Whose most secretive? Pisces, Cancer or Scorpio?

Profile picture of ScorpioFish
ScorpioFish
@ScorpioFish
14 Years1,000+ PostsPisces

Comments: 5 · Posts: 4180 · Topics: 103
Sweetheart,

I agree that all water signs can be secretive. I sometimes do reveal my emotions if I want to be with a girl.

Which water sign do you think is the most secretive? Probably a tie between the 3 of us. Scorpios are secretive when they are having sex outside of their relationships and stuff like that. Cancers are secretive when they cannot handle the truth or when they know something in their life is bad so they keep it hidden from public view. Pisces is secretive when we are into stuff we know would embarrass us, like getting into bad habits like drugs, alcohol, porn and so forth.

Which water sign do you think is the most manipulative? Hmm, I am not very manipulative and I don't know too many Pisceans who are. I know Scorpios can be when they want a human puppet to obey them, they will start using language that basically gets the person to do things for them. Cancers can be like that too, and can even withhold love and affection toward a man if they don't get what they want which is very, very hurtful. My mother is a Cancer and she can be quite harsh with me if I don't agree or do as she wants. 😢

Which water sign do you think plays the most games? Definitely Cancer based on my experience. I know Pisces will play games when they are playing the field at a young age, but the whole concept of psychological warfare seems to be owned by Cancer and Scorpio. Pisces will simply go cold when we are hurt or upset by something serious from our lovers.

Which water sign do you think is most psychic/intuitive? I sense this is either Cancer or Pisces. I can sometimes channel a sixth sense whenever dealing with other people, by instantly observing, recording and analyzing non-verbal behavior. I am not easily fooled by anyone anymore if I can monitor their behavioral patterns.
Profile picture of ScorpioFish
ScorpioFish
@ScorpioFish
14 Years1,000+ PostsPisces

Comments: 5 · Posts: 4180 · Topics: 103
Oh, and to add to your board.

We should talk about who responds the worst when relationships go sour with these 3 signs.

Is it not true that Scorpios get revenge on their ex's, even if they are the ones that ended the relationship?

Also, Pisceans tend to go one of two ways? We either chase the person down and try to get them back, or we swim so far away that one wonders just where in the hell we disappeared to?

Same of Pisces can be said of Cancer?
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Posted by Este8
I think all water signs can be secretive. We tend not to want to reveal our emotions.

Which water sign do you think is the most secretive?

Which water sign do you think is the most manipulative?

Which water sign do you think plays the most games?

Which water sign do you think is most psychic/intuitive?



1. Without a doubt Pisces. About weird shit that no one cares about. It's funny as hell.

2. Cancer. Based on the cardinal power there is no way any other water sign can top this.

3. Scorpio. They need you to submit to their will so they can get a good grasp of who you are..they will play games to understand where you come from. I don't see them as controlling though.

4. None..from people I know in my life. Pisces Moons are incredibly intuitive IRL, also moon/trine neptune people.
Profile picture of Este8
Este8
@Este8
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 1355 · Topics: 6
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Pisces secretiveness cracks me up.

They don't mean anything by it...they mainly want to be left alone and not have people trying to figure them out.

If they think you are on a figuring out mission, they'll switch the script just because.

Cancers actually protect themselves with the secrecy...there is a purpose for their actions.

Pisces? Just because. Adorable peeps.
Profile picture of Este8
Este8
@Este8
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 1355 · Topics: 6
Posted by Damnata
Pisces secretiveness cracks me up.

They don't mean anything by it...they mainly want to be left alone and not have people trying to figure them out.

If they think you are on a figuring out mission, they'll switch the script just because.

Cancers actually protect themselves with the secrecy...there is a purpose for their actions.

Pisces? Just because. Adorable peeps.



