Ladies, Would you marry someone who proposed to you with a fake diamond engagement ring..

Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

LoL. No. Not unless I wanted an equally fake marriage. I think an engagement ring is a token of someone's feelings for a person, the depth of those feelings, and the sincerity of those feelings. Giving someone a fake ring shows how little they value you. (Unless they're so poor they can't afford a real one in which case it's up to the recipient if they want to be wedded to someone in that financial situation.)

Yes. I would marry someone that proposed to me with a $ 2 Walmart ring if I was madly in love with him.

Scorpio sun

Currently single but my heart still belongs to my Libra ex.

No. Especially if it was under false pretences.

As long as he has real meaty shlong...

Probably if I was in love. But who does that?

Posted by Deedee86
Yes. I would marry someone that proposed to me with a $ 2 Walmart ring if I was madly in love with him.

Scorpio sun

Currently single but my heart still belongs to my Libra ex.

I would rather have nothing than wal mart ring!

It says he is stupid redneck with no sense of dignity to tell you I love you but I am a deadbeat who can't afford a ring!

My daughter bought me a ring at school for $ 3.50

So... Figure it out for yoirzelf

Posted by Easha23000us
Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

Explain significant...other! Please

Someone ask that the other day but no go!

Lol

I think it's the gesture that counts...A fake ring is fine as long as he tells you it's fake. Maybe he loves you and can't afford a $ 5,000 rock. Maybe if you say yes, you'll get a real one when finances improve. Why should the ring matter? That's just shallow. Would I want to marry some gold digger who rejects me based on my budget? Hell no.

And I'm a leo 😛

No, I dont need a ring before I would take a fake but I question getting married to someone that can't save something for a token of a ring. I mean me buy a pearl or something as a sign but I don't want fake. Also, I want someone that knows how to set a goal and knows how to save for it.

Maybe it's just me. I've never liked or worn rings anyways. I could care less about an engagement ring. Save the money for a fabulous honeymoon!

Posted by Season
LoL. No. Not unless I wanted an equally fake marriage. I think an engagement ring is a token of someone's feelings for a person, the depth of those feelings, and the sincerity of those feelings. Giving someone a fake ring shows how little they value you. (Unless they're so poor they can't afford a real one in which case it's up to the recipient if they want to be wedded to someone in that financial situation.)

This is off subject , what are your other placements u don't have listed. My BFF is Taurus sun aries moon Pisces Venus..

Posted by leowww
Lmao... @ this thread.

Who cares about diamonds. #Overrated

I think I would be more bothered if he tried passing the fake diamonds for real ones.

Otherwise... Idc

If I could choose.. I'd like something more personal... Vintage... Family heirloom.. Type of deal. Sapphires are beautiful...

Thats me too, I don't want a diamond, I want something else and something that you think represents me.

No that's wack as hell .. That would make me feel like I'm not worth the real thing , no thanks

Aries Sun me

Scorp Sun him

If I was really in love I wouldn't care what I got. That's how you know it's love if someone proposes to you and you r focused on the ring you're not in love and shouldn't be getting married. But these hoes out here will marry you just to say they married

If the dude lied about it, I'd have an issue. Be upfront with me and I won't care - lie to me and I have a problem. I've always said I want a wooden ring IF I get married anywho...I could care less about diamonds. I'm a Sag...current, long term, bf is a Gem. He knows my stance on all this and we're both not really about marriage anywho. Been going strong for 6 years now.

I don't really like diamonds

😐

But for the sake of the question I'd accept anything nice from him like a nice gemstone ring even something CZ with sterling silver if he was broke if I truly love him.

Just don't play me like oh its a diamond when you know it's not though.

Don't you dare lie to me!!! I will fuck you up.

Libra/Cancer

I have jewelry from him so far and it's simple and very nice quality. He didn't have to spend a fortune and I love and appreciate it more than anything

I'm anti-marriage so I would assume he's just pulling my leg.

So it used to be women were traded like cattle from their fathers household to their husbands. Their new husband would pay the 'bride price' to their father. Literally bought and sold. With the advent of women's rights purchasing a bride was no longer in vogue, marrying for love was. With the emergence of the middle class after the second world war engagement rings with diamonds became a sign of status.

I'd rather he invest the diamond money into our future. Lets take a long honeymoon, put down a healthy down payment on a home, etc. Don't go into debt for a cold hard rock, lets spend that money on experiences we both can enjoy and that will make our relationship stronger.

So yes, I don't need a diamond from a man for him to convince me he wants to spend his mortality with me.

Plus I'm a swimmer. I can't do clunky, chunky rings on my hands. It's annoying.

I'm a Pisces with a Gemini

Not if he LIED about it.

If he was *honest* then really, who cares?

Posted by DonumDei

Posted by leowww


Who cares about diamonds. #Overrated

This ^^^

Not to mention the whole ethical/moral dilemma surrounding "blood diamon" trade. Actually, it's not even a dilemma to me personally as I much rather go with a laxurious peach colored Morganite. 🙂

click to expand

Cathy Waterman

If they told me that it was fake, yes 😄

Do I know about it? I would prefer it. I'm not into over-hyped blood diamonds or so-called ethically sourced diamonds . ?

