Gemini or Cancer for a Capricorn? (Page 2)

You are on page out of 2 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of Greentea
Greentea
@Greentea
10 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 3848 · Topics: 46
Posted by Greentea
Posted by RumiLove
Posted by Greentea
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by Greentea
Posted by CreatingChaos505
maybe sometimes we feel strong attractions because there is a karmic pull..a lesson?
Why do you need a lesson? Don't you have enough common sense to know where this is going...

You just wanna fuk.
Right, a lesson to keep my head screwed on straight.
Attraction is inevitable, however it's just that. If I wanted to fuk every guy I thought was handsome and was attracted to me... oh boy. ...

But it's just not right...water your own lawn and live your life.
Hi green tea 🙂

What are your placements if you don't mind me asking? =) ...your views / feelings about loved ones and some other things remind me of my papa 🙂
Cap sun, leeb moon, aqua venus and mars
click to expand

Oh, aries rising
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by RumiLove
Posted by Greentea
Posted by RumiLove
Posted by CreatingChaos505
maybe sometimes we feel strong attractions because there is a karmic pull..a lesson?
"karma"....is what you do with yourself and nothing more.

Physical attraction plays with the mind .. It creates illusions...on many levels...subconsciously. Dont fall for it.

You probably wanted that watery passion with your lover. I have seen a video where the astrologer said water mars can pick up on sensual things without their knowledge. Perhaps that is why you are sensing something in the Crab and you just want to experience that... But trust me, you wouldn't want to spoil something good.
Ya, there was a virgo at my work with a scorpio mars that had a huge crush on me (he's no longer there), he told me that he was really attracted to me, and didn't want to miss out on what can happen between us, after I went out on one date with him, and decided he's not right for me. I told him this during a walk, and that's when he said that. I told him, I'm just don't see anything there with us. He quit a month later.
It's sad..it feels like us water mars get intoxicated and... just hypnotized. 😐

Yeah... We quit, disappear, look for an escape..very typical of water mars.
click to expand

Is this why I am obsessive? My mars in scorpio?
Profile picture of PerceptiveSymmetry
PerceptiveSymmetry
@PerceptiveSymmetry
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 21 · Topics: 1
I am a Cancer who has been married to a Cap for going on 18 years. He is amazing and his passion for me seems unchanged since the day that we met. It's a relationship that can take a lot of patience, and in the early years if it wasn't for the kids we may have given up but I can't imagine living my life with anyone else and enjoying it half as much.

That being said, take a card from your Cancer's playbook. Let it go and focus on your relationship with your Gemini. If it's not the right one you'll figure that out without interference. If you are meant to be with the Cancer down the road she will surely appreciate you more for having enough integrity not to chase tail while you were with your current girlfriend.
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by PerceptiveSymmetry
I am a Cancer who has been married to a Cap for going on 18 years. He is amazing and his passion for me seems unchanged since the day that we met. It's a relationship that can take a lot of patience, and in the early years if it wasn't for the kids we may have given up but I can't imagine living my life with anyone else and enjoying it half as much.

That being said, take a card from your Cancer's playbook. Let it go and focus on your relationship with your Gemini. If it's not the right one you'll figure that out without interference. If you are meant to be with the Cancer down the road she will surely appreciate you more for having enough integrity not to chase tail while you were with your current girlfriend.
I really like your response because it pretty much resonates with how I have decided to go about this entire thing. I'm being respectful to my current girlfriend and continuing with our relationship and if things don't work out in the end, than it will be for the *right* reasons. Not because of someone else. Bad karma. Bad everything.

And you are right, I did appreciate and respect how she did the right thing when she was still with her boyfriend and blocked me out of her life and let her relationship rwith her ex run its course. And she has kept her distance from me now that she knows I am not single.

So, if we get together later on there is no dishonesty right off the bat.
Profile picture of lisabethur8
lisabeth
@lisabethur8
13 Years50,000+ Posts

Comments: 4373 · Posts: 50653 · Topics: 564
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by starwars
for a capricorn you should be assertive, but then your libra moon kicked in and here you are.
What do you mean?
click to expand

capricorn is exalted in mars, that's why they are ambitious and Climbing up the mountain..that isn't because they are lazing around.

libra is venus, so it loves the luxury. and enjoys venusian harem style. you pull people in, instead of you going to them analogy.
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by lisabethur8
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by starwars
for a capricorn you should be assertive, but then your libra moon kicked in and here you are.
What do you mean?
capricorn is exalted in mars, that's why they are ambitious and Climbing up the mountain..that isn't because they are lazing around.

libra is venus, so it loves the luxury. and enjoys venusian harem style. you pull people in, instead of you going to them analogy.
click to expand

So I am a walking contradiction?
Profile picture of LunarMaiden
LunarMaiden
@LunarMaiden
13 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 136 · Posts: 9227 · Topics: 154
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by RumiLove
Mr Cap.. Gemini is already your GF 😢 if its already harmonious why spoil it?

