Britney vs. Taylor Swift

I suppose their fashon statements make them who they are...

but who do you prefer?? Britney or Taylor Swift and why??

does one or the other annoy you? or do you listen to any of their music at all?

Ahh both Sag ladies.

I like Britney more. Just because I listened to her as a child...some memories are attached so... ☺

Isnt it weird to see Brittany fade into the background when 15 years ago she was the Taylor of the music biz.

Posted by malloryor
Isnt it weird to see Brittany fade into the background when 15 years ago she was the Taylor of the music biz.

hm I don't know about that. Britney is still loved and wanted, she's not even middle aged yet!

just wait till she gets Madonna's age....

but I personally like Britney's music for some reason. Maybe it's the song writers.

I also like Madonna's song writers. (since I know their music is written by others)

Posted by RumiL
Ahh both Sag ladies.

I like Britney more. Just because I listened to her as a child...some memories are attached so... ☺

click to expand

yeah I like Britney too.

I thought maybe the people liked her best because she is from a commoners background, not wealthy,

but then again that's not true, lots of people from wealthy background get love from the people.

but it all depends.

Posted by lisabethur8

Posted by malloryor
Isnt it weird to see Brittany fade into the background when 15 years ago she was the Taylor of the music biz.

hm I don't know about that. Britney is still loved and wanted, she's not even middle aged yet!

just wait till she gets Madonna's age....

but I personally like Britney's music for some reason. Maybe it's the song writers.

I also like Madonna's song writers. (since I know their music is written by others)

Posted by RumiL
Ahh both Sag ladies.

I like Britney more. Just because I listened to her as a child...some memories are attached so... ☺

yeah I like Britney too.

I thought maybe the people liked her best because she is from a commoners background, not wealthy,

but then again that's not true, lots of people from wealthy background get love from the people.

but it all depends.

click to expand

Brittany is beloved my her niche of fans but she is not nominated in music categories like the VMAs and Grammys, she seldomnly appears on red carpets, let alone is asked to perform, she may have a single here or there but you rarely here them on the radio like before, people dont talk about Brittany'a videos anymore...I would not categorize her like Madonma because in her 30s and 40s Madonna was still making huge waves in Hollywood. Her tours were still highly talked about, the level of attention Brittany attracts due to her celebrity is different than the 00s when it was literally Brittany, boyband, Christina mania.

God I kinda miss those years lol

Posted by malloryor

Posted by lisabethur8

Posted by malloryor
Isnt it weird to see Brittany fade into the background when 15 years ago she was the Taylor of the music biz.

hm I don't know about that. Britney is still loved and wanted, she's not even middle aged yet!

just wait till she gets Madonna's age....

but I personally like Britney's music for some reason. Maybe it's the song writers.

I also like Madonna's song writers. (since I know their music is written by others)

Posted by RumiL
Ahh both Sag ladies.

I like Britney more. Just because I listened to her as a child...some memories are attached so... ☺

yeah I like Britney too.

I thought maybe the people liked her best because she is from a commoners background, not wealthy,

but then again that's not true, lots of people from wealthy background get love from the people.

but it all depends.

Brittany is beloved my her niche of fans but she is not nominated in music categories like the VMAs and Grammys, she seldomnly appears on red carpets, let alone is asked to perform, she may have a single here or there but you rarely here them on the radio like before, people dont talk about Brittany'a videos anymore...I would not categorize her like Madonma because in her 30s and 40s Madonna was still making huge waves in Hollywood. Her tours were still highly talked about, the level of attention Brittany attracts due to her celebrity is different than the 00s when it was literally Brittany, boyband, Christina mania.

God I kinda miss those years lol

click to expand

Madonna is just looking more like a caricature in her old age, it was beautiful in her 40s, when she got married and had her 2nd child, she looked like a woman middle aged happy in a foreign land (U.K.) and then all went down hill....

I think that's her biggest 10 year success, even before her "Like a prayer" days.

Posted by Explicit
I don't get the appeal with Taylor Swift. I don't find her or her squinty eyes attractive. I don't think she's a good performer. She's not much of a singer, but then again neither is Britney.

I feel like if Britney never would have suffered her meltdown, at this point she'd be surpassing Madonna by now. But life kind of took over for her. I also feel like she's way more focused on being a mother and living a normal life then being the pop queen again. Cancer MC life!

But in terms of who's better, I feel like Britney has more charisma and star power with just a look in her eye then Tay-Tay has in her whole body.

yes, Britney does have more star power and charisma than taylor.

