Which water sign (pisces, cancer, Scorpio) is most susceptible to mental illness regarding astrolog?

Whether it's your sun or rising sign, which is the most sad, depressed, negative, etc? Also, to all who have double water in their chart (sun sign and rising sign), what's it like?

All of them.

I'm a Scorpio sun pisces rising

yeah all of them

Posted by narayana
I don't think you can narrow it down like this

My illest friends have zero water

Capricorns?

Posted by NappTune
You mean emotional illness? cause mental illness sounds very airy.

I dunno about that. I have met a few pisces that were depressed and have an alcohol problem. Some scorps that blame the world for their problems. But I also met a libra that way and had an alcohol issue.

Posted by Koniuchaa
You need to look at the 3rd house for mental stuff, as that house rules the mind. Pluto in the 3rd could be a cause. Also harsh aspects

What would you think a scorp w/ a pisces moon & cancer rising, but also has pluto (virgo) in their 3rd house (leo) would be like?

Posted by Koniuchaa
You need to look at the 3rd house for mental stuff, as that house rules the mind. Pluto in the 3rd could be a cause. Also harsh aspects

Well that explains a lot. My Pluto is in the 3rd house.

Posted by narayana

Posted by AerialView

Posted by narayana
I don't think you can narrow it down like this

My illest friends have zero water

Capricorns?

1 Cap (some serious therapy needing narcissist shit)

Leo (panic disorder), Aqua (maj.depression), Taurus (lifelong therapy bc of self harm), Virgo (schizophrenia), 2 Aries (schizophrenia and maj.depression)

maybe forgot someone

click to expand

hmm you look so young, are they the same age as you?

Posted by Koniuchaa

Posted by Spotlessmind

Posted by Koniuchaa
You need to look at the 3rd house for mental stuff, as that house rules the mind. Pluto in the 3rd could be a cause. Also harsh aspects

What would you think a scorp w/ a pisces moon & cancer rising, but also has pluto (virgo) in their 3rd house (leo)

Third house rules the mind, communication, siblings.

Pluto is a very deep and transformative planet

http://www.sunsigns.org/pluto-in-third-house/

click to expand

how about Chiron in 3rd house @koniuchaa?

i have this.

Posted by Koniuchaa

Posted by Spotlessmind

Posted by Koniuchaa
You need to look at the 3rd house for mental stuff, as that house rules the mind. Pluto in the 3rd could be a cause. Also harsh aspects

What would you think a scorp w/ a pisces moon & cancer rising, but also has pluto (virgo) in their 3rd house (leo)

Third house rules the mind, communication, siblings.

Pluto is a very deep and transformative planet

http://www.sunsigns.org/pluto-in-third-house/

click to expand

They're a great speaker.. pretty sure that wasn't easy to obtain.. & they do tend to have little faith in things until they get all of the facts lol

Posted by Koniuchaa

Posted by AerialView

Posted by Koniuchaa

Posted by Spotlessmind

Posted by Koniuchaa
You need to look at the 3rd house for mental stuff, as that house rules the mind. Pluto in the 3rd could be a cause. Also harsh aspects

What would you think a scorp w/ a pisces moon & cancer rising, but also has pluto (virgo) in their 3rd house (leo)

Third house rules the mind, communication, siblings.

Pluto is a very deep and transformative planet

http://www.sunsigns.org/pluto-in-third-house/

how about Chiron in 3rd house @koniuchaa?

i have this.

I think it could mean pain with communication. Maybe you have a hard time expressing yourself?

http://freespiritedmind.com/chiron-in-the-3rd-house/

click to expand

yes a bit difficult for me to express my feelings. i don't have much anyway.

and i always having trouble communicate with overly emotional people or talk about emotional matters.

they see me as a heartless :/

my moon also square my saturn. double doom lol

um well...truthfully stuff like genetics, environment, and experiences really contribute to mental illness ...and even if you were to base it on astrology all 12 signs are susceptible to mental illness but to answer your question

stereotypically ...

pisces depression

scorpio rage

cancer hysteria

I am a cancer sun/scorpio moon/ pisces mars