Help me guess my crushes sign

The user who posted this message has hidden it.

Scorp
Or Pisces
Or crappie.

So there's a guy, there's a vibe. I dig him ya'll. Help me guess his sign. Lets put in some bets. Ask me some questions and we can figure it out. AKA help

Things I know:
Quirky off beat sense of humor- sometimes surprisingly crass (bc he seems kinda sweet/innocent)
Chill. Unbothered by others moods. Just chill.
Goes with the flow, but seems to be an innovator.
I would dub him introverted, as he is kinda mysterious and you cant find much about him online other than his music. Def. not an attention whore -comfortable with silence, but can carry a convo...
Very mysterious.
Has a checkered past. (also surprising)
Forward thinking.
Seems gentlemanly.
Always wears a tie- but casually not like a businessman but kinda 90s chic.

Any ideas?

Cappie*

I was thinking maybe a slightly bitter cancer
Hopefully not a scorp I don't get that vibe though.
I don't think a pisces bc i am NEVER attracted to Pisces...

I was kinda hung on Aqua, Cancer, or Libra
But I'm honestly pretty stumped
He's very quirky

EW if he was a capricorn id just kill myself i swear.

Posted by underwaterthing
EW if he was a capricorn id just kill myself i swear.

I feel you on the Capricorn thing. Does he have an air of superiority about him? Is he arrogant? Does he love money?

Maybe a libra

Posted by underwaterthing
I was thinking maybe a slightly bitter cancer
Hopefully not a scorp I don't get that vibe though.
I don't think a pisces bc i am NEVER attracted to Pisces...

I was kinda hung on Aqua, Cancer, or Libra
But I'm honestly pretty stumped
He's very quirky

Scorpios are known for being mysterious. And you mentioned that quite a few times.

All the cancers I've known have had big mouths and go on and on and on about shit, so I doubt it.

Could be Pisces

Hmmmm

He's hard to pin down. But I'd say he's just chill, but hard to read, and I'm a good reader. 🙂
Lets put it this way, we communicate mostly through cat memes at this point LOL

But he did check to make sure I got home ok last night (sweet) and said sweet dreams (very sweet)
Then this morning he texted a pic of him in the flower crown I made him last night while we were sitting and talking in the grass.
It was pretty hilarious.

He's definitely very different.

Posted by LibWman

Posted by underwaterthing
EW if he was a capricorn id just kill myself i swear.

I feel you on the Capricorn thing. Does he have an air of superiority about him? Is he arrogant? Does he love money?

Maybe a libra

click to expand

I didnt get any of those off of him. That all sounds very capricorn.
He's very passionate about his music and has his own business running and is struggling bc of it. Very dedicated, but I started to see his feels (negative) come out when discussing all that.

I can also say definitely not a taurus. I know their bs too well..

Pisces?

Posted by Shashka

Posted by RumiL
Pisces?

Maybe.

Or Virgo with a water moon like Pisces or cancer.

click to expand

You know I initially thought it could be Virgo with Libra/cancer influence too :p ...virgo with Pisces moon...yes!

Dear god, he is a Scorpio. Pray for me. I'm making my will now..

Posted by LibWman

Posted by underwaterthing
I was thinking maybe a slightly bitter cancer
Hopefully not a scorp I don't get that vibe though.
I don't think a pisces bc i am NEVER attracted to Pisces...

I was kinda hung on Aqua, Cancer, or Libra
But I'm honestly pretty stumped
He's very quirky

Scorpios are known for being mysterious. And you mentioned that quite a few times.

All the cancers I've known have had big mouths and go on and on and on about shit, so I doubt it.

Could be Pisces

click to expand

Posted by underwaterthing

Posted by LibWman

Posted by underwaterthing
I was thinking maybe a slightly bitter cancer
Hopefully not a scorp I don't get that vibe though.
I don't think a pisces bc i am NEVER attracted to Pisces...

I was kinda hung on Aqua, Cancer, or Libra
But I'm honestly pretty stumped
He's very quirky

Scorpios are known for being mysterious. And you mentioned that quite a few times.

All the cancers I've known have had big mouths and go on and on and on about shit, so I doubt it.

Could be Pisces

U win

click to expand

Yay.
What do I get?

All my possessions after he kills me!