Cancer Moon or Scorpio Moon? (Page 2)

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by PhoenixStorm

I thought all 3 were compatible since they’re all of the same element? No?

The Virgo I was dating briefly earlier this summer had a Pisces moon. I liked him a lot but yeah he seemed wishy washy. He is the only Pisces moon I’ve dated, that I’m aware of.

When I was younger I’ve gotten to know 3 different Scorpio moons. A cancer sun with Scorpio moon. A Capricorn with Scorpio moon and a Taurus with Scorpio moon. All 3 could be very vindictive and mean as hell when angry. My sensitive ass cancer moon wasn’t having it. Lol

I was with another cancer moon for over 10 years. Despite the fact that he broke my heart, I don’t think anyone has ever or will ever understand me and handle me the way he did. It’s a damn shame he couldn’t keep his dick in his pants.

All have reasons they will work, and all have reasons why they won't. The fact one is a Scorpio moon is a pretty good reason why one of the three won't work, so for me it was process of elimination lol!

Scorpio moons with fire moons: hell no

But... but I love scorp mooners 😭

Ok, I admit. I honestly think fire moons are extreamly attractive, and admirable. But you can deny you like to fight at times, and can bite pretty hard. It has a tendency to wake the up the demon in every scorpio moon 😈

You can't deny that it can be hot asf also 😉

It's quite literally as hot as it gets. I've been on both sides of fire moon relationships. My best relationships have been with fire moon women. Unfortunately for me they ended as passionate and fiery as they started. Deep down I still have hope though lol.

I think you need one with a Leo moon and Scorp ASC. Sun/moon conjunction and moon/ASC conjunction...you both would adore each other and completely understand each other really without words. The connection is insane and that's with either or...so I can only imagine how'd it be to find someone with both aspects.

I'm not trying to be bias either 😂 ...I've just experienced the aspects before...just not both with the same person.

click to expand

I've only been with Aries moon, and it was literally ww3. A Leo moon might actually work though due to my leo sun. If they had a few water placements it would likely work. Also most of my close friends have Sag sun, so I know I love the energy. My biggest worry is honestly me lol. I have a tendency to take fire energy to the edge. I also have Virgo mercury. So take a Leo sun, scorpio moon, Virgo mercury, with cancer venus and put them in a household with another person.

Moral of the story is we all are going fucking crazy lol!

Posted by Soul

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by LostinmyMind11

Posted by Soul

Posted by PhoenixStorm

I thought all 3 were compatible since they’re all of the same element? No?

The Virgo I was dating briefly earlier this summer had a Pisces moon. I liked him a lot but yeah he seemed wishy washy. He is the only Pisces moon I’ve dated, that I’m aware of.

When I was younger I’ve gotten to know 3 different Scorpio moons. A cancer sun with Scorpio moon. A Capricorn with Scorpio moon and a Taurus with Scorpio moon. All 3 could be very vindictive and mean as hell when angry. My sensitive ass cancer moon wasn’t having it. Lol

I was with another cancer moon for over 10 years. Despite the fact that he broke my heart, I don’t think anyone has ever or will ever understand me and handle me the way he did. It’s a damn shame he couldn’t keep his dick in his pants.

All have reasons they will work, and all have reasons why they won't. The fact one is a Scorpio moon is a pretty good reason why one of the three won't work, so for me it was process of elimination lol!

Scorpio moons with fire moons: hell no

But... but I love scorp mooners 😭

Ok, I admit. I honestly think fire moons are extreamly attractive, and admirable. But you can deny you like to fight at times, and can bite pretty hard. It has a tendency to wake the up the demon in every scorpio moon 😈

You can't deny that it can be hot asf also 😉

It's quite literally as hot as it gets. I've been on both sides of fire moon relationships. My best relationships have been with fire moon women. Unfortunately for me they ended as passionate and fiery as they started. Deep down I still have hope though lol.

I think you need one with a Leo moon and Scorp ASC. Sun/moon conjunction and moon/ASC conjunction...you both would adore each other and completely understand each other really without words. The connection is insane and that's with either or...so I can only imagine how'd it be to find someone with both aspects.

