Mafia Game 7 (77) (Page 2)

You are on page out of 10 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of AA
AA
@AA
15 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 5545 · Topics: 162
Posted by Rambunctious76
Posted by AA
Posted by Rambunctious76
Posted by AA
I'm in.



I still need to exchange reels with you lol



Thee be warned. Didn't i pm you? Thanks for the no response lol RUDE joke 🙂



I never got your PM 😢

I bet you'll not be impressed with my reel 😐

My editing skills need A LOT of brushing up.
click to expand



Sorry i thought i sent you one.

I'm going bed now but i'll message you tomorrow, i look forward to seeing some of your material.

Do you actually have a proper reel btw? Just out of curiosity
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Posted by Scruffles
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
I do take bribes btw in the form of Food and Soap Opera DVDs

😛

aight be back tomorrow

Keep recruiting Damnata!


I vote we have a celebratory game-ending feast. 🙂

^ Although subject to interpretation - no, that's not you.
click to expand




Really good display of Romanian cuisine. I can cook everything on there.

SARMALE though
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by Scruffles
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
yay!


Flowing water
soul
Getmisted
Scruffles
Damnata
Elle
Rambunctious
AA
Phoenix Rising
Feby
Kane
Champ


😄!

I think you should hold out for 3 more v??i??c??t??i'm??s?? ??players...
click to expand




People can still join until about 2 PM dxp time tomorrow

Then the roles will be given and the night will start. And on European time for once :O
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by Scruffles
Nights...

I thought I understood the Crooked Cop role but I'm still confused. 😐

I understood it as - he's Mafia but doesn't know who they are yet and has to find his team. If he picks a Townie and jails them, that Townie can't vote. Provided everyone else votes, the Crook can assume he picked a Townie.

But if he picks a Mafia and is still able to jail them, how is he supposed to know that person is Mafia? Plus, by being able to jail Mafia, he screws over his own outnumbered team.
If he can jail Mafia, then he isn't working for the Mafia.. 😕



Whoever he chooses to jail he also investigates so I will tell he/she that persons role the next day. So yes it will suck if he jails a mafia but that is also the only way he will know who mafia is. He/she could always ask that jailed mafia person who he/she should vote for.

Think of it this way, the crooked cop cant really be crooked until he/she knows who he is being crooked for..
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
Days,

I want to see if I get this role right.

Say I am the crooked cop. I send you a name at night..you send me a message back with that person's role but that person is automatically jailed from the vote in the town square next day right?

One question..is that crooked require to help the mafia out? Or whatever mindsets he/she has..he/she can follow that?

I mean, can he/she pick between sides to support or he/she has to stick by mafia til the end?
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by Damnata
Days,

I want to see if I get this role right.

Say I am the crooked cop. I send you a name at night..you send me a message back with that person's role but that person is automatically jailed from the vote in the town square next day right?

One question..is that crooked require to help the mafia out? Or whatever mindsets he/she has..he/she can follow that?

I mean, can he/she pick between sides to support or he/she has to stick by mafia til the end?



Yes but I wouldnt send you that message until it is day time and after the kill/nobody dies announcement. and yes that person wont be able to vote.

and yeah they are sided and have to be sided with mafia. They will count as a mafia member in the end. As in 1 out of 3 mafia members is out, there would still be 3 mafia members left counting the coorked cop.
Profile picture of Damnata
Damnata
@Damnata
15 Years25,000+ PostsVirgo

Comments: 252 · Posts: 36418 · Topics: 473
yeah but here is my question.

does that person vote with the mafia after one mafia dies..or not?

because i might not know who the mafia is and get one out by mistake.

when there's one mafia gone...does the crooked cop automatically take their place in the night unanimous vote of mafia?

that would be on top of his attributes.

but i can't see how he would stick with the mafia if he doesn't get all the 3 members right..assuming none of the mafias die.
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by Damnata
yeah but here is my question.

does that person vote with the mafia after one mafia dies..or not?

because i might not know who the mafia is and get one out by mistake.

when there's one mafia gone...does the crooked cop automatically take their place in the night unanimous vote of mafia?

that would be on top of his attributes.

but i can't see how he would stick with the mafia if he doesn't get all the 3 members right..assuming none of the mafias die.



Vote with the mob in the day? Yeah they prolly should team up if the mafia member trusts that he/she is the crooked cop.

But no the crooked cop will not join in with the night kills. If 1 members dies the remaining mafias will have to come up with a majority. If there was only 1 mafia members + the crooked cop left then I assume the game would prolly be over anyway because townies would have a hefty majority
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by Damnata
the thing is..if i guess a mafia member..i can't jail someone else right? the person i guessed gets jailed.

so that kinda defeats the purpose of helping the mafia out.

i like the role, praying i am not the crooked cop because things still sound fuzzy to me.



best case scenarios are
A. he/she happens to jail a mafia member at the very start because the first day is always the easiest to have everyone confused on just who is a mafia member so one mafia member being not able to vote wont be too bad.

B. He/she never jails a mafia member but finds out who the cop/slut/tracker/doctor are so he can always keep one of them jailed. Tho cant do the same person twice in a row.

Profile picture of PhoenixRising
PhoenixRising
@PhoenixRising
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 19 · Posts: 19733 · Topics: 48
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
Posted by Damnata
yeah but here is my question.

does that person vote with the mafia after one mafia dies..or not?

because i might not know who the mafia is and get one out by mistake.

when there's one mafia gone...does the crooked cop automatically take their place in the night unanimous vote of mafia?

that would be on top of his attributes.

but i can't see how he would stick with the mafia if he doesn't get all the 3 members right..assuming none of the mafias die.