YES Damnata! I agree. Pisces don't want you to think you've ever figured them out! While Pisces is mutable energy, I think there's a greater investment in them believing a) they can't be caged b) they can't be figured out and c) they are mysterious. It's a bit of an act, if you ask me. I've said it b4. Wanna be perceived as mysterious? Share less and listen more. Seriously. The less you reveal, the more you're perceived as mysterious. Pisces have this act down pat and are ready for their Oscars! I do love 'em tho. Very kind and loving energy. Generally, easier to take than crabby cancers. And those eyes man. Can get them into a lot of trouble!
Profile picture of Este8
Este8
@Este8
12 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 1355 · Topics: 6
Posted by LadyOfRebirth
Lol trust me I wish I could be secretive, or subtle or all of that other awesome stuff.. I'm mars dominant, everyone can read my face like a book lol😭😛



Well that's a better way to be Lady of Rebirth. My comments and observations are general and never apply to everyone. Besides, the natal chart shows the influences are more complex than merely our sun signs. It's mainly fun conversation starters for a slow Friday. And it's fun to think about the differences among water signs, which I know best.
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Este8..

Yeah, the best strategy is to stand there and look at someone..gazing lovingly or not. They will build a story in their minds from barely a word spoken. Our human propensity to weave stories..I luff stories.

Wish I could do that but I lack patience. I tried to be all mysterious and shit one evening and there was this guy doing his best to psych me up...I could barely contain my laughter with his analysis. He thought I was mute for half of the evening lol.
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Twirling one..do you agree with the statement on Scorpios as well?

I ask because I still don't have a clear image on that..it's what I gather from what I notice with my Scorpio gfs.

All 3 of them made me show my hand early on...before they ever started dropping personal info. I have no issue with that cuz I am open like a book. I probably never triggered any alarms in them.
Profile picture of CrabTwinsFish
CrabTwinsFish
@CrabTwinsFish
13 Years

Comments: 1 · Posts: 91 · Topics: 3
As a Cancer, I've always been upfront and direct ! ... no games here. I do HIGHLY understand the motives of people through their behavior and words, and can SMELL insincerity and alterior motives a thousand miles away ... and even further beyond that. I can't comment on my fellow Cancers thoughts but, (when significanty hurt by someone's spoken or written words) I tend to withdraw, and be angry for a long while, and won't expend alot of energy into addressing the conflict of the person who is obviously and outwardly WRONG and INCORRECT as I KNOW (intuition speaking here) they don't or may not understand circumstances ... and who really have NO interest in really knowing truth. My withdrawing on occasion, gets people really pissed off because I won't reply to, or accomodate their issues with a reply. I've got more important things in my life to take care of. That's our strength! I have no difficulty or trouble walking away, or saying a "goodbye." Case in point, people from my past years agp suddenly appear, and want to pick up where we left off .. my response ... stay well, and be happy. This is nonsense. I have Moon in Gemini so I can be real talkative in conversation with people I have mutual interests and understanding with, and like to see an equal and respective communication.
Profile picture of ScorpioFish
ScorpioFish
@ScorpioFish
14 Years1,000+ PostsPisces

Comments: 5 · Posts: 4180 · Topics: 103
Posted by CrabTwinsFish
As a Cancer, I've always been upfront and direct ! ... no games here. I do HIGHLY understand the motives of people through their behavior and words, and can SMELL insincerity and alterior motives a thousand miles away ... and even further beyond that. I can't comment on my fellow Cancers thoughts but, (when significanty hurt by someone's spoken or written words) I tend to withdraw, and be angry for a long while, and won't expend alot of energy into addressing the conflict of the person who is obviously and outwardly WRONG and INCORRECT as I KNOW (intuition speaking here) they don't or may not understand circumstances ... and who really have NO interest in really knowing truth. My withdrawing on occasion, gets people really pissed off because I won't reply to, or accomodate their issues with a reply. I've got more important things in my life to take care of. That's our strength! I have no difficulty or trouble walking away, or saying a "goodbye." Case in point, people from my past years agp suddenly appear, and want to pick up where we left off .. my response ... stay well, and be happy. This is nonsense. I have Moon in Gemini so I can be real talkative in conversation with people I have mutual interests and understanding with, and like to see an equal and respective communication.



What is the longest relationship you have ever had with a member of the opposite sex?