Okay..anyway, you said Cancer has Leo mars? How can it conjunct Pluto... Is her Pluto in Scorpio or Libra?

As far as passion goes.. I'm really not sure about it, its not the basis for choosing a life partner. And as you are a Capricorn yourself, who knows this better than you?

Your synastry with Cancer is good too. But if her mars in in Leo.. It squares your mars, perhaps the reason why you find her so alluring. Squares create for bad passionate attraction that burn each other out.
I'll write a more detailed comparison a little later.. I must go 🙂
Well, I wouldn't say it's all sunshine and rainbows. lol. But we do get along well. But our sexual styles are pretty different, given she is a Gemini. And in the long-term relationship that DOES matter. I mean, doesn't it?
click to expand

Can you explain the differences between you two sexually?
I find this very interesting.
Profile picture of LunarMaiden
LunarMaiden
@LunarMaiden
13 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 136 · Posts: 9227 · Topics: 154
Posted by OceanBoy88
Posted by CreatingChaos505
The thing is, the Gemini and I have been together for a couple years. My family likes her a lot. Things between us are pretty solid. I love her a lot.

The cancer girl stopped talking to me a long time ago because she had a BF, blocked me on facebook and everything. Which I respected. Then one day (2 years later!!) she popped into my life out of NOWHERE. And my attraction to her was still strong. She said she still always had me in the back of her mind all that time (her and her ex were together 6 years). And I sometimes feel like they say when someone returns to you it’s meant to be. Im surprised Im still attracted to her after all this time. I actually had to take her off my facebook 10 days after she friend requested me again because I couldn’t stand seeing her pop up in my feed.

But I’ve invested so much time into the By Ell itGemini now. And I do love her a lot. People always say “oh when you’re in a relationship it’s natural to be attracted to other people”. And I cant tell if it’s one of those scenarios or not. The attraction is just so mutually strong.
Can you see your self completely happy with the Gem? Marriage? Family? Does she understand you the way you want to be understood? Does she give you lots of BJs and keeps you sexually satisfied? Do both of your life goals have a common meeting point? Life is too short to not be fulfilled. Don't rely solely in astrology or be blinded by what can be lust. Capricorn and Cancer vs Capricorns and Gem are both relatively even in compatibility. Cancer is your opposite node and your both cardinal signs so it wouldn't be as great as say a Pisces or Scorpio. The cancer just got out of a relationship. I know 4 cancer girls. Out of those four, during the times they fell out of a long term relationship, they seem to uh, no offense cancer ladies, start hoeing around fuckin everything lol. Maybe your next in line. They seem very innocent at it but be careful . they know how to get what they want because they're do dam sexy and play the innocent girl role so well. Watch the Cancer girl. If shes fkirting around, let her fuck her system clean before you persue her full force. Think with your heart my friend. Not your dick.
click to expand

Oceanboy, Go fuck yourself please.
You know 4 Cancer women huh?
And these women represent us all eh?
You don't know this particular Cancer girls intentions.
Nor is it a fact that Cancer women start whoring around after we break up.

You make assumptions that have nothing to do with what he's feeling and what the situation actually is.

BTW, in the Astro world; Pisces males are known whores whether in or out of a relationship.

There are MANY Cancer/Goat long-term successful relationsh
Profile picture of LunarMaiden
LunarMaiden
@LunarMaiden
13 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 136 · Posts: 9227 · Topics: 154
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Ok, I feel like everyone here is getting the wrong idea.

The cancer girl who NOT being a s l u t at all. We met at bad timing in life. She did the respectful thing and remained with her bf.

Now she is single. She reached out to me once. That is all. She hasnt tried to break us up at all. She gets it.

My attraction to her is still strong. But I have remained respectful to my current GF (just like she did with her ex when she was attracted to me).

That's all this is about.
Please don't let a few losers on an astrology website convince you to demonize an innocent woman who is the object of your desires.
She didn't sign into DXP and create a thread saying she wanted to steal a Goat from his Gemini girlfriend.
There is some serious bias going on around her against Cancer women, just so you know.
And the usual suspects have attached themselves to this thread I see.

I can't tell you what to do, neither can anyone else on this site.
I can only do my best to help bring clarity.
Again what is your intentions with this Cancer woman?

