Pisces man break up - will he come back?

Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
My ex (Pisces sun, Aquarius moon, Capricorn Venus) broke up with me very recently after dating for 2 years. We were very much in love and had a wonderful beautiful relationship unlike anything else we’ve ever known. We had been talking about marriage and kids with each other since we first met. We did fight quite a lot throughout the relationship, typically over misunderstandings, though things improved a lot over the course of the relationship and we were clearly moving in the right direction. There were several near-breakups in the past, on both ends, but we always ended up deciding to stay together and work things through and ended up happier for it. Recently however he called things off between us and it seems much more serious this time. He’s been unhappy recently over a few things, like feeling he doesn’t have enough freedom to live the life he wants/fear that time is passing by and he’s going to end up with regrets, and that I don’t respect his boundaries when he says no to things. We both have fault in most of our issues, but often fail to properly communicate and understand each other’s side of it. He told me that he feels depressed when he thinks about having a marriage and kids and future with me or really anyone and that he’s been depressed lately and feels like he’s settling for less, although in the past he’s often told me that he doesn’t deserve me and that I’m so good to him and that he needs me. He said he just wants to be single and doesn’t know how to explain it. Another thing he said is that because he’s accomplished so much in his life lately and has gained a lot of momentum, he really wants to keep going and doesn’t want this relationship holding him back, even though he wouldn’t have gotten here in the first place without me. We were really good for each other and pushed and motivated one another to be better people and improve ourselves and our lives, but now he’s just jumping ship to try to have something better. He’s the type who’s pretty flaky and changes his mind a lot, so I don’t really know what’s going to happen. There was a whole sequence of events that sort of led up to this; we’ve been living apart long distance for about 4 months now and I’ve been trying to move back to be with him (though he doesn’t want to live together, so I think that caused him some stress), and I recently stayed with him at his parents house during the holidays for 2 weeks which was a lot for him because he needs a lot of space to recharge and wasn’t getting it. The full moon and eclipse was yesterday, so emotions have been high. He ghosted me for a day after the break up, and then texted me very early the next morning to tell me that that was the first day since we met where we didn’t talk at all. Later he said that it’s so hard to be away from me even though he knows that this is what’s right for us. I asked him why he texted me to say these things and he said he didn’t know and that he had wanted to delete the messages once he sent them but didn’t want to confuse me further. He hasn’t told his family or friends yet. I’m moving back in a week to be near him (it’s too late for me to back out of the move). Do you think that he’ll come back? I really do believe deep down in my heart that he’s the one and that we’re meant to be together. I have a strong feeling that he wants to be together and is just scared, but I’m scared too that I might lose the love of my life forever. Thanks for reading all this, any advice is appreciated.
Profile picture of MikeNYNYC
MikeNYNYC
@MikeNYNYC
7 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 84 · Posts: 875 · Topics: 6
Posted by piscetauro123

My ex (Pisces sun, Aquarius moon, Capricorn Venus) broke up with me very recently after dating for 2 years. We were very much in love and had a wonderful beautiful relationship unlike anything else we’ve ever known. We had been talking about marriage and kids with each other since we first met. We did fight quite a lot throughout the relationship, typically over misunderstandings, though things improved a lot over the course of the relationship and we were clearly moving in the right direction. There were several near-breakups in the past, on both ends, but we always ended up deciding to stay together and work things through and ended up happier for it. Recently however he called things off between us and it seems much more serious this time. He’s been unhappy recently over a few things, like feeling he doesn’t have enough freedom to live the life he wants/fear that time is passing by and he’s going to end up with regrets, and that I don’t respect his boundaries when he says no to things. We both have fault in most of our issues, but often fail to properly communicate and understand each other’s side of it. He told me that he feels depressed when he thinks about having a marriage and kids and future with me or really anyone and that he’s been depressed lately and feels like he’s settling for less, although in the past he’s often told me that he doesn’t deserve me and that I’m so good to him and that he needs me. He said he just wants to be single and doesn’t know how to explain it. Another thing he said is that because he’s accomplished so much in his life lately and has gained a lot of momentum, he really wants to keep going and doesn’t want this relationship holding him back, even though he wouldn’t have gotten here in the first place without me. We were really good for each other and pushed and motivated one another to be better people and improve ourselves and our lives, but now he’s just jumping ship to try to have something better. He’s the type who’s pretty flaky and changes his mind a lot, so I don’t really know what’s going to happen. There was a whole sequence of events that sort of led up to this; we’ve been living apart long distance for about 4 months now and I’ve been trying to move back to be with him (though he doesn’t want to live together, so I think that caused him some stress), and I recently stayed with him at his parents house during the holidays for 2 weeks which was a lot for him because he needs a lot of space to recharge and wasn’t getting it. The full moon and eclipse was yesterday, so emotions have been high. He ghosted me for a day after the break up, and then texted me very early the next morning to tell me that that was the first day since we met where we didn’t talk at all. Later he said that it’s so hard to be away from me even though he knows that this is what’s right for us. I asked him why he texted me to say these things and he said he didn’t know and that he had wanted to delete the messages once he sent them but didn’t want to confuse me further. He hasn’t told his family or friends yet. I’m moving back in a week to be near him (it’s too late for me to back out of the move). Do you think that he’ll come back? I really do believe deep down in my heart that he’s the one and that we’re meant to be together. I have a strong feeling that he wants to be together and is just scared, but I’m scared too that I might lose the love of my life forever. Thanks for reading all this, any advice is appreciated.

