scorpio break-up

Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
my boyfriend (scorpio) of 3 years broke up with me (virgo) a couple days ago. it's been rough because we live together and haven't seperated completely yet. our relationship was great. we both agreed that it was the best we've ever had. it ended on really good terms. he told me he just wanted to be alone and didnt want to be in a relationship anymore so he could focus on himself. he struggles a lot with self-happiness. he comes from a dark place. throughout our relationship, he'd find himself back in this dark place that hes so used to being in. the result of that would be to push me away. to push away all the happiness he had been feeling cause hes used to having nothing. it took me a few times to understand and accept this about him and it took him a long time to open up and actually talk to me. i accepted, supported, and was there for him as best i could. so then about 3 weeks ago he said there was things he wanted to talk about but he needed some time, so i gave him time. he was more distant, wouldnt text me as music, was going out most nights. but when he was home, everything was normal. laughing, fooling around, and some nights we'd go for dinner or just hang out. and then he broke up with me because i told him i wanted to talk to him about a few things. and i feel like he just did it not even being 100% prepared. he couldnt say much other than he just needed be alone and hes not in a good place. he told me he loves me and that it wasnt anything i did and there was nothing bad about our relationship. he couldnt really say much which upset me cause it was this huge thing and he wouldnt talk to me about it. he was just full of anger. he said we'd talk tomorrow ans then he left and went out. [note: we live together] we ended up talking the day after we talked, and he was more calm. he still didnt really explain much, but i understood where he was coming from because we've been in situations like this before. i took a minute ans thought about it and decided to just let it go. i love us, but i love him more. and i wanted him to find happiness within himself even if it was about me. i was devestated, still am. but i wanted to keep myself together because i wanted us to end on a happy note. and im so glad we did. i realized after, that it wasnt just him who needed to be alone, but i did too. what im having a difficult time with now, is the post-breakup. i wasnt sure what i was expecting. i was glad we left everything on a good note. but hes just been super distant (understandable) but what hurts me the most is that he acts like he doesnt give a rats ass about me. and yes, deep down i know. hes told me. but its that feeling that i dont get and it fucking hurts. but this is just how he is and how he wants to deal with it. we love each other very deeply. i really think we're meant for each other. his best friend, who is also my friend, thinks that we just need a break and that he will come back. i have a feeling he will, but i dont know... [cont.]
Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
theres something inside me that tells me its not over for good. but its so hard to tell with him. does he just need space and time for himself? is there a chance a scorpio will come back? im not expecting it... but of course im open to it. he also said that hes open to it. but is he just saying that? hes just so good at hiding all of feelings. hes a very emotional person on the inside, i think im the only one whos actually seen that side of him. he really opened himself up to me when we were together. has anyone experienced anything similar or having any advice on how i should continue on? right now im just giving him his space. not really saying much unless he does. we live together so its difficult, but hes barely home now anyways. we are eventually both moving out but its gonna take some time. anyways... would love to hear anyones feedback.
Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
Posted by scorpx3
If it ended on good terms, and if he does truly believe your relationship was the best he's had, odds are he will come back. It's a matter of time. Let him learn to be happy on his own, and only then will he love you right.

In the meantime, do your own things and allow for your own growth. Things will fall into place themselves. I know it's hard (please trust me, I truly know how hard it is), but let go and let the Universe or God or whatever Higher Power you believe in, sort this thing out. It or He or Whoever brought you two together, you guys are going separate ways, who's to say you won't mend again in the future? Leave some room for something to happen, but don't forget to take care of your self first.
thank you for that! ❤
Profile picture of Gennie
Gennie
@Gennie
9 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 1780 · Topics: 6
I have something I want you to think about. It's entirely possible to fall into the pressure cave in and get back together prematurely, especially since you live together, but do you honestly want him to come back and have it be as it was? Because it seems to me, for it to work again, there needs to be a change in both of you, and that's not going to happen overnight.

This is the time to drill down into yourself and ask the big questions, what do you want in life? What about in a relationship? Where do you want to be in 3 years? Focus on yourself and work on being a better, wiser, more put together you. Go out with your girlfriends, camp out at a friends for a weekend and eat Ice Cream while watching Sex in the City or something. Separate your personal space from his that is surrounded by things that are distinctly you.

It's time to the drop the WE and go with the ME as selfish as that sounds, no one will ever treat you better than you can be to yourself. Start looking for a new place that reflects your vibe and most of all, be happy and dump any guilt.
Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
Posted by Gennie
I have something I want you to think about. It's entirely possible to fall into the pressure cave in and get back together prematurely, especially since you live together, but do you honestly want him to come back and have it be as it was? Because it seems to me, for it to work again, there needs to be a change in both of you, and that's not going to happen overnight.

