How do you feel about the statement….

Profile picture of AbbyNormal
AbbyNormal
@AbbyNormal
12 Years5,000+ PostsTaurus

Comments: 14265 · Posts: 5321 · Topics: 61
“You cannot suffer the past or future because they do not exist. What you are suffering is your memory and imagination.”



I just shared this quote with Virguy because it came up on IG and has always been one of my favs from growing up. I’ve always found it very helpful in trying to manage my own stress and happiness. Seems very rational to me, but Virguy disagrees (of course, lol).

What do you feel/think about this statement?
Profile picture of Enfant-Terrible-II
Enfant-Terrible-II
@Enfant-Terrible-II
5 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 808 · Posts: 1450 · Topics: 13
Posted by AbbyNormal

“You cannot suffer the past or future because they do not exist. What you are suffering is your memory and imagination.”



I just shared this quote with Virguy because it came up on IG and has always been one of my favs from growing up. I’ve always found it very helpful in trying to manage my own stress and happiness. Seems very rational to me, but Virguy disagrees (of course, lol).

What do you feel/think about this statement?

But if it weren't for specific events, your memory and imagination wouldn't be suffering so ultimately it's still about these specific events. Saying it's memory or imagination is just deflecting 😂

But I could be totally misunderstanding the quote..
Profile picture of AbbyNormal
AbbyNormal
@AbbyNormal
12 Years5,000+ PostsTaurus

Comments: 14265 · Posts: 5321 · Topics: 61
Posted by AgentP911

Interesting. I'd not heard or seen this statement before. I understand the concept of it and think it holds some merit. I'm not sure it will transfer well into real life for most people but the philosophical concept is sound.


I honestly think some people cannot wrap their minds around this one. It makes so much sense to me that it boggles my mind when it doesn’t to others. Interesting to hear other people’s perspective on it….. because that’s what it’s all about right?
Profile picture of neves
neves
@neves
9 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1155 · Posts: 4750 · Topics: 13
In past years (or more like - a decade or so... years upon years) - the terms "Present Time" and "Now" - were quite heavily mediatized by celebrities like Allan Watts, Eckhart Tolle and others alike... Supposedly - that's the true nature of things - while Past and Future doesn't really exist (just a state of mind - as they put it - or something like that). Didn't think much about it and since it kinda made sense - i rolled with it... But now - that i did (think about it), well... Present/Now - is basically the middle ground between Past and Future. Yet... that's the part that can never materialize for a human being. I mean... time would have to stop - thus, Present and Future can be removed from this equation - leaving only the Present Time (Now). Then (if time Stops) you can truly say - that "Now is all there is...." The way i see - the true nature of things is a never ending treadmill - where you have the Present Time (Now) - in the middle - but one foot is always in the past - while the other in the future.

Tho, yes... distant past is composed memories (even imagination - cause most people struggle to remember every detail to a T - so ones imagination fills the gaps) - and distant future is... the unknown (one can imagine or have expectations - but precognitions, well... i'm not gifted in that regarded - so personally - i don't know what to say about that). That being said - i do agree that a lot people screw themselves - by investing energy in the past.... As for the future - to do need goals/aspirations - or else you're bound to drift aimlessly - in this big ocean we call life (or existence). Just don't fall in the trap of thinking you know things... unless you have enough evidence - to foresee a possible/probable outcome.

Just my impromptu opinion (: don't have any cents - since i don't live in U.S. - and the local currency could confuse a foreigner).
Profile picture of PuzzlePieces
Roo
@PuzzlePieces
6 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1560 · Posts: 3897 · Topics: 79
It’s not just memories and imagination. Although I do agree that we are better off living in the present, it involves letting go and letting life evolve.

There are things that have affected us so much in the past, that we get triggered when sometime feels familiar. Not just about the memory. So it is important to work through these things to move forward & ignoring the past does not help work through things. The thing about the future is we don’t want to repeat the triggering events, so we need to be aware & therefore careful.

I guess reality is just more complicated than the quote 🤷‍♀️
Profile picture of DMV
DMV
@DMV
15 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 294 · Posts: 28989 · Topics: 654
Posted by AbbyNormal

“You cannot suffer the past or future because they do not exist. What you are suffering is your memory and imagination.”



I just shared this quote with Virguy because it came up on IG and has always been one of my favs from growing up. I’ve always found it very helpful in trying to manage my own stress and happiness. Seems very rational to me, but Virguy disagrees (of course, lol).

What do you feel/think about this statement?


I get it.

People often feel trapped but they’re not really trapped, they just lack the imagination to see a way through.

Kinda like I think that DEPRESSION is the result of the denial of ones own current circumstances. People who are depressed just are reluctant to accept reality. Whether that reality is death, a breakup, or job loss. Etc

Profile picture of PhoenixRising
PhoenixRising
@PhoenixRising
13 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 19 · Posts: 19733 · Topics: 48
Posted by AbbyNormal

“You cannot suffer the past or future because they do not exist. What you are suffering is your memory and imagination.”



I just shared this quote with Virguy because it came up on IG and has always been one of my favs from growing up. I’ve always found it very helpful in trying to manage my own stress and happiness. Seems very rational to me, but Virguy disagrees (of course, lol).

What do you feel/think about this statement?

I like it. It is a statement meant to ground an individual, keep them in the present and reduce anxiety.

Virguy's probably bothered he didn't come across it first. Did he say why he disagrees? I am curious.