Elemental Energies

In general, same element Sun signs seem to play well together - how does this play out for other personal planets. Can this be a detriment, or, given that energies are from the same elemental source, a favorable interactive pairing for each planet in the same element? How would this play out if all personal planets were in the same element, yet different signs?

Intuitively I think this makes sense that there would be compatibility on all levels, but I thought I would throw it out there.

Here are the charts

Person A

PLANETARY POSITIONS
planet sign degree
Sun Capricorn 17??52'28 in house 8
Moon Gemini 15??34'54 in house 12
Mercury Sagittarius 27??50'21 in house 7
Venus Sagittarius 1??36'16 in house 6
Mars Scorpio 21??00'08 in house 6
Jupiter Scorpio 29??01'34 in house 6
Saturn Taurus 15??46'08 in house 12
Uranus Libra 13??31'21 in house 5
Neptune Sagittarius 2??13'38 in house 6
Pluto Virgo 29??41'40 in house 5
True Node Aquarius 24??08'23 end of house 9
Planets at the end of a house are interpreted in the next house.

HOUSE POSITIONS (Placidus)
Ascendant Gemini 21??32'13
2nd House Cancer 11??59'36
3rd House Leo 2??08'51
Imum Coeli Leo 25??54'20
5th House Virgo 27??41'36
6th House Scorpio 9??39'43
Descendant Sagittarius 21??32'13
8th House Capricorn 11??59'36
9th House Aquarius 2??08'51
Medium Coeli Aquarius 25??54'20
11th House Pisces 27??41'36
12th House Taurus 9??39'43

Person B

PLANETARY POSITIONS
planet sign degree
Sun Taurus 8??16'32 in house 11
Moon Gemini 8??25'12 in house 12
Mercury Aries 18??59'41 in house 10
Venus Aries 23??33'02 in house 10
Mars Pisces 20??15'58 in house 10
Jupiter Capricorn 3??30'18 in house 6
Saturn Capricorn 18??25'42 in house 7
Uranus Leo 16??56'17 in house 2
Neptune Scorpio 7??45'39 in house 5
Pluto Virgo 3??39'20 in house 3
True Node Virgo 23??44'33 in house 4

HOUSE POSITIONS (Placidus)
Ascendant Cancer 10??43'54
2nd House Leo 0??33'20
3rd House Leo 22??37'15
Imum Coeli Virgo 20??11'41
5th House Libra 25??39'03
6th House Sagittarius 5??27'53
Descendant Capricorn 10??43'54
8th House Aquarius 0??33'20
9th House Aquarius 22??37'15
Medium Coeli Pisces 20??11'41
11th House Aries 25??39'03
12th House Gemini 5??27'53

Although love may be expressed differently, wouldn't this be offset by the conjunct moons, both being Gemini and both being in the 12th? Wouldn't they have a general understanding of the other's form of emotional expression overall?

As for Venus square Pluto, on who's part would love be unrequited.

Synastry is not something I'm all that familiar with - trying.

Other aspects could offset the Venus - Pluto aspect, yes?

Person A's Sun resides in Person B's 7th which, from my understanding, if I read correctly, would create a deep sense fatedness perceived by Person B. Person B has expressed in absolute terms their intense perception of this to the extent that they described Person A as 'perfect' for them in every way.

Or is there something else in the chart that suggests this?

What about the fire/water mars combo of each. Person A is the woman.

Composite is kinda a mess with a lot of hard aspects.

Composite Horoscope midpoint method

PLANETARY POSITIONS
planet sign degree
Sun Pisces 13??04'30 in house 10
Moon Gemini 12??00'03 in house 12
Mercury Aquarius 23??25'01 in house 9
Venus Aquarius 12??34'39 in house 9
Mars Capricorn 20??38'03 end of house 7
Jupiter Sagittarius 16??15'56 in house 6
Saturn Pisces 17??05'55 in house 10
Uranus Virgo 15??13'49 in house 4
Neptune Scorpio 19??59'38 in house 5
Pluto Virgo 16??40'30 in house 4
True Node Sagittarius 8??56'28 in house 6
Planets at the end of a house are interpreted in the next house.

HOUSE POSITIONS (Placidus)
Ascendant Cancer 1??08'03
2nd House Cancer 21??16'28
3rd House Leo 12??23'03
Imum Coeli Virgo 8??03'00
5th House Libra 11??40'19
6th House Scorpio 22??33'48
Descendant Capricorn 1??08'03
8th House Capricorn 21??16'28
9th House Aquarius 12??23'03
Medium Coeli Pisces 8??03'00
11th House Aries 11??40'19
12th House Taurus 22??33'48

So, in trying to understand synastry better - which is the point of my thread...

Person B says that they are not looking for a relationship at this time. Albeit acknowledges a deep connection to/with Person A (as I mentioned, considers Person A 'perfect' on many levels - Sun 7th house, right?). Person A does feel she has quite the understanding of Person B as well and some innate attraction/connection that transcends the physical (WHY?). In addition, Person B has indicated that he does not want to see Person A with anyone else and suggested that she wait until he is ready (WHERE DOES THIS COME FROM? Aries Venus and...?). Person A isn't necessarily looking for a relationship either, but not one to wait in the wings (Sag Venus?). They are not having, nor have they ever had, sex, so this is not a factor.

I've noted some placements I think would explain some of this, what other aspects do you think are involved that could connect the dots?

Posted by Jynja
I'm sorry, it's not an Aquarius stellium, but the Aquarius planets being in aspect to the moon make them quite strong in a love relationship.

Please explain, and in relation to Mars Scorp...

In the end, what is it in their charts that draws these two people together so intensely? (not referring to the sexual) Both feel it, as if fated. (and maybe, wrong place, wrong time).