Pisces/Scorpio match... brilliant or terrible?

So, I'm the Pisces with a bucket chart:
Moon in Aquarius, Taurus rising (yeah THERE's a fun combo)
Mercury - Pisces, Venus - Capricorn, Mars - Taurus, Jupiter - Pisces, Saturn & Uranus in Sagittarius, Neptune in Capricorn, Pluto in Scorpio, node in Aries.

And he's the Scorpio with Moon and Ascendant Virgo, Mercury and Venus in Scorpio, Mars in Aquarius, Jupiter - Pisces, Saturn & Uranus in Sagittarius, Neptune in Capricorn, Pluto in Scorpio, node in Aries. (We're only four months apart in age, so all our outer planets are still in the same signs.)

Deep emotional AND sexual attraction (very rare for me, it's usually one or the other). Lots of History, lots of past drama, lots of electrifying tension. BDSM elements apply to our interaction/balance, him Dom, me sub.


So how self-destructive is this going to be? I always fall for the broody, darkly passionate Scorps. But usually they don't fall for me in return. Thoughts, commentary, laughing at me... bring it!

Can you add degrees to all your and his planets?

Or post your dates if you are comfortable

Feb 26, 1987, 9.17 AM in Chicago
October 28th, 1986, approx. 2-4 AM also in Chicago area

From what I've seen of him, that Scorpio/Virgo/Virgo makes for an incredible sort of refined, elegant ego-showoff that makes a Leo look like a dancing clown. I myself have a huge mental dichotomy where that pisces/aquarius split is concerned - very emotional but also exceedingly logical, often in paradox. And my taurus rising mostly just means I am stupidly stubborn about pretty much everything.

Here's my chart

And here's his (I put him at 3AM 'cause that's about the closest he knows)