I'm not trying to be bias either 😂 ...I've just experienced the aspects before...just not both with the same person.

I've only been with Aries moon, and it was literally ww3. A Leo moon might actually work though due to my leo sun. If they had a few water placements it would likely work. Also most of my close friends have Sag sun, so I know I love the energy. My biggest worry is honestly me lol. I have a tendency to take fire energy to the edge. I also have Virgo mercury. So take a Leo sun, scorpio moon, Virgo mercury, with cancer venus and put them in a household with another person.

Moral of the story is we all are going fucking crazy lol!

click to expand

Yeah that might be too much fire if their sun was also a fire sun...but someone with Jupiter in the 1st might work ...it'll give them that Sag flare (again not being bias here lol). But def someone with some scorp...whether that be Venus, mars or ASC...they will gladly go to the edge and under with you...no hesitation...I honestly think they'd be your perfect match 🤷🏼‍♀️.

I never dated a pisces mooner

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

click to expand

No, burn it.. send it to hell !

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

Tbh its hard for anyone to get with a Scorpio moon lol. In arguments we have a tendency to dissect people, then feel nothing from it. Scorpio moons can be cold at times. I've noticed its hard for people to deal when a Scorpio sun, or even moon once they tap into their Pluto energy. It might not even be because of you they tapped into it, but they did, and you will certainly feel it.

I have a Scorpio Venus, I get along with Scorpio moons just fine as well! 😛 I love water moons. I sooth all those Scorpio moon worries and make them feel secure when they have those cute, crazy jealousy flare ups! 😆

See thats a really smart way to go about it. If you can deal with some of us, or potentially help a Scorpio moon through turmoil you will end up with a loyal friend of lover who would literally kill someone to keep you safe. Or get revenge on someone who truly did you wrong.

I think Cancer moons in general are pretty empathetic when we are involved with someone romantically. I'm a;ways nurturing and very understanding with my partner. I just want to help and understand in the end, and if I need to fix something I will. I see insecurity as love that the person has for me, so I like it. It's a turn on and I want to sooth it, instead of flare it up, show them they're appreciated. 🙂

click to expand

"I think Cancer moons in general are pretty empathetic when we are involved with someone romantically. I'm a;ways nurturing and very understanding with my partner. I just want to help and understand in the end, and if I need to fix something I will. I see insecurity as love that the person has for me, so I like it. It's a turn on and I want to sooth it, instead of flare it up, show them they're appreciated. "

exactly

and some of them who showed us insecurity and are healed by us, they suddenly feel some kind of "power" or something, what they maybe never experienced and use it to boost their ego

its always a mystery to me, how understanding is percieved as weaknees to be used, but maybe people who are weak themselves see the "understanding love" as patronising and want to punish for it? or they think its like with them, that understanding means total submission?

Posted by WateryGem

Posted by SeaLion

Which one is more compatable with Pisces Moon?

I would have to say it would depend on the Sun. My girlfriend is married to a Scorpio moon, she has her moon in Pisces.

I know of a couple with Pisces and Cancer moon, I think the pisces moon is very submissive to the Cancer and Scorpio moon, unless, it's a Scorpio Sun.

I find Pisces moons to be very sweet!!! I feel very protective of them. I don't know if I would like a man with this moon, though.

click to expand

I do feel more submissive with the cancer moon, but it also feels very comfortable and warm to be with him. With the Scorp moon, it was a little uncomfortable at first but I feel more balanced with him and I feel like I can open up more to him. The cancer moon is a Pisces with venus and Mars in Pisces sag rising. The scorp moon is Virgo with Virgo venus and cancer Mars, libra rising. I'm a Leo with Leo venus and cancer Mars sag rising.

Posted by 777

Cancer moon whine too much

Scorpio moon make too many excuses

I whine in private. The other person would never know. I’m all about manifesting what I want. You can’t do that by just complaining. Actions need to happen.

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

No, burn it.. send it to hell !

click to expand

Lol. Maybe my mutable sun doesn’t mind the dreamy, flakey bits of the Pisces moon. I’m fine with people taking their time and them coming and going.

