Which sign is the better match for a Scorpio ....

Pisces or Cancer? and Why?

Neither in my experience. Pisces too emotional. Cancers waaaayyyy tooo clingy (no air to breath ever!!!)

However, my chart is full of fire and air, so that might make a difference.

It depends on whether you want a passionate short-term romance or a long-term stable partnership. The former belongs to Pisces. The latter is better suited to Cancer.

I love Pisces. They are so sweet and kind. Their ideals and visions for romanticism make them absolutely adorable and loveable. My ex was a Pisces, and I still adore her. But they will break your heart for the simple reason that you can never have all of them. And when it comes time to facing challenges and trying to build a life together, Pisces' dreaminess will frustrate Scorpio to no end.

Cancer seems more grounded. Unlike the floating fish, they are well grounded around family in a practical sense.

Given where I am in my life now, I would prefer Cancer moving forward since I'm looking for the latter.

May I suggest a virgo or gemini.

"On paper it looks good because all 3 signs are water signs but in reality Pisces and Cancer are not strong enough to take on a Scorp."

I agree....

***Look at the glyps, both used to be one sign and look at what the purpose of the Libran scales is (yes you guessed right, one for the virgo and the other one for the scorpio)***

Librapersonified, came up with this same scenario on the libra board awhile back. Interesting.

Why do many sources say that Pisces and Cancer is Scorpio best match?

For instance Pisces are sensitive and weak, and the Scorpio is sensitive and strong.

I agree that Scorp and Pisces/Cancer arent a good match! We all need more contrasts. We "get" each other, us water signs...on a very deep level, but we arent good for each other on a relationship level. Thats what I think.

Capricorns are good, any earth sign is pretty good--also personally, I love Aquarians and Leos too. (being fixed)

"For instance Pisces are sensitive and weak, and the Scorpio is sensitive and strong"

On the contrary, compassion can be a bigger strength.

Pisces and Cancer are the best match for a Scorpio.

"Pisces and Cancer are not strong enough to take on a Scorp."

Taurusbabe, I can't speak for the fish people but why you gotta rip on us crabs like that?? Saying we aren't strong enough means you're calling us weak..

Sure Shaka...make sure to put a restrainign order on notso first 😛

I suggested virgo and gemini b/c:

I didnt want to suggest water...b/c I agree they arent strong enough.
I didnt want to suggest fire because there too strong.
Earth was next best thing o match emotion, strength, and wit...I feel its just right.
I felt the need to suggest air for some odd reason...not aqua, b/c its hard to deal with a scorp personally. Libras are too soft for them...hell even for me, but I got a mars in Aries. I feel gem would be up for it...but I think they'd drive the scorp crazy as oppose to the other way around 😛

From what I know scorps and earth signs don't last in a serious long term relationship. I also think the best way to stabilize scorps is constant sex and total devotion.. which we cancers can provide on a daily basis. I think you've just been meeting the wrong cancers.

While this will of course be argued, here's what I think: we cancers are survivors and we'll outwit and outlast the rest of you.. 😉

Oh and if it's sugar.. it'd be SGR not SRG

I know of 2 taurus - scorp couples and neither are still together. In fact, I don't think they even talk any more and in both cases, it was the scorp that initiated the conflict.

You're right though, these things are relative.. but it's no fun just saying that everything's relative.

Don't mind my BS, it's my cocky, arrogant leo side.. 😉

Taurusbabe, what 2 emotionally intense people are you talking about?

It is an opinion on the matter -- shouldn't we be asking the scorps themselves who they prefer?

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA!

Scorpio are one of the most powerful sign so to call them weak is absurd. Scorpio always one to be in control and dominate because it a security not that they are weak. They can not fall in love with someone without being the dominate one or have some type of power.

The man has a point. But I do also think people with Virgo rising can be a little annoying. They seem unable to admit emotion. That, to me, is pretty weak.

I'll exclude deivil and Roxi for sake of piece.

Man, weren't you subtler once?

Move along folk, nothing to see here but repetitive Scorpio-baiting.

"If I am Scorp baiting, it will work. Scorps are so full of themselves, and so emotionally unstable, they'll fall for it hook, line and sinker"

OMG YOU ARE SOOOO LUCKY I DONT SEE YOU IN REALLY LIFE CUZ ILL USE MY INVINCIBLE SCORPIO POWERS ON YOU AND WE WILL SEE WHO IS FULL OF WHOM!!!!!11177

Satisfied now?

branh Scorpio is one of the most interesting sign. Virgo are the least discussed sign in zodiac. However, they are usually discussed in length in how much people hate then or love them. For example, you spend time talking about how much you dislike them. I disagree that a Scorpio would want to be a Virgo.

yeah right.

@bran You are very immature. lol

OMFG off topic.

Bran.. lucky bastard you were with a taurus.. but please guys lets stop acting gay and try to stay on topic.

@ Roxi lol

Actually i'm a bit curious too.. I like ze bull girlies.

"what are you doing here?"

Changing the subject of this thread from Scorpios to himself.

Lets see some pics and then get back on topic.. that way there'll be some meaning to this offtopic flame war.

I would just like to say that no one should ever talk shit to bran again.. the man has some taste in women..

"But they will break your heart for the simple reason that you can never have all of them."

I think Pisces is the better match. Pisces is the sign of idealism and love. A True Pisces in True love wants nothing, "more"; but to give ALL of themselves..'you can have ALL of them'..'forever.' ..and more. (as well, i think whole chart comes into play, as people are multi-dimensional..'just look for a more earthy (grounded) kind of fish.. 'good luck ..

I saw it's a toss up cancer - pisces or cancer - scorp even though I personally prefer can - scorp. Certainly it's better than taurus - scorp. Don't hate ladies.. 😉

Well, if it isn't the oldest damn thread in the history of DXP...

Ive seen older.

I understand why people pick on brahn on a playful level but why be so rude?

I agree with branh.

BranH is the man.

Some people remember how rude and outrageous brahn has been on other threads, this is probably why they pick on him.

He seems a lot calmer now.

Improvement is much better than past, to me. I remember him from over a year ago now and he has improved.

It's 1am here, Nyx... Shut up.

Nyx, I'm only kidding. Come back.

hola!

Damnit.

Haha... Just want you to myself for a little while.

I'm so tired but have to stay awake for atleast another hour.

What makes you think I'm posessive?

*Locks Nyx's special Scorpius cuffs*

Well, SOOOORRY!

I shall not encroach any longer.

I can't even talk straight. I don't know if I said a joke or just got horny.