Book?

Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
I have been writing ever since I was 9. I have been trying to write a novel, but I'm not sure if it's long enough. I just don't get how other writers can spend two paragraphs writing about the color of some dudes curtains when I spend 2 paragraphs describing a massive city. Do you think it's long enough? Or good enough? Link: Derpxderp.blogspot.com


P.S. Read from bottom to top.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
click to expand

May I ask, who is your audience? Just got curious after having read on.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
May I ask, who is your audience? Just got curious after having read on.
click to expand


Probably the people on Google+.
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
Profile picture of lisabethur8
lisabeth
@lisabethur8
13 Years50,000+ Posts

Comments: 4373 · Posts: 50653 · Topics: 564
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.
are you a writer too, happy capper? it sounds like you know very well how to write.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
May I ask, who is your audience? Just got curious after having read on.

Probably the people on Google+.
click to expand

Who is that? What age group, for instance?
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
click to expand

I didn't understand that. What do you mean?
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by lisabethur8
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.
are you a writer too, happy capper? it sounds like you know very well how to write.
click to expand

Hmm. Well. I have written stuff...
Profile picture of lisabethur8
lisabeth
@lisabethur8
13 Years50,000+ Posts

Comments: 4373 · Posts: 50653 · Topics: 564
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by lisabethur8
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.
are you a writer too, happy capper? it sounds like you know very well how to write.
Hmm. Well. I have written stuff...
click to expand

oooohhhhh share!!

(if you like of course!)
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
May I ask, who is your audience? Just got curious after having read on.

Probably the people on Google+.
Who is that? What age group, for instance?
click to expand


14-18 year olds.
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
I didn't understand that. What do you mean?
click to expand


My main problem is that I'm not good at stretching out the chapters with detail. And this is AFTER I made edits.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by lisabethur8
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by lisabethur8
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.
are you a writer too, happy capper? it sounds like you know very well how to write.
Hmm. Well. I have written stuff...
oooohhhhh share!!

(if you like of course!)
click to expand

Not sure what I have written that would be suitable for a forum, lenghthwise, and that I'm actually prepared to call completely finished. Hmm. Thinking.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
I also only read the first chapter and tbh, I think you could spend more time on characterization and setting.

The part that I liked the most in terms of characterization was "The bad kids sat in the back and the good kids sat in the front, so she figured that in between was fine with her." But I need more. Why should I care about this girl - what is so special about her - I need it to be more idiosyncratic.

The setting also needs more work. imo. In the prologue, you tell us about "her home planet," so at least I expect to get something that will make me come more to terms with where I am, in order for me to really be able to get down to and enjoy the actual story.

Imo.

That's fair. I'm going to work on that. And the planet she's on doesn't matter until chapter 5... Thanks for the criticism!
May I ask, who is your audience? Just got curious after having read on.

Probably the people on Google+.
Who is that? What age group, for instance?

14-18 year olds.
click to expand

That's probably good. And you could go even a bit lower, imo. Just remove the "go back to" part, as that makes the reader fall out of the story and the younger reader would not identify. Again, imo.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
I didn't understand that. What do you mean?

My main problem is that I'm not good at stretching out the chapters with detail. And this is AFTER I made edits.
click to expand

Do you feel like you know your characters? Can you be inside their heads?
Profile picture of Crapmaster555
Crapmaster555
@Crapmaster555
10 Years

Comments: 25 · Posts: 132 · Topics: 28
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
I didn't understand that. What do you mean?

My main problem is that I'm not good at stretching out the chapters with detail. And this is AFTER I made edits.
Do you feel like you know your characters? Can you be inside their heads?
click to expand


Yeah. I imagine the story as I write it.
Profile picture of HappyCapper
HappyCapper
@HappyCapper
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 28 · Posts: 5115 · Topics: 92
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Posted by Crapmaster555
Posted by HappyCapper
Read to chapter five and it is, imo, way to fast. It's like you want to cram as much information onto the pages as possible, but at the same time that you are restraining yourself from writing what you actually want to write. Relax!

You've got the imagination, you've got the drive and you've got the passion and most importantly, you're actually doing it! Now, all you need to do is to "find yourself as a writer." It seems to me you want your story to be exciting and funny, but that the actual writing is limiting you. Again, relax! Find your own voice. Don't hold back - just write!

Again, imo.

I have nothing to describe.
I didn't understand that. What do you mean?

My main problem is that I'm not good at stretching out the chapters with detail. And this is AFTER I made edits.
Do you feel like you know your characters? Can you be inside their heads?

Yeah. I imagine the story as I write it.
click to expand

Your main character,

Does she have any siblings?
What's her relationship with the sibling(s) if she has any?
What kind of toothpaste does she use?
Does she like veggies?
Alone on a park bench or in a coffee house in the city?
Which subjects does she like in school? Gym? Math? English?
What's her first memory?

You don't have to give us all this info, if you don't want to, ofc, just consider if you really know the character.

When you imagine the story, how much do you see? Where is "the camera," so to speak?