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

No, burn it.. send it to hell !

Lol. Maybe my mutable sun doesn’t mind the dreamy, flakey bits of the Pisces moon. I’m fine with people taking their time and them coming and going.

click to expand

Don't mind anything dreamy/abstract

But from my experience they never learn from their experiences but keep going through the same (e)motions.

Something like DiCaprio's character in Shutter Island,

< Tragedy & enlightenment

> rewind

> start over again

like shit never happened.

Posted by Pandora101

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

Tbh its hard for anyone to get with a Scorpio moon lol. In arguments we have a tendency to dissect people, then feel nothing from it. Scorpio moons can be cold at times. I've noticed its hard for people to deal when a Scorpio sun, or even moon once they tap into their Pluto energy. It might not even be because of you they tapped into it, but they did, and you will certainly feel it.

I have a Scorpio Venus, I get along with Scorpio moons just fine as well! 😛 I love water moons. I sooth all those Scorpio moon worries and make them feel secure when they have those cute, crazy jealousy flare ups! 😆

See thats a really smart way to go about it. If you can deal with some of us, or potentially help a Scorpio moon through turmoil you will end up with a loyal friend of lover who would literally kill someone to keep you safe. Or get revenge on someone who truly did you wrong.

I think Cancer moons in general are pretty empathetic when we are involved with someone romantically. I'm a;ways nurturing and very understanding with my partner. I just want to help and understand in the end, and if I need to fix something I will. I see insecurity as love that the person has for me, so I like it. It's a turn on and I want to sooth it, instead of flare it up, show them they're appreciated. 🙂

"I think Cancer moons in general are pretty empathetic when we are involved with someone romantically. I'm a;ways nurturing and very understanding with my partner. I just want to help and understand in the end, and if I need to fix something I will. I see insecurity as love that the person has for me, so I like it. It's a turn on and I want to sooth it, instead of flare it up, show them they're appreciated. "

exactly

and some of them who showed us insecurity and are healed by us, they suddenly feel some kind of "power" or something, what they maybe never experienced and use it to boost their ego

its always a mystery to me, how understanding is percieved as weaknees to be used, but maybe people who are weak themselves see the "understanding love" as patronising and want to punish for it? or they think its like with them, that understanding means total submission?

click to expand

Hmmm I see what you’re saying but my sun sign won’t allow people to take advantage of me. I have too much of a big ego. And when I see they are undeserving of my understanding and kindness, I will cut it off swiftly. I end up being the one who punished them instead. Probably my Scorpio Venus that helps with that. Nothing gets passed me when I am kind and it’s used in a manipulative way. I’m not having any of it.

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

No, burn it.. send it to hell !

Lol. Maybe my mutable sun doesn’t mind the dreamy, flakey bits of the Pisces moon. I’m fine with people taking their time and them coming and going.

Don't mind anything dreamy/abstract

But from my experience they never learn from their experiences but keep going through the same (e)motions.

Something like DiCaprio's character in Shutter Island,

< Tragedy & enlightenment

> rewind

> start over again

like shit never happened.

click to expand

Lmao. I’ve never had the pleasure of being in a relationship with a Pisces mooner so I don’t have much experience in love with one.

Posted by LittleStar

Scorpio Moon isn’t compatible with either IMO.

So I would say Cancer and Pisces.

I’m more a fan of the Moon being connected to the others sun than Moon-Moon.

I just can’t do Cancer Sun men. I don’t know why. It’s not a good combo for me at all. They are like extra big babies who are needy, stubborn and attention seeking.

How am I going to get the attention I need by catering to their asses! 😩😂🤣

Posted by Ararule

Posted by FknMeow

Cancer moon.

Scorpio moon doesnt even get to be the third water moon anymore. Ophiuchus does.

wait this is western astrology there is no Ophiuchus. I like the the Ophiuchus though which means my moon is it.

click to expand

This is my sign if there was a 13th one.

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by enfant_terrible

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

No, burn it.. send it to hell !

Lol. Maybe my mutable sun doesn’t mind the dreamy, flakey bits of the Pisces moon. I’m fine with people taking their time and them coming and going.

