DXP Survivor 2014 Part II Challenge (Page 3)

This topic was created in the Miscellaneous forum by StoicGoat on Monday, March 24, 2014 and has 492 replies.

You are on page out of 10 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

Time is up. No one got it exactly correct, but the whale was closest. Congratulations on winning your immunity for this vote. Dryer sheets: please PM your votes to me for whom you wish to vote off.

Your explanation: Nacho??s posts on page 9 beginning at 12:30:23 AM are perfect and would have won but for the fact that the links for Libra through Pisces don't work. He corrected the Cap one before the deadline, but that still leaves 5 errors to the whale's 4. Mr. Whale, your last two posts on page 10 are very close, but imperfect. Your link does not support Aries?? preference for Russian vodka. The link you offer for Virgo??s preference for Gin does not support this preference, either. The link you provided for the Sag does not work. And your link offers no reason why Capricorns should prefer Canadian whiskey over any other whiskey. However, all of those are irrelevant, because you still answered more correctly than Mr. Nacho.

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

Profanity filter: 1, Judge: 0

My judgment above is hereby reversed. Nacho's links all work; DXP's profanity filter altered his URL's. *turns off profanity filter*

NACHO, congratulations on winning your immunity for this vote. Dryer sheets: please PM your votes to me for whom you wish to vote off.

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

His post won, no irreparable harm has been done. The game will progress as though no error was made. You would want me to do the same for you if your positions were reversed.

Profile picture of NotYourAverageAquarius
@NotYourAverageAquarius
13 Years5,000+ PostsAquarius

Posted by GetMisted

Posted by StoicGoat
His post won, no irreparable harm has been done. The game will progress as though no error was made. You would want me to do the same for you if your positions were reversed.

There is more to this game than debates and challenges. It's strategy.

You made a decision. It should stay the way you posted it and let the votes fall where they may.

click to expand

Those subjects are not related to who wins an immunity but...
I already know that debating with you is pointless.

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

The fact of the matter is that the links did work. That I failed to realize that is no reason to penalize ANY of the players, yourself included, particularly when such can be corrected before we have moved forward.

Let's assume a man has been convicted of murder and is on death row. In the event the prosecution discovers evidence after his conviction that exonerates him, should it sweep that under the proverbial rug and continue to insist upon his guilt?

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

Posted by GetMisted

Posted by StoicGoat
The fact of the matter is that the links did work. That I failed to realize that is no reason to penalize ANY of the players, yourself included, particularly when such can be corrected before we have moved forward.

Let's assume a man has been convicted of murder and is on death row. In the event the prosecution discovers evidence after his conviction that exonerates him, should it sweep that under the proverbial rug and continue to insist upon his guilt?

If you want to have another immunity challenge and redermine a winner, I'm fine with that.

But having us recast votes, after you already deteremined a winner? No.

It's not fair. And it's borderlined cheating on your part.

Make it right Stoic.

click to expand

I was wrong. I did make it right. That making it right is not what you want does not make it wrong. Accept that.

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

Posted by GetMisted
I will not accept it.

Are you going to change the immunity winner after votes are casted every time? It's cheating. I want no part of it.

Nacho won the immunity challenge whether you like it or not. That I failed to recognize that has no bearing on the fact. It was a factual error. It has been corrected.

Profile picture of StoicGoat
@StoicGoat
14 Years1,000+ Posts

Posted by GetMisted

Posted by NotYourAverageAquarius

Posted by GetMisted
I will not accept it.

Are you going to change the immunity winner after votes are casted every time? It's cheating. I want no part of it.

Good I want no part you in it either.

I could play this game drama free without you in it.

Apparently you can't win without Goat rigging the game for you.

click to expand

Correcting an error that everyone can see is not cheating or rigging. It is making things right.

Profile picture of NotYourAverageAquarius
@NotYourAverageAquarius
13 Years5,000+ PostsAquarius

Posted by GetMisted

Posted by StoicGoat

Posted by GetMisted

Posted by NotYourAverageAquarius

Posted by GetMisted
I will not accept it.

Are you going to change the immunity winner after votes are casted every time? It's cheating. I want no part of it.

Good I want no part you in it either.

I could play this game drama free without you in it.

Apparently you can't win without Goat rigging the game for you.

Correcting an error that everyone can see is not cheating or rigging. It is making things right.

You allowed votes to be casted before YOUR mistake was made. And then you give immunity to the person who had votes casted against them. That's not okay and not a fix. It's cheatng.

click to expand

See the problem is... he made the mistake before you cast your vote.
😄