I don't know why, but taylor just doesn't have it.

Posted by xEUx
I forgot to mention Britney. PP would never forgive me.

Britney is still drop dead gorgeous Still has good music too.

Britney and Taylor are two different people with different qualities, each being equally valid for her own time frame.

taylor is cute, but so is a lot of celebrity women out there.

they really are too different. I don't know what it is...

maybe it's because Britney has trines in her chart....which makes it seem EASIER??

and her sun moon sextiles, venus mars trines.

and Taylor, she has cancer moon Jupiter (which is good) but with her sag sun, not good?

and her scorpio mars SQUARE venus aquarius...it's like a MESS.

edit the only thing is...

her mars trines Jupiter which is a harmonious aspect in relations to whatever she wants in life.

http://www.astrotheme.com/astrology/Taylor_Swift

and her moon/mars are in harmony too. she's very moon Jupiter,

Posted by everlynn
In music, Taylor Swift. I like country music and Brittany's music genre ain't country.

As far as who I like better, i honestly don't know really. That's a tough call.

is it really all country?

haven't really listened to swift's music much. I just saw the most popular ones.

I don't think this is very country is it?

I would think even Shania twain's music is more country...

Posted by Explicit
And since we're on the topic of Britney, here's my favorite Britney video ever!

*giggles*

she's mean!!!

lmao

I can't see taylor doing that. can you?

Taylor has more natural timeless beauty going for her, she also comes across as more expensive than britney.

I never liked taylor till that out in style song came out, you guys do realise she writes her own songs right?

Posted by The_eleventh_sign_11

Taylor has more natural timeless beauty going for her, she also comes across as more expensive than britney.

I never liked taylor till that out in style song came out, you guys do realise she writes her own songs right?

yeah I know, but they're not that great in my opinion, it's kind of boring.

the common people also have a voice. I don't even like Adele's music. *shrug*

I love the song writers of Britney's and Madonna's....

I even love Lady Gaga's song writing and also Pink's.

Posted by Explicit

Posted by lisabethur8

Posted by Explicit
And since we're on the topic of Britney, here's my favorite Britney video ever!

*giggles*

she's mean!!!

lmao

I can't see taylor doing that. can you?

I don't think Taylor even swears. But who knows. 😛

click to expand

taylor swear? she seems UPTIGHT.

needs some Jennifer Lopez and Madonna in her.

and she ain't NO PINK

love this gal.

Lets Break this down:

Taylor:

Britney:

My guy's opinion is that Taylor is someone you go have hipster coffee with. Britney is who you want to bring home at the end of the night.

Posted by Gennie
Lets Break this down:

Taylor:

Britney:

My guy's opinion is that Taylor is someone you go have hipster coffee with. Britney is who you want to bring home at the end of the night.

best answer ever!!! 😄

Posted by lisabethur8
and she ain't NO PINK

love this gal.

Have you seen her chart? Virgo Stellium. But all I can see in her performance is that Aries Moon with Cancer Mars.

It's like Aries and Cancer had a baby and it decided to go kick some ass. She also writes her own songs and I'm interested in her messages than Taylor.

That said, I loved Blank Space.

Posted by JohnnyRed007
As a Libra in Pluto Generation id have to say that Brittany is way better, and better looking too 🙂

hm I don't think that has anything to do with it, cause I know my cousins LOVE Britney spears and they are scorpio pluto and pluto sag

Posted by Gennie

Posted by lisabethur8
and she ain't NO PINK

love this gal.

Have you seen her chart? Virgo Stellium. But all I can see in her performance is that Aries Moon with Cancer Mars.

It's like Aries and Cancer had a baby and it decided to go kick some ass. She also writes her own songs and I'm interested in her messages than Taylor.

That said, I loved Blank Space.

click to expand

I agree! I see her Jupiter Leo trining her Aries moon, cancer mars break out!! but her mutability makes it all cray.

Taylor has Aqua and Scorpio influences. also Cap. her style is better.

(also she is a composer. so a real artist.

but she has not come with a revolutionary cord as twenty one pilot would say.)

Britney is as headless as I am in real life.

I prefer Jessie J.

Britney seems more genuine then Taylor. If I had option to meet either, definitely I would pick Britney 🙂

tay tay alll day

I think its cause of her cancer moon! 😄

I love Taylor's style (I.e. I love her stylist.)

Britney's personality is much more charming and likable, in my opinion. So Britney wins as a human being, I think.

