Exhalted planets are excuted better than by Sign Rulers. What's your opinion? (See reference below

Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
The Sun

Rulership in Leo, exaltation in Aries, detriment in Aquarius, fall in Libra.

The Moon

Rulership in Cancer, exaltation in Taurus, detriment in Capricorn, fall in Scorpio.

Mercury

Rulership in Gemini and Virgo, exaltation in Virgo too, detriment in Sagittarius and Pisces, fall in Pisces too.

Venus

Rulership in Taurus and Libra, exaltation in Pisces, detriment in Scorpio and Aries, fall in Virgo.

Mars

Rulership in Aries and Scorpio, exaltation in Capricorn, detriment in Libra and Taurus, fall in Cancer.

Jupiter

Rulership in Sagittarius and Pisces, exaltation in Cancer, detriment in Gemini and Virgo, fall in Capricorn.

Saturn

Rulership in Capricorn and Aquarius, exaltation in Libra, detriment in Cancer and Leo, fall in Aries.

Uranus

Rulership in Aquarius, exaltation in Scorpio, detriment in Leo, fall in Taurus.

Neptune

Rulership in Pisces, exaltation in Leo (or in Cancer, depending on authors), detriment in Virgo, fall in Aquarius (or in Capricorn, depending on authors).

Pluto

Rulership in Scorpio, exaltation in Aries (or in Pisces, depending on authors), detriment in Taurus, fall in Libra (or in Virgo, depending on authors).

https://www.astrotheme.com/astrology_planetary-rulerships.php

(Note - Carl Payne Tobey wrote some articles on these rulerships, especially Pluto in Aries if interested in researching yourselves)
Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
Posted by Lilianni
I personally like the exalted planets. I don't think many people could hate a Taurus moon's personality (they're very calm and you can just be calm with them). Mars in Capricorn is great at managing their drive (and are Oh so sexy). Saturn in Libra makes people work together and compromise for the greater good of a goal.
Couldn't agree more about those planets you mentioned and especially my experience with the Mars in Capricorn. I just wasn't ready to be anyone's step baby mama.
Profile picture of Lilianni
Lilianni
@Lilianni
10 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 609 · Posts: 1982 · Topics: 53
Posted by Shinzo
Posted by Lilianni
I personally like the exalted planets. I don't think many people could hate a Taurus moon's personality (they're very calm and you can just be calm with them). Mars in Capricorn is great at managing their drive (and are Oh so sexy). Saturn in Libra makes people work together and compromise for the greater good of a goal.
Couldn't agree more about those planets you mentioned and especially my experience with the Mars in Capricorn. I just wasn't ready to be anyone's step baby mama.
click to expand

Oh yeah that's asking for a lot from you.
Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
Posted by tiziani
It depends on if they're aspected to the actual ruler of the sign they sit in imo.
Very possible to fulfil with more ease but I still find those with exhalted planets use it properly even without having any aspect to the natural ruler.

I do notice however that challenging aspects like Pluto opposite Taurus Moon or Venus in Pisces square Saturn takes a lot of maturity and evolving put into practice before reaching a certain time in their life to accomplish.

Could be said for anyone but they just have that magic that I can't put a finger on but you just can't help but see that growth.
Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
Posted by GlaringTruth
Posted by Shinzo
Posted by GlaringTruth
What are the odds a Libra (two planets in fall) or one of the signs with no exaltation at all making this thread? Lol... Of course it would be an Aries to make such a thread. Blowing smoke up your own ass.
Of course, that's what I'm doing... You seem so pathetic, I'll just leave you to it darling
Because I'm not as excited as you? Seems like that exaltation is working wonders for you giving you supreme judgment and perception. Right.....
click to expand

Just so you know, I don't converse with idiots if that's all you do in here. I actually come here to chat about astrology. So you might want to take your stupid rants elsewhere. Blocking you now.... toodles 😉
Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by Shinzo
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by tiziani
It depends on if they're aspected to the actual ruler of the sign they sit in imo.
Can you give us examples?


I think what Tiziani might mean (correct me if I'm wrong) is that the Sun in Aries for example placed in the 5th house or Venus in Pisces is sextile Taurus Sun etc.
Oh.. I get that perfect placements for the signs. But I don't think I'm following you on venus is pisces sextile taurus. Is pisces sextile taurus?

Sextile is signs within range, right? As in virgo, libra, scorp and sag. Or am i wrong?
click to expand

Sextile is 60 degree range between signs (56 - 64 degree range maximum in a natal chart). So for example, if my Venus is at 15 degrees Pisces, it would be sextile a 17 degrees Sun placement in Taurus.