Profile picture of MikeNYNYC
MikeNYNYC
@MikeNYNYC
7 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 84 · Posts: 875 · Topics: 6
Posted by MikeNYNYC
Posted by piscetauro123

My ex (Pisces sun, Aquarius moon, Capricorn Venus) broke up with me very recently after dating for 2 years. We were very much in love and had a wonderful beautiful relationship unlike anything else we’ve ever known. We had been talking about marriage and kids with each other since we first met. We did fight quite a lot throughout the relationship, typically over misunderstandings, though things improved a lot over the course of the relationship and we were clearly moving in the right direction. There were several near-breakups in the past, on both ends, but we always ended up deciding to stay together and work things through and ended up happier for it. Recently however he called things off between us and it seems much more serious this time. He’s been unhappy recently over a few things, like feeling he doesn’t have enough freedom to live the life he wants/fear that time is passing by and he’s going to end up with regrets, and that I don’t respect his boundaries when he says no to things. We both have fault in most of our issues, but often fail to properly communicate and understand each other’s side of it. He told me that he feels depressed when he thinks about having a marriage and kids and future with me or really anyone and that he’s been depressed lately and feels like he’s settling for less, although in the past he’s often told me that he doesn’t deserve me and that I’m so good to him and that he needs me. He said he just wants to be single and doesn’t know how to explain it. Another thing he said is that because he’s accomplished so much in his life lately and has gained a lot of momentum, he really wants to keep going and doesn’t want this relationship holding him back, even though he wouldn’t have gotten here in the first place without me. We were really good for each other and pushed and motivated one another to be better people and improve ourselves and our lives, but now he’s just jumping ship to try to have something better. He’s the type who’s pretty flaky and changes his mind a lot, so I don’t really know what’s going to happen. There was a whole sequence of events that sort of led up to this; we’ve been living apart long distance for about 4 months now and I’ve been trying to move back to be with him (though he doesn’t want to live together, so I think that caused him some stress), and I recently stayed with him at his parents house during the holidays for 2 weeks which was a lot for him because he needs a lot of space to recharge and wasn’t getting it. The full moon and eclipse was yesterday, so emotions have been high. He ghosted me for a day after the break up, and then texted me very early the next morning to tell me that that was the first day since we met where we didn’t talk at all. Later he said that it’s so hard to be away from me even though he knows that this is what’s right for us. I asked him why he texted me to say these things and he said he didn’t know and that he had wanted to delete the messages once he sent them but didn’t want to confuse me further. He hasn’t told his family or friends yet. I’m moving back in a week to be near him (it’s too late for me to back out of the move). Do you think that he’ll come back? I really do believe deep down in my heart that he’s the one and that we’re meant to be together. I have a strong feeling that he wants to be together and is just scared, but I’m scared too that I might lose the love of my life forever. Thanks for reading all this, any advice is appreciated.

click to expand



What is the day, month and year of both your birthdays?
Profile picture of sweetpea2977
sweetpea2977
@sweetpea2977
6 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 2 · Posts: 1548 · Topics: 27
This sounds exhausting. Breakup, makeup. Breakup, makeup. What a vicious cycle, to say the least. It may even be codependency based.