You say you are attracted to her, yet in a long term relationship with someone else.
Do you see yourself breaking up with the Gemini to be with the Cancer woman?

So far all you speak of is attraction, not a desire to be apart of her life.
Do you see yourself waking up at 3am to help her fix a flat while she was driving home?
Is she someone you feel you could introduce to your family?
Profile picture of LunarMaiden
LunarMaiden
@LunarMaiden
13 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 136 · Posts: 9227 · Topics: 154
Posted by RumiLove
Posted by CreatingChaos505
I feel like if she starts dating someone new later on I am going to be sooo jealous. But why? How do I make this attraction just die off?
TIME....

Time takes care of everything ðŸ™
click to expand

Some attractions never die.
It Is what it is, call it synastry if you will.

The only question he needs to ask himself is, if he wants to leave a good relationship to pursue someone else he was and still is intensely attracted to.
If he feels strong enough, he will.
If he doesn't he will stay.




Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by Arielle83
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by hydorah
Posted by CreatingChaos505
The cancer girl stopped talking to me a long time ago because she had a BF, blocked me on facebook and everything. Which I respected. Then one day (2 years later!!) she popped into my life out of NOWHERE. And my attraction to her was still strong. She said she still always had me in the back of her mind all that time (her and her ex were together 6 years).
you need to tell her to fuck off.
Why? Sometimes people meet at bad timing. She wasn't a bitch to me about it, she did the honorable thing. She stuck it out with her asshole Aries boyfriend who treated her like crap and finally moved on (which I knew would happen, but she had to walk the steps).
So basically you got into a 2 year thing with a Gemini only to still want some cancer who was in a relationship you have an opinion on.

How do you know about her ex? Are you seriously going to dumb someone you invested 2 years of your life for someone with an hourglass figure? You know bishes don't stay skinny forever, right?

Does cancer know you have a gf? Does she want you even though she knows?
click to expand

This is really taking everything I said and putting it into a really cheap light. I really LIKED the cancer girl a long time ago. As a person, regardless of how she looked.

You can't really help who you are attracted to. No, I'm not dumping my Gemini.
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by Arielle83
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by PerceptiveSymmetry
I am a Cancer who has been married to a Cap for going on 18 years. He is amazing and his passion for me seems unchanged since the day that we met. It's a relationship that can take a lot of patience, and in the early years if it wasn't for the kids we may have given up but I can't imagine living my life with anyone else and enjoying it half as much.

That being said, take a card from your Cancer's playbook. Let it go and focus on your relationship with your Gemini. If it's not the right one you'll figure that out without interference. If you are meant to be with the Cancer down the road she will surely appreciate you more for having enough integrity not to chase tail while you were with your current girlfriend.
I really like your response because it pretty much resonates with how I have decided to go about this entire thing. I'm being respectful to my current girlfriend and continuing with our relationship and if things don't work out in the end, than it will be for the *right* reasons. Not because of someone else. Bad karma. Bad everything.

And you are right, I did appreciate and respect how she did the right thing when she was still with her boyfriend and blocked me out of her life and let her relationship rwith her ex run its course. And she has kept her distance from me now that she knows I am not single.

So, if we get together later on there is no dishonesty right off the bat.
Dude, you're dishonest as fuck. I was with a cap close to a year only to find out he was messaging all these single moms from high school and trying to meet up while I'm at work. Like how you're reconnecting with someone and wishing you were single.

Youre not worth it for either woman. I've never met a cap who didn't have a backup plan.

Lame ass ego.
click to expand

It sounds more to me like you are projecting your experience onto me. I'm sorry to hear that. Guess what? Were not messaging each other. As a matter of fact, she sent me one message, saying hello and asking how I was doing. I let her know I wasnt single. And she hasnt bothered me since, and I havent reached out to her since. It is just a strong attraction that is "just there" and has been for a long time.
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by Arielle83
I'm sure your Gemini gf will be real happy to meet the cancer "friend" you're considering a future with, over her.
You're not going to like my answer but you do realize I haven't taken vows and love is always a risk? If I think someone is going to be a better match for me, long term, than that is who I will decide to be with. Does that make sense? Or does it make more sense to stay in a relationship, that is not even a marriage, that is not the right one for you?
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by Arielle83


Ya I'm projecting my Capricorn experience, since you are wondering which astrological experience is best for you (Gemini/cancer).

As a cancer who has been with a Capricorn, the cancer will not be happy knowing what you might do to make HER a better option over the Gemini.

Cancer doesn't want a love triangle or drama.

I'd be disgusted knowing you were in a relationship and you thought of me as an option. You know why?

Because you can do it to me? Like I said, cap is always looking for a better option.