Vote with the mob in the day? Yeah they prolly should team up if the mafia member trusts that he/she is the crooked cop.

But no the crooked cop will not join in with the night kills. If 1 members dies the remaining mafias will have to come up with a majority. If there was only 1 mafia members + the crooked cop left then I assume the game would prolly be over anyway because townies would have a hefty majority
click to expand



Question:
The townies get to save a life if they sleep with mafia, how does mafia benefit from this unless the crooked cop already know who needs "protection" with their shady behaviour?

Couldn't the crooked cop know who the mafia is and perhaps only jail townies? I mean townies have the advantage of 1) Saving a life (help from the slut) 2) Saving someone from a kill (help from the doctor)

How exactly does the crooked cop help anyone? Especially mafia until the bitter end or unless he/she happens to guess all mafia members?

It sounds unfair, but perhaps mafia doesn't get to know who the crooked cop is so they have to be careful who they kill or oust during the vote.
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by PhoenixRising
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
Posted by Damnata
yeah but here is my question.

does that person vote with the mafia after one mafia dies..or not?

because i might not know who the mafia is and get one out by mistake.

when there's one mafia gone...does the crooked cop automatically take their place in the night unanimous vote of mafia?

that would be on top of his attributes.

but i can't see how he would stick with the mafia if he doesn't get all the 3 members right..assuming none of the mafias die.



Vote with the mob in the day? Yeah they prolly should team up if the mafia member trusts that he/she is the crooked cop.

But no the crooked cop will not join in with the night kills. If 1 members dies the remaining mafias will have to come up with a majority. If there was only 1 mafia members + the crooked cop left then I assume the game would prolly be over anyway because townies would have a hefty majority


Question:
The townies get to save a life if they sleep with mafia, how does mafia benefit from this unless the crooked cop already know who needs "protection" with their shady behaviour?

Couldn't the crooked cop know who the mafia is and perhaps only jail townies? I mean townies have the advantage of 1) Saving a life (help from the slut) 2) Saving someone from a kill (help from the doctor)

How exactly does the crooked cop help anyone? Especially mafia until the bitter end or unless he/she happens to guess all mafia members?

It sounds unfair, but perhaps mafia doesn't get to know who the crooked cop is so they have to be careful who they kill or oust during the vote.
click to expand




I was going to do another role for mafia but people were complaing that the mafia already has the big advantage which isnt true since the townies have 75 advantages but it is what it is

The crooked cop doesnt have to guess all mafia members if he can get 1 mafia member to trust him and tell him or her who the rest of the mafia is. He/she also helps by keeping townies from voting
Profile picture of Soul
Soul
@Soul
10 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 2280 · Posts: 17009 · Topics: 110
Posted by Scruffles
Nights...

Are you sure you want to include 2 new roles?

I think the Tracker is enough for now. I mean, if the Crook is even confusing the Virgo...the game is gonna be a hot mess, ya know?



Ahh yes, but here's where your wrong. The Virgo is actually very smart, and must be acting dumb so smart player give examples of how they would play their role if they got it.

Isn't that right my lovely Virgo 😉


Hype!
Profile picture of AfternoonDelights22
AfternoonDelights22
@AfternoonDelights22
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 819 · Posts: 28237 · Topics: 174
Posted by PhoenixRising
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
Posted by Damnata
yeah, the problem with A is when it happens further along the game because there's 4 mafias, not just one.

that's a tricky scenario.



The crooked cop could always ask that person who the rest of the mafia is. Up to that person to trust if it is the crooked cop or not tho..


Do you mean through PMs?
click to expand




yeah
Profile picture of PhoenixRising
PhoenixRising
@PhoenixRising
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 19 · Posts: 19733 · Topics: 48
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
Posted by PhoenixRising
Posted by AfternoonDelights22
Posted by Damnata
yeah but here is my question.

does that person vote with the mafia after one mafia dies..or not?

because i might not know who the mafia is and get one out by mistake.

when there's one mafia gone...does the crooked cop automatically take their place in the night unanimous vote of mafia?

that would be on top of his attributes.

but i can't see how he would stick with the mafia if he doesn't get all the 3 members right..assuming none of the mafias die.



Vote with the mob in the day? Yeah they prolly should team up if the mafia member trusts that he/she is the crooked cop.

But no the crooked cop will not join in with the night kills. If 1 members dies the remaining mafias will have to come up with a majority. If there was only 1 mafia members + the crooked cop left then I assume the game would prolly be over anyway because townies would have a hefty majority


Question:
The townies get to save a life if they sleep with mafia, how does mafia benefit from this unless the crooked cop already know who needs "protection" with their shady behaviour?

Couldn't the crooked cop know who the mafia is and perhaps only jail townies? I mean townies have the advantage of 1) Saving a life (help from the slut) 2) Saving someone from a kill (help from the doctor)

How exactly does the crooked cop help anyone? Especially mafia until the bitter end or unless he/she happens to guess all mafia members?

It sounds unfair, but perhaps mafia doesn't get to know who the crooked cop is so they have to be careful who they kill or oust during the vote.



I was going to do another role for mafia but people were complaing that the mafia already has the big advantage which isnt true since the townies have 75 advantages but it is what it is

The crooked cop doesnt have to guess all mafia members if he can get 1 mafia member to trust him and tell him or her who the rest of the mafia is. He/she also helps by keeping townies from voting
click to expand



Alright. Cool.