Britney, atleast she had her honest breakdowns and didnt really pretend to be anyone she wasnt. Tay Swift is such a sham. She's slept with half of hollywood by now. That good girl image isnt fooling anyone! Lol

When someone tells me how creative Katy Perry and Taylor Swift are.....

Posted by Gennie

it's Leo/ 5th house, that's it! well of course part of it. Britney is 5th house moon too.

Leo RULES the stage.

Posted by Gennie
When someone tells me how creative Katy Perry and Taylor Swift are.....

I never got into Katy Perry's stuff much either.

sure some of her pop songs are catchy and ok, but nothing that stands out, like Madonna or Britney.

Posted by Dastard

Posted by Explicit

Posted by Dastard

Posted by Explicit
I don't get the appeal with Taylor Swift. I don't find her or her squinty eyes attractive. I don't think she's a good performer. She's not much of a singer, but then again neither is Britney.

I feel like if Britney never would have suffered her meltdown, at this point she'd be surpassing Madonna by now. But life kind of took over for her. I also feel like she's way more focused on being a mother and living a normal life then being the pop queen again. Cancer MC life!

But in terms of who's better, I feel like Britney has more charisma and star power with just a look in her eye then Tay-Tay has in her whole body.

I grew up with Taylor and I can say without a shadow of a doubt that Taylor is no Britney. The only appeal Taylor has is (or was) her innocent image, her catchy tunes, the fact that she bathes in drama, and has a commercial image and sound that sells to a lot of people.

She is not exceptionally charismatic, she has zero stage presence, no sex appeal, her sweetness comes across as fake, she can't sing that well, she can't dance for shit, her body is kinda bleh, and she is pale as fuck.

I'm not saying she's boring. I like Taylor, but compared to Britney she is nothing.

I agree. Another pop star like that is Katy Perry. She literally offers nothing except releases the same sounding, same generic music every single year and radio and the little kids eat it up. She's a 30-something year old woman dressing up in ice cream outfits with lime green hair and has these kid-friendly pop songs.

I cannot WAIT for the day that pop stars like Katy Perry and Taylor Swift FADE away. They will never have longevity in the business. They bring nothing to the table and they're one-trick pony's. As soon as this "era" of pop music ends, they're gonna fade away, because they're not going to know how to transition into the next era of music.

Rihanna on the other hand, she's a little more feisty, she's a little more daring, more of a risk-taker - I feel like she's gonna be around for a long time. But who knows.

Rihanna is not my cup of tea but I like her for the same reasons you do. I still like Beyonce better, she is a real superstar.

Yea, Katy Perry is another mediocre pop star, haha.

But yeah. Even at her sexiest or her best, Taylor cannot touch Britney.

click to expand

taylor seems to try

tries too hard to be sexy. lol she's so stick skinny and doesn't seem to have a sexy image, so I think she should stay away from trying to look sexy. Shania Twain does it BETTER even though Twain is twice her age.

Posted by Harukka

so boring.

that ballroom dance is probably more tiltillating with senior citizens.

ok some more Britney

To be fair, Madonna and Britney are from a time when dancing your ass on a stage was the norm. I don't think Taylor has done any hard core choreography. It's a different time, and I don't wanna jump on her, just because looks. My commentary is about her ability to be an entertainer.

I came across this and was like, jesus only Janet can look sexy in a trench coat =p

Posted by Gennie
To be fair, Madonna and Britney are from a time when dancing your ass on a stage was the norm. I don't think Taylor has done any hard core choreography. It's a different time, and I don't wanna jump on her, just because looks. My commentary is about her ability to be an entertainer.

I came across this and was like, jesus only Janet can look sexy in a trench coat =p

do you think the nipple slip has anything to do with the PUBLICITY stunt thing??

Also, T Swift has the bod of a 12 yr old boy.

Posted by Gennie
To be fair, Madonna and Britney are from a time when dancing your ass on a stage was the norm. I don't think Taylor has done any hard core choreography. It's a different time, and I don't wanna jump on her, just because looks. My commentary is about her ability to be an entertainer.

I came across this and was like, jesus only Janet can look sexy in a trench coat =p

Yesss. I agree. Music vids are just celebs staring into the camera sitting in different places/positions, and minor booty shaking/hair flipping

Taylor Swift gives me neurotic control freak vibes, like she prob screams at "the help" behind closed doors for not properly color-coordinating her headbands.

TAYLOR SWIFT FOR ME... BY A MILE! 😢