted by ldj
Hi,

I am new here, and need some help with this weird on and off "relationship" I have had with a scorpio man for more than 10 years. We can't seem to stay away from each other, but can't make anything happen either.

Can anybody help me get some clarity on this?

Here are parts of our charts:

Me: (Birthday is January 19 1985)

Sun in Capricorn

Ascendant in Cancer

Venus in Pisces

Mars in Pisces

Moon in Capricorn

Mercury in Capricorn

Saturn in Scorpio

Pluto in Scorpio

His: (Birthday is nov 2 1986 - don't know the time)

Sun in Scorpio

Venus in Scorpio

Mars in Aquarius

Moon in Scorpio

Mercury in Scorpio

Saturn in Sagittarius

Pluto in Scorpio



Thanks in advance!!!

Ten YEARS on and off?!!!

Anyways that Saturn square Venus looks harsh but I need to look at an actual synastry chart instead of placements... Doesn't help you don't have his time of birth to see how you affect him.

click to expand

Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Posted by Escorpio90
Hello ... I understand, the same thing happens with an ex-girlfriend of mine .. the years go by and there is no way to let go of us but we also can not be together, anyway ... according to what I read this is due to the connections in synastry when venus does aspects to pluto of the other person. Surely some personal planet of yours is touching its pluton with some aspect. These aspects generate obsessions, pluto with venus it becomes impossible to let go, and that they can not return maybe something of a neptune, poorly aspected Saturn.
Thank you Escorpio90. I really appreciate this. And somehow nice to know that others out there have similar experiences. I tell my self I need to stop and let go, but it is almost impossible somehow.
Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Posted by Squishy_Marshmallow
Posted by ldj
Hi,

I am new here, and need some help with this weird on and off "relationship" I have had with a scorpio man for more than 10 years. We can't seem to stay away from each other, but can't make anything happen either.

Can anybody help me get some clarity on this?

Here are parts of our charts:

Me: (Birthday is January 19 1985)

Sun in Capricorn

Ascendant in Cancer

Venus in Pisces

Mars in Pisces

Moon in Capricorn

Mercury in Capricorn

Saturn in Scorpio

Pluto in Scorpio

His: (Birthday is nov 2 1986 - don't know the time)

Sun in Scorpio

Venus in Scorpio

Mars in Aquarius

Moon in Scorpio

Mercury in Scorpio

Saturn in Sagittarius

Pluto in Scorpio



Thanks in advance!!!

Ten YEARS on and off?!!!

Anyways that Saturn square Venus looks harsh but I need to look at an actual synastry chart instead of placements... Doesn't help you don't have his time of birth to see how you affect him.

click to expand

I know it's crazy! I don't understand it myself. I guess that's why I turn to astrology, to get some answers. I am very new to astrology, but I do believe in it. Any help would be appreciated. How do you make a synastry chart?
Profile picture of Gemitati
Gemitati
@Gemitati
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 2057 · Posts: 38091 · Topics: 1026
Posted by ldj
Posted by Escorpio90
Hello ... I understand, the same thing happens with an ex-girlfriend of mine .. the years go by and there is no way to let go of us but we also can not be together, anyway ... according to what I read this is due to the connections in synastry when venus does aspects to pluto of the other person. Surely some personal planet of yours is touching its pluton with some aspect. These aspects generate obsessions, pluto with venus it becomes impossible to let go, and that they can not return maybe something of a neptune, poorly aspected Saturn.
Thank you Escorpio90. I really appreciate this. And somehow nice to know that others out there have similar experiences. I tell my self I need to stop and let go, but it is almost impossible somehow.
click to expand

The only solution to your problem is to find someone new. I’ve let Scorpio go after 8 years because I’ve replaced him!

Otherwise it’ll be a dead circle. Break away!
Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Thank you all.

I know that I need to move on! I actually ended it now. But I am here to understand, why I felt such a strong connection to this man - and so sure he felt it too. Maybe astrology holds some answers? If anyone can interpret anything from our charts or do a reading, I would appreciate it very much.

Maybe it is something in my chart, that make me so stubborn to let go. I am curious about it all.

Thank you in advance.
Profile picture of ldj
ldj
@ldj
7 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 14 · Topics: 2
Posted by La_Dolce_Vita_Scorpio
I have had a relationship with a Scorpio like engaged to marry types.

They are very demssnibg emotionally, if the needs aren't met they just resent

Forgiveness is something that don't come go Scorpios naturally.

I would suggest if you can, move away.

More than likely it's him who keeps coming back to you rather you going to him.

This is about control and risk averse attitude many Scorpios have.

I'm a Scorpio and I did the same with my Scorpio ex for 5 longs years on and off.

I was able to let go when I found someone else to forget the Scorpio.

He still Keep a coming back occasionally just to check how am I doing and all that but I have learned to resist him.

Good luck x
You are very right. I always thought it must mean something, that he kept coming back. He once said that he thought it meant something, that we kept coming back to each other. I guess it is just about control.