Cancerian ex gf confusing HELP

This topic was created in the Cancer forum by leonineguy on Monday, October 26, 2015 and has 5 replies.

Profile picture of leonineguy
@leonineguy
11 Years

I got iced out by this Cancerian ex and she kept ignoring me so I thought I would play my last card. I thought making Cancerian girls really emotional will trigger something. I wrote a long heartwarming emotional letter and told her that this would be the last time I will contact her. I was not trying to manipulate her or anything coz I meant what I wrote.
Lo and behold she calls me for the first time after breakup and we talk for 3 hours. In the end I asked her where are we going with this? She said that we are just "talking" and she also mentioned that it is okay if we talk and she will call me in a few weeks. She also said that she is scared she will look like a fool if she gives me another chance and I hurt her again. However she also tells me we cant be friends but it is okay to talk. So what do u guys think? Is she interested in giving another chance or I am just overthinking this?

Profile picture of Lindaaaatje
@Lindaaaatje
11 Years

Posted by leonineguy
I got iced out by this Cancerian ex and she kept ignoring me so I thought I would play my last card. I thought making Cancerian girls really emotional will trigger something. I wrote a long heartwarming emotional letter and told her that this would be the last time I will contact her. I was not trying to manipulate her or anything coz I meant what I wrote.
Lo and behold she calls me for the first time after breakup and we talk for 3 hours. In the end I asked her where are we going with this? She said that we are just "talking" and she also mentioned that it is okay if we talk and she will call me in a few weeks. She also said that she is scared she will look like a fool if she gives me another chance and I hurt her again. However she also tells me we cant be friends but it is okay to talk. So what do u guys think? Is she interested in giving another chance or I am just overthinking this?

What was the reason of the break up?

Profile picture of leonineguy
@leonineguy
11 Years

I broke up with her coz we fought too many times. When we loved each other, it felt so deep but when we were worse then we couldnt stand each other

Profile picture of GalOnTheCusp
@GalOnTheCusp
11 Years

Call me crazy but I'm an Aqua/Pisces cusp and if you broke up with me and then waited to hear from me... it'd be a long ass time that you'd wait.

Then you write to her, tell her it's the last time you'll contact her... you finally get her to talk on the phone and then you ask her where it's going!! (Too much too soon is my point.)

I think she meant exactly what she said. She only wants to talk, she doesn't want to think about getting back together or even necessarily seeing you any time soon. Just get back to square one.

She's upset, hurt and her pride is wounded. If you want this to go anywhere positive, do what she's suggesting, or risk her cutting you off.

Profile picture of crabbykaycee
@crabbykaycee
11 Years

Cancerians don't usually like making the first move. We're all different though considering we have other signs traits. She's probably just hurt and needs time to think about if she wants to go through the pain of breaking up and fighting again. Us cancers will give chance after chance to those we love but when we get fed up and are done, there's no going back.