I think that you should believe him when he says that "he feels depressed when he thinks about having a marriage and kids and future with me". It's really not your job to decipher what you THINK he means but for you to RECEIVE THE MESSAGE as it's spoken, so that you can make better decisions for YOURSELF.

Just based on this, "He’s been unhappy recently over a few things, like feeling he doesn’t have enough freedom to live the life he wants/fear that time is passing by and he’s going to end up with regrets, and that I don’t respect his boundaries when he says no to things." and having read your perspective, I can believe it possible, that you don't get what he's truly saying to you. Almost like you're in denial.

You may not be able to "back out" from this move but you better give that man some space if you want to have any chance of "getting him back." That's real talk right there, so please stay open to my advice. The last thing you would want this "depressed", "unhappy", confused man to do, is to resent you. He's crying out for space. Give it to him.

It's my hope that in 2020 all of this damned 'struggle love' will end. #wishfulthinking Sheesh.
Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Look at what you wrote here, saying ‘we had a wonderful beautiful relationship’ and ‘were very much in love’. But then go on to say he is depressed and stifled by the relationship. That there have been many arguments and breakups over the 2 year period. Plus the fact he ended things...

Seems like your perception on things is not his perception of things.

Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by piscetauro123

He’s been unhappy recently over a few things, like feeling he doesn’t have enough freedom to live the life he wants/fear that time is passing by and he’s going to end up with regrets, and that I don’t respect his boundaries when he says no to things.

He said he just wants to be single and doesn’t know how to explain it.

I have a strong feeling that he wants to be together and is just scared


You are falling into old patterns. He tells you point blank he wants to be single, that you disrespect him by not taking no for an answer.

And here you are in your feels rationalizing that he still wants a relationship and is just scared.



Your best bet if you want him back is to honor what he wants and distance yourself. Let him miss you and, if he really is just scared or commitment, come to that realization on his own.

Personally I don’t see it happening. He had space and distance from you with you living abroad. It was only AFTER you spent the holidays with him that he broke things off and decided he prefers his freedom.
Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
I should clarify that this is the only time he’s ever said he’s depressed because of the relationship and there have been a lot of other factors contributing to his depression/he also tends to blame his feelings on me a lot and then come around later and say that I didn’t actually cause anything he was feeling.

I do agree that I should give him a lot of space. I agreed with him when he said that this is right for us and I haven’t been talking to him at all/don’t intend to unless he reaches out. Thank you for the advice!
Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
He really is super scared of commitment sometimes... keyword sometimes. Sometimes he talks about how excited he is to have kids and what they’re gonna look like and sometimes he says he wouldn’t be able to take a job offer in Cuba if he’s in a relationship, and I ask him why he would be offered a job in Cuba and he says “I don’t know! But if I did, I couldn’t take it!” Lol. He stresses out a lot about the future and time passing by in his life. But he also really loves companionship and the stability of always having one person there through everything. I don’t think he really knows how to balance any of it
Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
Posted by CancerAquaSagg

Why do you speak in his name ?

"My ex (Pisces sun, Aquarius moon, Capricorn Venus) broke up with me very recently after dating for 2 years. We were very much in love and had a wonderful beautiful relationship unlike anything else we’ve ever known"

That's kinda insane lol

Seems like the Pisces is suffocating. Sorry.


I am not assuming anything he thinks or feels, only stating things that he has expressed to me
Profile picture of virgal_perfectionist
virgal_perfectionist
@virgal_perfectionist
7 Years

Comments: 2 · Posts: 235 · Topics: 11
I would ask myself if I would want someone like that back in my life? Sometimes it's not the actual person we want back its the memories or the idea of him.

But...

If he came back, how do you know when he gets all insecure again that he won't up and leave you a second time? It would be like walking on eggshells and who wants to be in a relationship like that?