Posted by RumiL
If they told me that it was fake, yes 😄

Hm marry me,??

Idk never crossed my mind nothing to flashy, just something that you actually took time and effort to look at one and think about me actually.

What are you saying check your rings to see if they are real or not? 5 years later.

Posted by FirstDecanTaurianWomen0428

Posted by RumiL
If they told me that it was fake, yes 😄

Hm marry me,??

click to expand

..*happy tears* ...yesss 😄

I hope that's not your actual toilet at your casa.

Posted by Gemitati

Posted by Easha23000us
Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

Explain significant...other! Please

Someone ask that the other day but no go!

Lol

click to expand

Your significant other is that main special person in your life...Your husband or fiance or future spouse....

Posted by Kittenfish
I think it's the gesture that counts...A fake ring is fine as long as he tells you it's fake. Maybe he loves you and can't afford a $ 5,000 rock. Maybe if you say yes, you'll get a real one when finances improve. Why should the ring matter? That's just shallow. Would I want to marry some gold digger who rejects me based on my budget? Hell no.

And I'm a leo 😛

Interesting perspective, but very debateable!

Posted by SofiaV87
No that's wack as hell .. That would make me feel like I'm not worth the real thing , no thanks

Aries Sun me

Scorp Sun him

You are the only one who followed directions...LOL!!

Posted by Easha23000us

Posted by Gemitati

Posted by Easha23000us
Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

Explain significant...other! Please

Someone ask that the other day but no go!

Lol

Your significant other is that main special person in your life...Your husband or fiance or future spouse....

click to expand

How about husband and lover?

I am not sure who is more significant...

Lol

Posted by Gemitati

Posted by Easha23000us

Posted by Gemitati

Posted by Easha23000us
Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

Explain significant...other! Please

Someone ask that the other day but no go!

Lol

Your significant other is that main special person in your life...Your husband or fiance or future spouse....

How about husband and lover?

I am not sure who is more significant...

Lol

click to expand

Your legally wedded spouse...LOL!

Wow!!! DXP added the like button, just like on facebook....I have not noticed until now 😉

No

Cap

No, if he really loved me .. the ring would be real unless he had a valid reason like "i can't afford the real diamond right now but i'll upgrade soon"... then i would accept & honor it.

I'm a virgo.

fiance is a libra.

Posted by BuffaloBills28
Allow me to worship that sexy body of yours for the rest of our days, but hey, here's a 25cent plastic ring you get in those little machine thingy's to show how much I value you. 🙂

Never thought of the ring as my 'value'...

That's stupid!

Ring was given as a sign of belonging to someone so others should keep their paws off!!!

But my value— Shit!!! That's degrading.

A man and a woman are planning their future together. They have X amount of money to spend on things they deem important. Two options:

1. Use most of the money to pay off the mortgage sooner. Small amount on the ring.

Or

2. Use most of the money on the ring. Take longer to pay off mortgage.

Posted by starwars
who needs a fuckin ring when you can get matching tatts

Knowing you I thought you said

Matching tits...

Of course ...... what a shallow question.

What a shallow person to put that kind of expectation on a guy to where he has to produce a ring for you to examine it's value as a determination of his worth.

Posted by Easha23000us
Post your sign, and your significant other's as well...

No significant other

However I would agree to marry them with a fake ring if it was a spontaneous proposal and they were going to replace it at some point.

I'm not superficial by any stretch of the imagination, however if I was going to propose I would save for a decent ring and would like my SO to at least try to do the same.

Posted by atearth
A man and a woman are planning their future together. They have X amount of money to spend on things they deem important. Two options:

1. Use most of the money to pay off the mortgage sooner. Small amount on the ring.

Or

2. Use most of the money on the ring. Take longer to pay off mortgage.

Pay off that mortgage quick and get me a better ring when WE can afford it, if it's necessary!

Posted by starwars

Posted by Gemitati

Posted by starwars
who needs a fuckin ring when you can get matching tatts

Knowing you I thought you said

Matching tits...

you know me so well 🙂

click to expand

And keep wishing to turn it back before I did🙂

Posted by atearth
A man and a woman are planning their future together. They have X amount of money to spend on things they deem important. Two options:

1. Use most of the money to pay off the mortgage sooner. Small amount on the ring.

Or

2. Use most of the money on the ring. Take longer to pay off mortgage.

Diamonds, unless the quality/clarity is top tier, do not retain their value very well. Whereas property gains equity.

I have a client in Santa Monica who purchased her home 19 years ago for 319,000. It's worth over 1.5mill now.

Spending 10-30,000 on a diamond that depreciates over that 19 year period or make 4xs that amount by investing that money in a morguage. Status verses your future. Easy choice.

Posted by DivaCanLeo
Hell naw im worth a couple of dead Africans

Lmfao!!

Posted by DonJohn
is he black?

cuz if he were, you would gladly accept

The Proposal, right?

No mam

Posted by Easha23000us

Posted by SofiaV87
No that's wack as hell .. That would make me feel like I'm not worth the real thing , no thanks

Aries Sun me

Scorp Sun him

You are the only one who followed directions...LOL!!

click to expand

Lol