Trines (120 degree) and Sextiles (60 degree) are carried out easily (sometimes too easily to the point of being lazy)
Profile picture of Shinzo
Shinzo
@Shinzo
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 396 · Topics: 18
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by Shinzo
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by Shinzo
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by tiziani
It depends on if they're aspected to the actual ruler of the sign they sit in imo.
Can you give us examples?


I think what Tiziani might mean (correct me if I'm wrong) is that the Sun in Aries for example placed in the 5th house or Venus in Pisces is sextile Taurus Sun etc.
Oh.. I get that perfect placements for the signs. But I don't think I'm following you on venus is pisces sextile taurus. Is pisces sextile taurus?

Sextile is signs within range, right? As in virgo, libra, scorp and sag. Or am i wrong?
Sextile is 60 degree range between signs (56 - 64 degree range maximum in a natal chart). So for example, if my Venus is at 15 degrees Pisces, it would be sextile a 17 degrees Sun placement in Taurus.

Trines (120 degree) and Sextiles (60 degree) are carried out easily (sometimes too easily to the point of being lazy)
Oh. Okay. So say that

Planet A is at 4 deg

Planet B is at 37 deg

A - B = sextile (within range of 1 - 60 deg?)

Planet A is at 59 deg

Asteroid A is 0 deg

Planet A - Asteroid A = sextile

Oh gawd by going back through learning this, i just learned that.... My dejanira is a sign of my asc!!

Holy mother of hell.

Someone's nessus is in 1st house and my dejanira is in 1st and we're communicating to each other... He digressed tho!! So that prolly a good thing!

??

Oh no! Nonononono

click to expand

I'm not going all the way into asteroids to be honest with you. This is purely about planets and I don't know what system you use but the Circular charts I deal with have 30 degrees for each signs and nothing beyond.

I don't know what level of astrology you're on at the moment but I can't really start explaining aspects, sorry (just got a couple of things going on at the moment). You're on the right track though. Thanks for your input.
Profile picture of AerialView
AerialView
@AerialView
8 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 1255 · Posts: 12836 · Topics: 26
Posted by tiziani
If you were an Aries Sun in 5th with no aspects to Sun, that energy would be kept by your Sun.



But if it were conjunct any slower planet in Aries then it's a different story (for example Saturn conjunct Sun both in Aries) then you would have a far more Saturnian approach to that 5th house of their life.
i still don't get it. probably because i have nothing in aries.
Profile picture of AerialView
AerialView
@AerialView
8 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 1255 · Posts: 12836 · Topics: 26
Posted by tiziani
Posted by AerialView
Posted by tiziani
If you were an Aries Sun in 5th with no aspects to Sun, that energy would be kept by your Sun.



But if it were conjunct any slower planet in Aries then it's a different story (for example Saturn conjunct Sun both in Aries) then you would have a far more Saturnian approach to that 5th house of their life.
i still don't get it. probably because i have nothing in aries.
It's just an example, but I'm just saying aspects change the meaning (my 2 cents).
click to expand

should have use venus in pisces as your example 😛
Profile picture of rabidtalker
RabidTalker
@rabidtalker
14 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 746 · Posts: 5608 · Topics: 190
Posted by tiziani
Posted by AneemA08
Posted by tiziani
It depends on if they're aspected to the actual ruler of the sign they sit in imo.
Can you give us examples?


For example if someone has a Saturn in Aries then whatever part of their life Saturn sits in may collect energy from their Sun part of their chart (Sun being exalted in Aries) but only if their Sun aspects their Saturn. If there is no aspect there then that energy is kept in the Sun area of their chart.



click to expand

Wouldnt this happen regardless of signs involved? It's just explaining what an aspect is?
Profile picture of bricklemark
bricklemark
@bricklemark
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 76 · Posts: 6208 · Topics: 230
Of course, but rulership is good too, also the other signs of the same element work well, and l use only the squares as dignities.

Example Mars =Aries ruler, one square before, Capricorn =exalted. One square after(Cancer) =fall.

Sun =Leo ruler. One square before Taurus=exalted. One square after(Scorpio) =fall.

Taurus people are exalted because it's their chance to shine, they admire Leo a lot, Taurus Sun people seem really happy, satisfied with life. George Clooney, Uma Thurman, David Boreanaz, the dude in my pro pic.

Also Sag and Leo Mars work well. Scorp or Pisces Moon also. Jupiter Aries and Leo.