Gemini or Cancer for a Capricorn?

**I just realized I should have posted this here earlier*

I'll make this simple.

Which is a better match. Girl 1 or Girl 2.

ME:
Sun: Capricorn
Moon: Libra
Venus: Capricorn
Mars: Scorpio

GIRL 1:
Sun: Gemini
Moon: Taurus
Venus: Cancer
Mars: Capricorn

GIRL 2:
Sun: Cancer
Moon: Gemini
Venus: Cancer
Mars: Leo (but I guess has some aspect that modifies her Mars to be more like Mars in Scorpio?)

SHOOT.

Well both have Venus in Cancer so I can see why you're attracted to both, however I pick the Cancer because both of you have Air sign moons.

I see.

The cancer has a Scorpio Rising (she told me).
I actually don't know my rising at the moment, I'm still trying to find my time of birth (birth certificate).

I'm VERY attracted to her, for a long time. I'm curious...is there some synergy going on between her Scorpio Rising and my Scorpio Mars?

Neither

Posted by CreatingChaos505
I see.

The cancer has a Scorpio Rising (she told me).
I actually don't know my rising at the moment, I'm still trying to find my time of birth (birth certificate).

I'm VERY attracted to her, for a long time. I'm curious...is there some synergy going on between her Scorpio Rising and my Scorpio Mars?

If you are VERY attracted to the Cancer, why not just go for her in the first place?
Are you actively dating either right now.