But, I'm guessing you just want a bunch of strangers telling you, astrologically, this scenario is "okay", because the better option is simple "cancer".

Look a bit deeper, Capricorn, your shallowness would turn a cancer off.
Alright, I think you make a valid point. And I do see where you are coming from.
I realize it's...not an ideal circumstance. But, in all honesty, what DO you do when you are in a scenario where you REALLY were into someone (think of someone from your life who you were SUPER interested in) who had a really similar family background to yours, same sense of humor, same interests and emotional styles, and just other really uncanny similarities...but when you first met them the timing was off. You move on. But then they reappear in your life. what do you do in that scenario? I am asking a genuine question.
Profile picture of CreatingChaos505
CreatingChaos505
@CreatingChaos505
9 Years

Comments: 0 · Posts: 198 · Topics: 3
Posted by Arielle83
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by Arielle83


Ya I'm projecting my Capricorn experience, since you are wondering which astrological experience is best for you (Gemini/cancer).

As a cancer who has been with a Capricorn, the cancer will not be happy knowing what you might do to make HER a better option over the Gemini.

Cancer doesn't want a love triangle or drama.

I'd be disgusted knowing you were in a relationship and you thought of me as an option. You know why?

Because you can do it to me? Like I said, cap is always looking for a better option.

But, I'm guessing you just want a bunch of strangers telling you, astrologically, this scenario is "okay", because the better option is simple "cancer".

Look a bit deeper, Capricorn, your shallowness would turn a cancer off.
Alright, I think you make a valid point. And I do see where you are coming from.
I realize it's...not an ideal circumstance. But, in all honesty, what DO you do when you are in a scenario where you REALLY were into someone (think of someone from your life who you were SUPER interested in) who had a really similar family background to yours, same sense of humor, same interests and emotional styles, and just other really uncanny similarities...but when you first met them the timing was off. You move on. But then they reappear in your life. what do you do in that scenario? I am asking a genuine question.
Think of how many ppl are in the world and the possible mix matches of personality, background and compatibilities that are possible. Heck look at astrology charts if you're basing it on that.

The point is there are more ppl in the world for you than just this one. And ppl change, she might not be the same because you're basing this all on an ideal.

If you're over the Gemini then break up cuz you don't believe in the relationship. Don't hold onto her until cancer wants you etc because you may self sabotage Gemini just to get the cancer.

That's not fair to someone you dedicated 2years of your life with.

Can you be single and not in a relationship?
click to expand

Yeah, but very few you actually share chemistry with that transcends friendship. At least from my experience.

I'm capable of being single. And that's probably something I should consider at this point.
Profile picture of Greentea
Greentea
@Greentea
10 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1 · Posts: 3848 · Topics: 46
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by Arielle83
Posted by CreatingChaos505
Posted by Arielle83


Ya I'm projecting my Capricorn experience, since you are wondering which astrological experience is best for you (Gemini/cancer).

As a cancer who has been with a Capricorn, the cancer will not be happy knowing what you might do to make HER a better option over the Gemini.

Cancer doesn't want a love triangle or drama.

I'd be disgusted knowing you were in a relationship and you thought of me as an option. You know why?

Because you can do it to me? Like I said, cap is always looking for a better option.

But, I'm guessing you just want a bunch of strangers telling you, astrologically, this scenario is "okay", because the better option is simple "cancer".

Look a bit deeper, Capricorn, your shallowness would turn a cancer off.
Alright, I think you make a valid point. And I do see where you are coming from.
I realize it's...not an ideal circumstance. But, in all honesty, what DO you do when you are in a scenario where you REALLY were into someone (think of someone from your life who you were SUPER interested in) who had a really similar family background to yours, same sense of humor, same interests and emotional styles, and just other really uncanny similarities...but when you first met them the timing was off. You move on. But then they reappear in your life. what do you do in that scenario? I am asking a genuine question.
Think of how many ppl are in the world and the possible mix matches of personality, background and compatibilities that are possible. Heck look at astrology charts if you're basing it on that.

The point is there are more ppl in the world for you than just this one. And ppl change, she might not be the same because you're basing this all on an ideal.

If you're over the Gemini then break up cuz you don't believe in the relationship. Don't hold onto her until cancer wants you etc because you may self sabotage Gemini just to get the cancer.

That's not fair to someone you dedicated 2years of your life with.

Can you be single and not in a relationship?
Yeah, but very few you actually share chemistry with that transcends friendship. At least from my experience.

I'm capable of being single. And that's probably something I should consider at this point.
click to expand

Lol, you're only considering it so you can go after the cancer dude.

How was your relationship with the Gemini before the canc