@cookiem0nster
12 Years
Guess my placements
Can You Guess Someone's Astrology Placements Without Their Birth Details
Astrology placements are determined by exact birth date, time, and location. Without this information, it is impossible to accurately guess someone's placements or validate astrology's effectiveness. Astrology relies on precise data to interpret celestial influences on personality and life events.
You are on page out of 2 | Reverse Order
Sun sign incorrect and, what are the odds of there being a leo placement? Quite high I'm guessing
Astrology doesn't work.
You sure taught all us ignorant fools a lesson we'll never forget.
You can leave now.
No rational debate yet?
Anyone born around late August is supposed to be rational so they say here
Is family important to you? Yes
Is money? Yes
How about friends? Yes
What is your outlook on the world? There are lots of people in it.
Do you prefer a woman for her looks or for her personality? Either
Are you more emotional or rational? Neither
How empathetic are you? Very
Do you philosophize alot? No
Do you think you're smarter then everyone else? No
How do you feel about the poor? "The poor" is a very broad definition
Whose your favorite, your mother or father? Mother
What career field are you pursuing? Science
Do you prefer going out all the time or staying home? Depend on my mood
Do you like playing online games? How often? No, never
What kind of movies do you watch? Drama & Sci-fi
Posted by LadyOfRebirth
Are you even going to tell what your zodiac sign is if someone guesses it correct?
If someone gets over half my placements right I will conclude there is something to astrology, and let you know what the rest are.
Do you think with your HEAD or HEART? Head
When two people come to you with a problem, how do you find solutions for it? Draw on experience or ask someone that knows more than me
Do people find you indecisive? No
Are you look at as a leader? In some situations
Do you prefer working behind the scenes or in front? In front
Are you overly talkative? no
Do you tell lies all the time? no
Are you intuitive? yes
Can you tell what to say and how to say it when the timing is right? yes
Do you manipulate situations to your own ends? no
How would your friends and loved one's describe you? broad shouldered
Are you an introvert or extrovert? extrovert
The problem with this game is that participants are set up to fail.
Any specific astrological combination only occurs, at most, one time for roughly two days every 25,000 years or so. Given that the angular relations between planets augment how they function with one another and birth time and location will affect how they present themselves in one's personality, placements alone don't cut it. I won't even get into transits. Someone might be able to get a few right with blind guesses but would otherwise have to be a human supercomputer to really get any kind of true accuracy.
And your statement about late August persons supposedly being rational is faulty. Assuming you're speaking of Virgo that also extends into September, and there are two "logic" signs. The other is Aquarius.
What's more important to you? Family or Money? Family
What's more important to you? Being a productive citizen who does very well on their job or making Money? Being a productive citizen
Do you like to EAT ALOT? Are you a FOODIE? No
Does looking good matter to you? Only when it matters
Do you like to go shopping? No
When you think about a WIFE, what traits are you looking for? I don't think about a WIFE
Any specific astrological combination only occurs, at most, one time for roughly two days every 25,000 years or so. Given that the angular relations between planets augment how they function with one another and birth time and location will affect how they present themselves in one's personality, placements alone don't cut it. I won't even get into transits. Someone might be able to get a few right with blind guesses but would otherwise have to be a human supercomputer to really get any kind of true accuracy.
So you can't work backwards from traits, only forwards from birthdate and time? How do you then prove that it works?
And your statement about late August persons supposedly being rational is faulty.
Why? Are late August persons not deemed rational in Astrology?
Leo moon
Cancer Sun
How about a Girlfriend, what traits are you looking for in a woman?
Intelligent, kind, motivated
Posted by Montgomery
Leo moonidiot i already claimed the leo placements...so fuk off.
click to expand
No, you didn't.
Nice try, though.
Aries sun with virgo moon
How about a Girlfriend, what traits are you looking for in a woman?
Intelligent, kind, motivated
Do you often feel misunderstood?
Even persecuted?
Do you often feel misunderstood?
Even persecuted?
No, never
Posted by cookiem0nster
Do you often feel misunderstood?Even persecuted?
No, never
Do you ever feel like you're the only one who knows what is *really* going on?
Do you ever feel like you're the only one who knows what is *really* going on?
No. But sometimes I feel like I'm the only one who doesn't know what's going on
Posted by Andalusia
Cancer Sun
Posted by Montgomery
Leo moonclick to expand
Are you going to tell us when one of the placements is correct?
Sun: Cancer
Moon: Virgo or Pisces
Merc: idk.. Gemini, Cancer, or Leo
Venus: Gemini
So you can't work backwards from traits, only forwards from birthdate and time? How do you then prove that it works?
Simple one line answers offered in text via the internet are hardly "traits". Were one to present a real personality for observation it might be done by an experienced astrologer, but would still be educated guesswork.