Don't mind anything dreamy/abstract

But from my experience they never learn from their experiences but keep going through the same (e)motions.

Something like DiCaprio's character in Shutter Island,

< Tragedy & enlightenment

> rewind

> start over again

like shit never happened.

Lmao. I’ve never had the pleasure of being in a relationship with a Pisces mooner so I don’t have much experience in love with one.

click to expand

Well you dont have to be in a relationship with someone to know them closely

Posted by LittleStar

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by LittleStar

Scorpio Moon isn’t compatible with either IMO.

So I would say Cancer and Pisces.

I’m more a fan of the Moon being connected to the others sun than Moon-Moon.

I just can’t do Cancer Sun men. I don’t know why. It’s not a good combo for me at all. They are like extra big babies who are needy, stubborn and attention seeking.

How am I going to get the attention I need by catering to their asses! 😩😂🤣

Like if you have a Pisces Moon I’d look more at Taurus and Capricorn suns. I think water-water could be overwhelming.

click to expand

I can do Scorpio suns but that’s about it.

I dunno everyone seems to think cancer moon but then everything everyone says about cancer moon makes me want to rather deal with Scorpio Moon 🤔😂

Posted by Notmyrealname

Agree with everything @saggurl88 has said in this thread 👍 water moons ftw

Aww so sweet! Thank you. 🏆 😜❤️

Posted by SeaLion

I dunno everyone seems to think cancer moon but then everything everyone says about cancer moon makes me want to rather deal with Scorpio Moon 🤔😂

Then you don’t like being nurtured and you like jealousy more. Nothing wrong with Scorpio moons either. I love them too.

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by SeaLion

I dunno everyone seems to think cancer moon but then everything everyone says about cancer moon makes me want to rather deal with Scorpio Moon 🤔😂

Then you don’t like being nurtured and you like jealousy more. Nothing wrong with Scorpio moons either. I love them too.

click to expand

It was more the moodiness that is turning me off. I was married to a cancer sun man... was like being married to another woman 🙄

I guess I would say neither lol. I'll never have an experience with either so take that as you will.

It's hard enough dealing with my scorp moon, let alone another water moon.😅

Posted by Timon

Posted by SeaLion

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by SeaLion

I dunno everyone seems to think cancer moon but then everything everyone says about cancer moon makes me want to rather deal with Scorpio Moon 🤔😂

Then you don’t like being nurtured and you like jealousy more. Nothing wrong with Scorpio moons either. I love them too.

It was more the moodiness that is turning me off. I was married to a cancer sun man... was like being married to another woman 🙄

Was he a cancer moon though? Scorpio moons can be very moody too but in a different way. I find cancer moons to be more sensitive and get hurt easily. That's where their moodiness comes from. Scorpio moons moodiness is more angry moody. 😛

click to expand

No. Just cancer sun. I agree. Scorpio moon is more angry moodiness. But I can deal with that kind of moodiness better than over sensitive moodiness. Atleast with anger moodiness I can understand where it comes from and it is more predictable.

Posted by Notmyrealname

Posted by Black-Mamba

This leo moon is allergic to all 3

just making my opinion known

Totally understandable

click to expand

😂 I don't blame you... I wouldnt want to deal with us either

Posted by Plague

Posted by virgoOPPP

Posted by saggurl88

Posted by Soul

Imo Cancer moon is better for Pisces moon. Personally I agree with the post above.

I agree with this. All the horror stories I see hear about Pisces moons, I don't get at all. I see nothing wrong with them.

and pisces moon men are sweethearts

Also can be delusional as fuck. Spent 5 years with one. Lies, cheating, kinda funny everyone thinks Pisces moon men are incapable of being whores.

click to expand

Holy shit, Virgo Sun, Pisces Moon, Leo Rising...I'm pretty much a mess to most people but seeing something good about a Pisces Moon is delightful I must say. Although about the whore comment, I have never cheated so I got that going for me.

I have no experience with Scorpio moons (or suns). Used to joke that they hide under a stone when they see me.

