Earth Signs=Pure Evil?

This topic was created in the Astrology forum by Yama on Saturday, December 23, 2006 and has 58 replies.

Are Earth Signs Associated with Negative Traits

There is no scientific evidence linking earth signs to negative behavior. Astrology suggests earth signs are practical and dependable. The idea that they are inherently evil is a misconception and lacks factual basis.

You are on page out of 2 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of vfacullo
@vfacullo
19 Years

I think it's funny how you titled this thread
"EARTH SIGNS= PURE EVILS?"
Oh then every earth sign people have potential to be like them?
I don't think so.

That's just like saying:
"All blondes are stupid."
"White people can't rap or dance."
"You are wearing black so you must be depressed."
yadiyadiyada and so on...

If you looked at their whole chart and then
came up with that conclusion,
maybe... but just Sun signs?...

Profile picture of wheelhomies
@wheelhomies
20 Years10,000+ Posts

"?"

is that a "watchyu crazy bitch (i don't have a lot of saturn influence)?" or a "watchyu crazy bitch (that has nothing to do with earth signs being evil)?" or maychance a combination of the two?

Profile picture of wheelhomies
@wheelhomies
20 Years10,000+ Posts

"Can you clarify the meaning of "a lot of saturn influence"?"

weeeell i dunno charlie but i can certainly try.

..umm yeah pretty much having capricorn placements, or planets in the tenth house.

Profile picture of wheelhomies
@wheelhomies
20 Years10,000+ Posts

capricorn is ruled by saturn, what's the problem? lol

umm yeah i'm a leo with my moon in aquarius yet i have no influence from the sun or URANUS. hahaha

"Oh, and I only used four "i". Lern2mimic."

that wasn't even worth pointing out. *brushes shoulder off*

Profile picture of wheelhomies
@wheelhomies
20 Years10,000+ Posts

"Because saturn != Capricorn."

i have no idea what "!=" means but that's ok because i think i can sorta figure it out. unfortunately you're wrong, dear, because saturn = capricorn in much the way pluto used to = scorpio before its planetary status was nixed (haha at the loser with no ruling planet, except for the fact that my sun sign's supposedly ruled by a star but it's big and shiny so that counts for something). of course it doesn't directly =, but, in the end, it does =.

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

According to wiki saturn is the main ruler of Aquarius, along with Urnaus.

From the article-"Saturn () is the ruling planet of Capricorn and Aquarius, unlike some stoopid boarders would have you believe(you know who you are!)"

Profile picture of wheelhomies
@wheelhomies
20 Years10,000+ Posts

but let's just say for a quick sec, you and i, that saturn is the primary ruler of aquarius (although it most def isn't), who cares? i'm still right about you having a lot of saturn influence.

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"but let's just say for a quick sec, you and i, that saturn is the primary ruler of aquarius"

Who said it was the primary ruler of Aquarius? Straw-man, much?

"i'm still right about you having a lot of saturn influence."

No, I have a lot of Capricorn influence. There's a difference, y'know.

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"thanks for that link, you succeeded in proving absolutely nothing. "

Ditto.๐Ÿ™‚

"and nope, there's not a difference, saturn + capricorn, it's like communism + exploitation."

Ah, but there can be exploitation without communism, correct?

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"lol (at you, not me), your senses fail you . because i was referring to the (lack of) relation you brought up, not my own."

I just contradicted you, and you agreed.

So nyah.

"which in the end means the same thing"

Why?

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

There are rare times when not coming up with a comeback is better. This is one of those times.

This is not only a failure of humor, and of originality, but a failure of reason as well.

Profile picture of agent006
@agent006
20 Years500+ PostsVirgo

Yama: "Saturn influence=planets in Capricorn..?"

i'm with you Yama, i don't think saturn influence equals planets in capricorn. i tend to look saturn influences as aspects that INVOLVE saturn, like sun/moon/etc. conjunct/trine/etc saturn. planets in capricorn just indicates the way you express or utilize those planets' energies (in cap would mean you express them in a cap fashion, not exactly a saturnine fashion). but this just my opinion.

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"Lol just from this statement i can tell you are jealous "

Why are you offering your opinion on this matter? No offense Kris, but you're a joke.

"They are many scorps who despeartely wish they were aquas no i am not lieing "

Focus Kris, we are talking about earth signs here.๐Ÿ˜›

"Says the kid who doesn't even know what a logical fallacy is."

"One of the most common non-rational appeals is an argumentum ad hominem--or, as the Latin phrase suggests, an "argument against the person" (and not against the ideas he or she is presenting). Our decisions should be based on a rational evaluation of the arguments with which we are presented, not on an emotional reaction to the person or persons making that argument. But because we often react more strongly to personalities than to the sometimes abstract and complex arguments they are making, ad hominem appeals are often very effective with someone who is not thinking critically. Consider a few examples:.

* A political candidate is gaining support by proposing a tax change. So her opponent argues that the candidate herself would be one of the chief beneficiaries of that tax change.
* Your doctor tells you to lose some weight. But why should you listen to a doctor who is himself overweight?
* A friend has recommended a new investment opportunity, but your significant other rejects the recommendation with the remark, 'How could you possibly value the advice of that idiot?'"

Their words, not mine.๐Ÿ˜›

"Everything. Esp. logic. "

Yeah, mental powerhouses such as Rainingpeanutz, Qbone and yourself.๐Ÿ˜›

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"Well i am sorry but i thought anyone can post their opinions on a public message board but i must be wrong now"

It seems you are confused,(yet again) I didn't say you can't, I inquired about your reason.

And as for the rest of your post...It doesn't even merit an actual reply.

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"Yama you are in no postion to comment on intelligence ,a few weeks back you could barely type anything without a million grammitcal mistakes . Lets us see your report card then tell me what college you get into then we will let you speak ."

Ah, so, student=smart?

I guess George Bush must be a bona fide genius then, since studied at Harvard and all.๐Ÿ™‚

Oh and "grammtical mistakes"? lol

Profile picture of Yama
@Yama
20 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

"I could care less if you reply or not you are just some kid please don,t buy into the whole scorpion bullshit because then you will be stupider in my eyes ."

Oh noes, I will be stupider in your eyes??

First
Previous
Next
Last