Is scorpio the most reasonable & rational water sign?

I know they are still nutty like the rest of their water sign cousins, but do you think they are more realistic than the other 2?

There's a fine line between scorpio realism and paranoia.

I mean some of the realism stems from common sense and paranoia but is actually beneficial, but some isn't because it's from coockoo land where the worst option rules.

So ratio's are important, knowing the history of the person, how many right calls they made and how many was just "fearmongering" due to insecurities, bias, experience of this and that kind.....

I'd like to say yes being a Scorpio.... but it could go many ways. I feel it depends on how evolved the person is. I've never really seen a truly evolved Pisces (that's going by having them as family and friends)... but I Have seen many awesome cancers, albeit they are VERY emotional.

Scorpio's can be nasty creatures but there's a few of us who has moved past those kind of actions and are pretty dang wonderful people.

I don't know about reasonable, but they definitely deal with the real world far better (on average) than Pisces and Cancers.

I know some Scorp-dominant people (with no Earth whatsoever) who are very responsible and practical, which is rare for anyone without much/any Earth...you don't see that with other Water/Fire/Air signs who lack any Earth grounding.

They’re not. If it were not for Pisces, Scorpio would take the prize for having the biggest delusions.

We feel things and go with our intuition, whether it is rational to others or not. We can't go against intuition because we mess up when we do. It goes beyond the mind and body.

And we're not nutty. You just don't see what we see, therefore you don't fully understand why we act like we do.