Cancer moon on an Aqua sun left me cold. He was my exclusive fuck buddy for about one year....I was in it for our Aqua Mars/Venus conjunction, not for his moon. He, on the other hand, started to act increasingly possessive. I had to end it.

Cancer moon on a Cap sun was a different story. We went on three dates before he ghosted me, lol. At that time, I didn't even know that there was a term for what he did: ghosting. Searching for answers online landed me on dxpnet, where I spent my first year on the Cap forum, lol. I cared enough to investigate his whereabouts...found out he went back to his Aqua (ex?)girlfriend.

Posted by Undine

I have no experience with Scorpio moons (or suns). Used to joke that they hide under a stone when they see me.

Cancer moon on an Aqua sun left me cold. He was my exclusive fuck buddy for about one year....I was in it for our Aqua Mars/Venus conjunction, not for his moon. He, on the other hand, started to act increasingly possessive. I had to end it.

Cancer moon on a Cap sun was a different story. We went on three dates before he ghosted me, lol. At that time, I didn't even know that there was a term for what he did: ghosting. Searching for answers online landed me on dxpnet, where I spent my first year on the Cap forum, lol. I cared enough to investigate his whereabouts...found out he went back to his Aqua (ex?)girlfriend.

My best friend is a Cap sun Cancer moon. She can be cold with men but I've also seen her sensitive side. Honestly, imo you're probably better off. I wouldn't date her if I was a guy.

Posted by Gobby

Several pages in and still no-one's mentioned anything about Hades moon (which I have)...

Based on the fact we're on an astrology forum, what the fuck's wrong with you all? Pull your socks up, please!

I don't know what a hades moon means.

Posted by kingflo

Cancer moon because Pisces moon understand cancer moon. Plus cancer moon is less evil

Don't tell me you've got a Pisces moon...?!

Posted by kingflo

Posted by Undine

Posted by kingflo

Cancer moon because Pisces moon understand cancer moon. Plus cancer moon is less evil

Don't tell me you've got a Pisces moon...?!

what wrong with that

click to expand

Noooo, it's a nice surprise! What's your sun sign...? Pisces?

Posted by kingflo

Cancer moon because Pisces moon understand cancer moon. Plus cancer moon is less evil

I like Scorpios more I think. Sun and moons. I think Scorpio has a stronger influence in my chart.

I like cancers and get along with them really well but there is something about them that just gets under my skin. Might be because they all fall in my 8th house.

Posted by SeaLion

Which one is more compatable with Pisces Moon?

I had a close friend. She's Pisces moon. M scorp moon. We just understood each other.

In my opinion Scorpio handles Pieces better

Posted by ElvisStalinWoods

Now that I'm dealing with a cancer sun, Scorpio moon, I definitely support Pisces and cancer moon more.

I love this Scorpio moon woman to death, but the push-pull on the intimacy and communicative openness level drives me mad. She's going to fucking end me.

Are you a cancer moon or a Pisces moon?

Posted by ElvisStalinWoods

Posted by SeaLion

Posted by ElvisStalinWoods

Now that I'm dealing with a cancer sun, Scorpio moon, I definitely support Pisces and cancer moon more.

I love this Scorpio moon woman to death, but the push-pull on the intimacy and communicative openness level drives me mad. She's going to fucking end me.

Are you a cancer moon or a Pisces moon?

Fish

click to expand

I know how u feel with the push and pull and communication. Dating a Scorp moon as well. But....dated Cancer moons too and those were worse.

I prefer scorpio moon over cancer moon.

Scorpio moon alot of the times seem more witty. Cancer moons typically think like children, and try to hard to be in tune with other people. Kind of vindictive like scorpio sun.

But I prefer cancer sun over scorpio sun

Im actually here because of pisces moon 😭😭 to complain. I said i will not entangle myself with a pisces moon again but why you so nice and dreamy

I guess my pisces rising is to blame

Posted by fishcrabscale2

Im actually here because of pisces moon 😭😭 to complain. I said i will not entangle myself with a pisces moon again but why you so nice and dreamy

I guess my pisces rising is to blame

Awe. I've never dated a Pisces rising so I couldn't say. I would imagine you guys would be dreamy too. ❤