Earth Sign Boyfriend...Who do you choose?

If you could only choose a man all other qualities equal, without knowing the rest of his chart, simply based on the fact he is a Virgo, Capricorn or Taurus. Which one would you choose and why?

No, just wondering the general consensus.

Virgos-I like the males because they are sensitive and genuine and they don't let the softer sides of them determine their masculinity. hard workers too.

Taurus-I like how hilarious they are and the have a sensitive side as well. with them you are bound to have a good time, and the softer sides are not as easily shown as with a virgo, so pushing that out of them is always fun and heartwarming.

Capricorn-Funny guys, very charming and although they are probably the most stubborn with showing their sensitivity, if they care they really care. great supporters and wonderful providers.

So, really, it's hard to say. Sorry I couldn't answer your question lol.

Toss up between Virgo and Taurus.

Taureans and I have always gotten along best (they rank as the # 1 sign that I tend to befriend the most) and I've always been attracted to them. However, the passion wanes quickly and I often view them as mere friends after getting to know them better.

Virgos are a little different. I rarely meet one that I am even remotely sexually attracted to, but when I do, look out! It's all passion and heated moments. Heavy lusting infused with romance. There is some crazy chemistry when I find one to say the least. So weird. They're a bit more sensitive in love matters and they seem to feel deeply. Overall, though, I like their style . They're often very intelligent, yet not pretentious (

I've only been with a taurus really. Went on a date with a virgo, and am friends with one. I only know one capricorn and he seems pretty cool and a lot people seem to like them.

I have a lot of taurus in my life, but they tend to rub me the wrong way. I'm a sag btw.
I enjoy the company of my virgo friends, but they complain alot -.-

So I guess for the sake of picking on I like the cap

I'd pick Capricorn. Yes, they can be a little pessimistic, boring & too serious sometimes, but Capricorns are very loyal & they don't seem to mind my Aqua nature. They're not as initimidated as Taurus & Virgo are. Caps don't try to compete with me or make me change.

Virgos are great friends, but in terms of relationships..no, I'm cool on them. They always have something to say. They can never take things at face value. They make everything complicated with their complex views/mindsets. They pick apart everything & can be quite manipulative. They have a problem when it comes to how to pick one's battles. Virgos need someone they can intellectually control or dominate & Aqua is the LAST person for that job lol. Although I love that Virgos are more action-oriented people (they let their actions speak for them), I still like to end up with someone who doesn't have such a problem verbalizing their feelings. Virgos seem to have a problem doing that.

Taurus is cool too, BUT they're a little to selfish, stubborn, routine & stuck in their ways for me. Aqua & Taurus tick completely the opposite. And alot of the ways we differ are actually deal breakers, atleast to me. They can be downright mean and/or moody if they don't get their way. They can get "deep/intellectual" with me but not as deep as some other signs can like Gems, Libras, Sagg's, Scorps. Taurus likes to run the show & for their companions to tick like they do. Welp, there's only 1 problem. Aquas are the same way. Taurus & Aqua will either totally get along great OR completely NOT stand eachother at all.

Really feeling this Taurus guy right now. We've always hit it off, they are funny and witty. Fast on their feet. Street smart, I like that. Chemistry's good and they are sooo sweet.

Virgos are cool, but I can't help but feel there's some sort of agenda with them. You could call it selfish, you could call it not verbalizing their intentions. They also kind of slip through your fingers, it's the mercurial essence.

Caps are mad cool. I love kicking it with them and hanging out. Very solid, charming and open people. They do their own thing and respect that you do yours. I admire their critical eye for perfection.

I can't say who I'd choose since I haven't romantically linked with a Capricorn, so either Taurus or Cap. It's TBD.

I would say Virgo, and Cappy next. I have always had good relationship with virgo almost perfectly actually no problems but there was always distant or something to prevent the relationship. The best relationship I have ever had in my 32 years of living was with a cappy guy that I am still friends with till this day.

@LoveBucket could have been, he live in NY and me in Chicago, I went to go visit him in NY and I had a blast also he came to visit me but he wanted me to move to NY but NY is to dirty for me I dont like it. I am sure he had someone out there we were not even together sexually until I visit him and I had knew him for 9 months before I went to visit we basically had met twice then had phone convo. My Leo friend is currently dating a virgo and he seems like that guy you are talking about he wants an open relationship while he strings the leo on it's crazy the things she tells me he does and the funny thing he has also tried to talk to my cousin who is a cappy but I dont want to tell the Leo since she had feelings for the Virgo and also she will be so PISS.

Capricorn......closely followed by Taurus. Get on great with Virgo's but just don't see myself with one romantically.

Posted by 69virgo
Have capri son....Taurus son...virgo son...right now i'll have to choose the goat...seems to care a lil more about his girl...

Aww, that's cute. Three earth sign sons lol!!

Caps are a bit exhausting during the courting stage! Once you are in a committed relationship with one, you will have one of the most loyal guys in town! At least that's my personal observation.

Oh my, no question, give me the VIRGO. I generally tend to clash with Taurus men; never really liked them, only a sexual attraction with a few. I have never been attracted to a Capricorn, and I know quite a few. Some I don't care for and others I would never look at as anything more than a friend. I have always been drawn to Virgos. They have this pull on me that I can't fight, and I love it.

Capricorn men seem drawn to me, and I enjoy the reward of their trust after having the patience to earn it. They are very intelligent but also too temperamental for me.

Virgos are sweet, kind and ambitious. Yet, they are also sensitive, very difficult to read and have a completely different way of communicating than I do.

Taureans and I usually get along so well. We share similar creative tastes and the same strange sense of humor. They can become stubborn over such trivial things, yet I appreciate that they're upfront with their feelings and willing to call me out on my crap.

Overall, as much as I like my current Virgo boyfriend, from past experience alone, I'd have to choose a Taurus.

Virgo please.

Just realized I've dated a capricorn, but it was an online relationship. Even so in the relationship I felt very suffocated, almost trapped and wanted out. Anyone else feel that with a cap?

LOL @ Cap not being an option to most. For me its either Virgo or Taurus but I lean more towards Virgo. Taurus are family oriented mild men. I need just a little something more than that though just a little.

Caps all the way. And maybe Virgos. But not Taurus. Not Taurus! Never again!

Can we just admit that virgo is the best and move on already

I just couldn't date an earth guy. There is nothing wrong with them and there's nothing wrong with me, I just already know from hanging with earth friends that it would be a HUGE personality clash.

Posted by PandorasBox

Posted by virgoking
Can we just admit that virgo is the best and move on already

Lol.. And what would you say makes you Virgo boys so special? ")

click to expand

well everything duh were have you been look at the ladies in here and count how many say virgos there is a reason people go crazy over us. You will just have to find out if your not scared :b