This is the time to drill down into yourself and ask the big questions, what do you want in life? What about in a relationship? Where do you want to be in 3 years? Focus on yourself and work on being a better, wiser, more put together you. Go out with your girlfriends, camp out at a friends for a weekend and eat Ice Cream while watching Sex in the City or something. Separate your personal space from his that is surrounded by things that are distinctly you.

It's time to the drop the WE and go with the ME as selfish as that sounds, no one will ever treat you better than you can be to yourself. Start looking for a new place that reflects your vibe and most of all, be happy and dump any guilt.
I definitely wouldnt want us to get back together now or anytime soon. it's just one of those thoughts you get especially when it didnt end based on our relationship and just on him. i know that if we got back together so soon that it wouldnt work. we definitely both need a lot of time. i just don't really know his exact thoughts everything and me. now that we're broken up, he doesnt want to talk about anything like that. which is understandable. i think im just having a brutal time coping with everything. im trying to keep myself busy, watching some hilarious post-break up movies. i have a few things to look forward to for myself. theres just those moments of sadness when i wish i could just call him about something good that happened to me. thank you so much for your advice. let me know if you have any other thoughts.
Profile picture of Scorpioluver
Scorpioluver
@Scorpioluver
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 392 · Topics: 5
I understand how you are feeling. My ex Scorpio left me after 2 years, a couple of months ago. We had that deep connection bond that people only dream about. Anyway, he wasis in darkness with bouts of depression and general unhappiness. I truly respect him for ending things and I am giving him space. It will get better for you two and hopefully once he proves to himself that he deserves you and is good again, he'll be back. You're feeling the freeze and it comes across like that person doesn't care about you or you have been ghosted. The best for both is keeping busy and no matter how much you wanna contact him, don't. If you give him space to get mentally right, he will appreciate you for it.
Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
Posted by Scorpioluver
I understand how you are feeling. My ex Scorpio left me after 2 years, a couple of months ago. We had that deep connection bond that people only dream about. Anyway, he wasis in darkness with bouts of depression and general unhappiness. I truly respect him for ending things and I am giving him space. It will get better for you two and hopefully once he proves to himself that he deserves you and is good again, he'll be back. You're feeling the freeze and it comes across like that person doesn't care about you or you have been ghosted. The best for both is keeping busy and no matter how much you wanna contact him, don't. If you give him space to get mentally right, he will appreciate you for it.
ah exactly what im going through. he battles major depression and has so many demons. i understood that which is by i just let him go. i trust that he knows what he needs to so for himself. ive just been trying to keep myself busy. seeing friends, work, self-help books. how have you been coping? is it still hard for you?
Profile picture of Scorpioluver
Scorpioluver
@Scorpioluver
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 392 · Topics: 5
Posted by wedtk
Posted by Scorpioluver
I understand how you are feeling. My ex Scorpio left me after 2 years, a couple of months ago. We had that deep connection bond that people only dream about. Anyway, he wasis in darkness with bouts of depression and general unhappiness. I truly respect him for ending things and I am giving him space. It will get better for you two and hopefully once he proves to himself that he deserves you and is good again, he'll be back. You're feeling the freeze and it comes across like that person doesn't care about you or you have been ghosted. The best for both is keeping busy and no matter how much you wanna contact him, don't. If you give him space to get mentally right, he will appreciate you for it.
ah exactly what im going through. he battles major depression and has so many demons. i understood that which is by i just let him go. i trust that he knows what he needs to so for himself. ive just been trying to keep myself busy. seeing friends, work, self-help books. how have you been coping? is it still hard for you?
click to expand


It's been difficult, we spoke a couple of months ago and he asked for a bit of break before being friendly again. It broke my heart to see him so un happy but I'm respecting his need for quiet. It gets easier everyday, but I do miss him. I threw myself in to making me better by hitting the gym, getting a new career and being with friends. The worst is over as I've gotten used to the Scorpio freeze. Just know that he does love you even if feels like he doesn't.
Profile picture of wedtk
wedtk
@wedtk
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 18 · Topics: 4
Posted by Scorpioluver
Posted by wedtk
Posted by Scorpioluver
I understand how you are feeling. My ex Scorpio left me after 2 years, a couple of months ago. We had that deep connection bond that people only dream about. Anyway, he wasis in darkness with bouts of depression and general unhappiness. I truly respect him for ending things and I am giving him space. It will get better for you two and hopefully once he proves to himself that he deserves you and is good again, he'll be back. You're feeling the freeze and it comes across like that person doesn't care about you or you have been ghosted. The best for both is keeping busy and no matter how much you wanna contact him, don't. If you give him space to get mentally right, he will appreciate you for it.
ah exactly what im going through. he battles major depression and has so many demons. i understood that which is by i just let him go. i trust that he knows what he needs to so for himself. ive just been trying to keep myself busy. seeing friends, work, self-help books. how have you been coping? is it still hard for you?