As for proof, there isn't any. Astrology can be likened to therapeutic psychology in that it is largely subjective and based on observation rather than empirical data. It is something that has been in practice for thousands of years with traits and quirks being documented and interpreted by observing persons. Something that was done by breaking each component into simple forms.
Every Virgo will have their Sun in one of thirty degrees on the wheel, but not every Virgo will have that Sun placed within ten degrees of their Mars or in proximity to a neighboring sign. All details must be examined on their own before it can be determined how each piece fits together to make a whole.
Why? Are late August persons not deemed rational in Astrology?
click to expand
Nice sidestep. Notice though that I said your statement was faulty, not necessarily wrong. And as I have been explaining, just because a person belongs to a certain sign does not mean they will behave as every other person of the same sign. Sun sign alone means little to nothing.
So which regular DXP user are you?
Are you going to tell us when one of the placements is correct?
I will give out my chart at some point. Too early and it spoils the fun.
i have yet to meet a rational virgo, logical yes, rational no.
ra??tion??al
/??raSH??nl,??raSHn??l/
adjective
adjective: rational
1.
based on or in accordance with reason or logic.
Simple one line answers offered in text via the internet are hardly "traits". Were one to present a real personality for observation it might be done by an experienced astrologer, but would still be educated guesswork.
So you are suggesting one line answers via the internet cannot give suitable insight into someone's personality? Have you not just debunked the entire well founded research field of personality evaluations in the field of psychology in one sweeping statement?
Astrology can be likened to therapeutic psychology in that it is largely subjective and based on observation rather than empirical data
===
Observation of what?
So you are suggesting one line answers via the internet cannot give suitable insight into someone's personality? Have you not just debunked the entire well founded research field of personality evaluations in the field of psychology in one sweeping statement?
Psychology was around long before the internet. And most extensive evaluations are conducted in person.
You're sidestepping again. You also didn't answer my last question.
So you are suggesting one line answers via the internet cannot give suitable insight into someone's personality? Have you not just debunked the entire well founded research field of personality evaluations in the field of psychology in one sweeping statement?
Psychology was around long before the internet. And most extensive evaluations are conducted in person.
click to expand
Yes, psychology was around long before the internet, and?
Most extensive evaluations are conducted in person. Does this mean they can't be conducted as extensively over the internet? Think about this one and don't sidestep. I'm only answering questions which are relevant to this discussion
Posted by cookiem0nster
I'm only answering questions which are relevant to this discussion
Posted by cookiem0nster
Ask me anything apart from my birthdate and I will answerclick to expand
Does that mean you're no longer playing by your own rules then?
douche with a side of bag
there is my guess of a game no one will win! lol
Posted by cookiem0nster
I'm only answering questions which are relevant to this discussionPosted by cookiem0nster
Ask me anything apart from my birthdate and I will answerDoes that mean you're no longer playing by your own rules then?
click to expand
You're basically asking for my chart. I think it goes with the territory that I'm not going to answer.
Sun sign is Virgo
More guesses and I'll carry on
You're basically asking for my chart. I think it goes with the territory that I'm not going to answer.
I didn't ask for your chart. I didn't ask for a birthdate.
I asked for a name. 😄
I have an idea who you are though anyway.
Virgo? Gahd dammit.
Aqua moon
Posted by CluelessCancer
Montgomery your a bytch a lying one at that, i said he had leo placements for sure, he agreed, then you said leo moon.go to hell bytch. back to block
Great.
Then they'll be no more objections from you.
Posted by TwirlingStrawberry
sag moon
virgo merc
leo venus
Taurus mars
lol. Perfect
Wow Clueless, I think you must be sherlock holmes
I do not have a capricorn moon and a libra mercury
Neither
here, have a cookie
BAHAHA This has been a fun read, I was thinking Virgo from page one, then I was thinking capi o sag moon and you confirmed it too!
I'm guessing a leo in Venus
blueeyes got both the sag moon and venus leo right
mercury not in aquarius no
Posted by cookiem0nster
Wow Clueless, I think you must be sherlock holmesWait, really? That has to be sarcasm. Right? GAH I DONT DO WELL WITH NOT KNOWING.
click to expand
This is funny.
Ahh hell, you have a Leo Venus too?! Well fuck.
Libra Mercury and Gemini Mars
Ah. Thanks, I missed that 🙂
Want to keep conversations like this alive?
dxpnet has hosted real conversations like this since 2000. If you value independent communities, you can support the site below.
Every contribution helps keep dxpnet independent and ad-light.
Join the Conversation. Explore Yourself. Connect with Others.
Discover insights, swap stories, and find people. dxpnet is where experiences turn into understanding.
Create Your Free Account →
Ask me anything apart from my birthdate and I will answer
If you can't guess my placements from those answers then I will conclude that astrology doesn't work
Defend your existence dxpnet