Honestly, I think he did you a favor. Move on to a man who really wants a relationship and considers your feelings. He's the one that walked out of your life so don't go chasing him.
Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
He called me tonight! He apologized and cried a lot and we talked about how much we’ve missed each other. He said he couldn’t hold his feelings inside anymore. He’s still not entirely sure what he wants and said he needs more time but that his heart knows he wants to be with me. He said we’ve got a lot to talk about before we consider potentially getting back together but that he really wants to talk about all of it. I think it was a huge weight off our chest for both of us
Profile picture of Chessmess
Chessmess
@Chessmess
6 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 69 · Posts: 641 · Topics: 14
Posted by CancerAquaSagg

Why do you speak in his name ?

"My ex (Pisces sun, Aquarius moon, Capricorn Venus) broke up with me very recently after dating for 2 years. We were very much in love and had a wonderful beautiful relationship unlike anything else we’ve ever known"

That's kinda insane lol

Seems like the Pisces is suffocating. Sorry.


We don’t know the insights and perhaps she’s repeating what they have spoke in private.

Makes perfect sense. I mean, why make assumptions ?

Profile picture of Adreamuponwaking
Adreamuponwaking
@Adreamuponwaking
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 2650 · Posts: 6434 · Topics: 214
Posted by piscetauro123

I should clarify that this is the only time he’s ever said he’s depressed because of the relationship and there have been a lot of other factors contributing to his depression/he also tends to blame his feelings on me a lot and then come around later and say that I didn’t actually cause anything he was feeling.

I do agree that I should give him a lot of space. I agreed with him when he said that this is right for us and I haven’t been talking to him at all/don’t intend to unless he reaches out. Thank you for the advice!


he sounds pretty immature and immature men make the worst husbands.

those are the dudes that mess around until their 40s and 50s and then want to settle down because they don't want to die alone......

they don't make the best dads...and usually are habitual cheaters.

get with a guy who is ready for the long haul and wants the same things as you.

you can find one with a similar or even most likely a better connection since you want the same things
Profile picture of piscetauro123
piscetauro123
@piscetauro123
5 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 9 · Topics: 1
Posted by Sassysailorscout

Thats great !!

What did he say ?


We decided to go out for coffee one day and we talked things over and decided that we both want to be together. He said that despite things going well in his life, he just wasn't happy underneath it all without me in his life, and I felt the same way. Things were a little weird/detached at first, but we slowly eased back into it. We decided to start over new instead of just continuing our old relationship. It's been about a month now and things have never been better. We haven't gotten into a single argument, we communicate so much better, he has a greater desire to see me more often and I've become much more independent and have worked on my own life. The break up was honestly really good for us, it gave us a lot of space and perspective to really think about things and understand ourselves and each other. We both have much more confidence in the relationship now.
Profile picture of sweetpea2977
sweetpea2977
@sweetpea2977
6 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 2 · Posts: 1548 · Topics: 27
Posted by piscetauro123
Posted by Sassysailorscout

Thats great !!

What did he say ?

We decided to go out for coffee one day and we talked things over and decided that we both want to be together. He said that despite things going well in his life, he just wasn't happy underneath it all without me in his life, and I felt the same way. Things were a little weird/detached at first, but we slowly eased back into it. We decided to start over new instead of just continuing our old relationship. It's been about a month now and things have never been better. We haven't gotten into a single argument, we communicate so much better, he has a greater desire to see me more often and I've become much more independent and have worked on my own life. The break up was honestly really good for us, it gave us a lot of space and perspective to really think about things and understand ourselves and each other. We both have much more confidence in the relationship now.
click to expand



Hopefully it continues to go uphill for the both of you.

And hopefully, he knows why he's been depressed and takes the steps to overcome it. Completely.
Profile picture of pinkbird03
Pink Bird
@pinkbird03
9 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 975 · Posts: 5791 · Topics: 44
Posted by piscetauro123
Posted by Sassysailorscout

Thats great !!

What did he say ?

We decided to go out for coffee one day and we talked things over and decided that we both want to be together. He said that despite things going well in his life, he just wasn't happy underneath it all without me in his life, and I felt the same way. Things were a little weird/detached at first, but we slowly eased back into it. We decided to start over new instead of just continuing our old relationship. It's been about a month now and things have never been better. We haven't gotten into a single argument, we communicate so much better, he has a greater desire to see me more often and I've become much more independent and have worked on my own life. The break up was honestly really good for us, it gave us a lot of space and perspective to really think about things and understand ourselves and each other. We both have much more confidence in the relationship now.
click to expand



How long did you break up for?