It's been difficult, we spoke a couple of months ago and he asked for a bit of break before being friendly again. It broke my heart to see him so un happy but I'm respecting his need for quiet. It gets easier everyday, but I do miss him. I threw myself in to making me better by hitting the gym, getting a new career and being with friends. The worst is over as I've gotten used to the Scorpio freeze. Just know that he does love you even if feels like he doesn't.
click to expand

im glad you took the initiative to better yourself. i work out daily and had stopped when all of this happened. i havent really eaten. im slowly getting out of it. i actually just started a new job in the field i want, so things are looking up for me. its really just the missing him part and having to get used to him not being around anymore.. weve had talks when ive broken down about how he acts like he doesnt care. hes pretty cold but still tells me that hes chosing to act this way because it makes it less hard for him. and that hes not trying to hurt me by acting that way. i know he loves me... i just want to feel it. but i just have to accept the fact that we handle things differently. the only thing we can do is respect their wishes and hope they find happiness... we can really just focus on making ourselves happy now. im slowly but surely getting there. it is hard. you seem to be getting along good, keep it up.
Profile picture of lovely77
lovely77
@lovely77
10 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 1703 · Topics: 66
Posted by Gennie
I have something I want you to think about. It's entirely possible to fall into the pressure cave in and get back together prematurely, especially since you live together, but do you honestly want him to come back and have it be as it was? Because it seems to me, for it to work again, there needs to be a change in both of you, and that's not going to happen overnight.

This is the time to drill down into yourself and ask the big questions, what do you want in life? What about in a relationship? Where do you want to be in 3 years? Focus on yourself and work on being a better, wiser, more put together you. Go out with your girlfriends, camp out at a friends for a weekend and eat Ice Cream while watching Sex in the City or something. Separate your personal space from his that is surrounded by things that are distinctly you.

It's time to the drop the WE and go with the ME as selfish as that sounds, no one will ever treat you better than you can be to yourself. Start looking for a new place that reflects your vibe and most of all, be happy and dump any guilt.
Good advice
Profile picture of BrightLight
BrightLight
@BrightLight
10 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 306 · Topics: 3
Okay I'm going to come out and say this--if you are really, really the best relationship a Scorpio partner has ever had, then there is no way in hell your Scorpio is going to let that go. Scorpio lives for the mythic ultimate soul connection.

Sooooo....not saying you didn't have a great relationship and all. Not saying the feelings weren't real etc. What I am saying is that "something" was missing. Something undefinable wasn't connecting between the two of you that even though your Scorpio can't put into words, he's feeling it.

It's like he got to the insurmountable roadblock in your relationship. The realization that it wasn't "all." So rather than string you along, your Scorpio let you go.

This is the feeling I get from your OP
Profile picture of BrightLight
BrightLight
@BrightLight
10 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 306 · Topics: 3
Posted by Montgomery
"... and then he broke up with me because

i told him i wanted to talk to him about

a few things"



Smells like guilt.
That's what I got as well. I wouldn't doubt this Scorpio hasn't felt another connection with someone else that has caused him to realize Virgo here is not the one. The break up was too out of the blue. And that "dark place" talk? Nope. Sorry. Scorpio can go dark, but we need our lovers around for support. It's part of the loyalty deal we require. So all this dark place talk is BS. He just wanted out.
Profile picture of Chelsey07
sunflowers&curls
@Chelsey07
9 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 4 · Posts: 586 · Topics: 22
Posted by BrightLight
Posted by Montgomery
"... and then he broke up with me because

i told him i wanted to talk to him about

a few things"



Smells like guilt.
That's what I got as well. I wouldn't doubt this Scorpio hasn't felt another connection with someone else that has caused him to realize Virgo here is not the one. The break up was too out of the blue. And that "dark place" talk? Nope. Sorry. Scorpio can go dark, but we need our lovers around for support. It's part of the loyalty deal we require. So all this dark place talk is BS. He just wanted out.
click to expand

I was thinking the same thing. That was sprinkled in there to soften the blow. I didn't want to be the first person to say this because I didn't want to sound like Debbie-downer, but it sounds like he met someone else or was probably cheating for the past few weeks or months of the relationship. The breakup was too quick and seriously out of the blue.