Ask a Transgender Woman (Page 2)

You are on page out of 5 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by -Flo-
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by -Flo-
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by -Flo-
Posted by GetMisted
Posted by -Flo-
Do you not answer my question because it reveals the truth?

I am the experience of a woman who has had a tranny come in between a family, I want to know answers.

This is a sensitive topic, this is a topic people need to be aware about. None of that festive, none of that pride, none of those parades. This is real life shit.
jfc the truth comes out. Happy I avoided this


This is what I've gone through. This is my life and not in any sort of way a joke.

I'm glad I avoided you too..


Continue going thru life betating others because your ex was a douche..

Makes perfect sense.


I'm asking questions. To back up my statement, Milani was doing the same thing with the aqua guy and his girl. So in sense, no I can't respect that.

You weren't even being understanding to how I felt without assumptions. This is a painful experience.
You drunkenly lit me up in PM because I mentioned in a thread about a trans woman I was interested in.

You and I are not, never were, and never will be "together".

the jealousy and hatefulness I witnessed that night was enough. Maybe you went through something horrible.. But that's no reason to berate others that had no involvement in your past. It's time for you to grow up and stop playing victim.


Thanks for putting my shit on blast, you're a dick.

Thank you.

click to expand

I agree with GetMisted - You are pushing your experience on others or trying your hardest to compare it with my experience. There is no relation.
Profile picture of DepthAndDeath
AneemA
@DepthAndDeath
8 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 55 · Posts: 942 · Topics: 15
From your pov as a transgender, what are some feminine energies and masculine energies do you have, and if there has been a significant gap of prominence within you?

I believe every individual have both. With which has different amount level to each one of us.

And so does your transformation is a way for you to promote your feminine energies as opposed to masculine ones?

Does it have anything to do with your sexual preference?

Profile picture of Gemitati
Gemitati
@Gemitati
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 2057 · Posts: 38091 · Topics: 1026
Posted by P-Angel
Why would anyone have questions?

I think we all get what a transgender is, right?



Sounds to me like you have something to say, and so are trying to prompt people into starting the conversation.


Yea! People know what transgender is are but everyone including you curious about what's between legs!

I am wondering if it had been discussed already in one of 7 pages...
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?

click to expand

"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with your notion that that is what defines a woman.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
No not at all. Kids identify their gender at a very young age. Look at Jazz Jennings. Her parents knew she was meant to be a girl from a very young age and she has now blossomed into a beautiful young woman.

As for me, when I came out to my mom that I was transgender, she said "I knew already"... I think its one of those things as parents - they know if their child is gay or for this instance, transgender. Its just a matter of how accepting the parent is of knowing this knowledge and their support/love for their child.
Isn't being Trans gendered being gay. I mean you date guys

How do men feel when you tell them
click to expand

If the transgendered individual is a woman, and she dates men, then she isn't gay - she's heterosexual.

Not only referring to you, but it takes effort to try and understand instead of clinging to personal prejudices and fallacies because it's about accepting that people are complex and the world isn't as black and white as many of us (myself included) were raised to believe because it's what's convenient. An LGBTQ activist came to campus and presented a seminar that cleared all of that confusion up. I went in with a similar ignorant thought processes as some of the posters here and I left more enlightened. The trick is to go in assuming you're wrong and ask questions correct yourself.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by saweetz1988
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
Man the giving birth part and raising a child.. it takes a real woman... and I wish I can be a man on my next life that's for sure
So a woman who has had a C-section or who can't have babies, isn't "a real woman"? Or is she a "real woman" once she's adopted and raised a child? Or does that not count either?
You sound stupid a hell. Hmmmmm gonna argue why the sky is blue too
click to expand

I'm challenging the arrogant assumption of what a "real woman" is. There is nothing that makes one sound more ignorant than beginning a sentence with "A real...woman/man" or what have you. No. If a woman can't give birth she isn't any less "real" than a woman who has quintuplets.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?


"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with that notion that that is what defines a woman.
what is a vagina and breasts if they do not do what they are meant to do? they are not there for looks, they serve purposes. same with men. i can make myself a trans man and have the whole shebang - penis, testicles, muscles and all. i can have 'the look', but i will never be able to perform like a man. i cannot get erections, ejaculate or produce sperm. i can feel manly and live that way, but some aspects of manhood will forever be lost to me since i naturally am not one. are we just going by how we feel and want things to be? some things cannot be other things, no matter how hard you try to change them.
click to expand

So you were claiming that that's what defines a woman. Stand by your words.

If a man has erectile dysfunction, is he any less "real"? That argument is false intrinsically. Plenty of women have breast that don't produce milk - so the breasts aren't doing "what they are supposed to do." So, are they not "real women"? What of the women who are barren - their uteruses aren't functioning the way it's supposed to. Are they not "real women"?

What is more - why does it concern you whether or not she will ever feel about her body as you do? What is it that you're doing? Is this you feeling sorry for her that she'll never push one out through her vagina?
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by DepthAndDeath
From your pov as a transgender, what are some feminine energies and masculine energies do you have, and if there has been a significant gap of prominence within you?

I believe every individual have both. With which has different amount level to each one of us.

And so does your transformation is a way for you to promote your feminine energies as opposed to masculine ones?

Does it have anything to do with your sexual preference?


Hi, yes I think I definitely have more female energies. Being a female now, I feel 'in tuned' with myself.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by saweetz1988
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
Man the giving birth part and raising a child.. it takes a real woman... and I wish I can be a man on my next life that's for sure
So a woman who has had a C-section or who can't have babies, isn't "a real woman"? Or is she a "real woman" once she's adopted and raised a child? Or does that not count either?
You sound stupid a hell. Hmmmmm gonna argue why the sky is blue too
I'm challenging the arrogant assumption of what a "real woman" is. There is nothing that makes one sound more ignorant than beginning a sentence with "A real...woman/man" or what have you. No. If a woman can't give birth she isn't any less "real" than a woman who has quintuplets.
Apples and oranges. You're obviously reaching. We're talking about biology difference in women and men

Not womb issues of women.

click to expand

What aspect of the biology?
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
No not at all. Kids identify their gender at a very young age. Look at Jazz Jennings. Her parents knew she was meant to be a girl from a very young age and she has now blossomed into a beautiful young woman.

As for me, when I came out to my mom that I was transgender, she said "I knew already"... I think its one of those things as parents - they know if their child is gay or for this instance, transgender. Its just a matter of how accepting the parent is of knowing this knowledge and their support/love for their child.
Isn't being Trans gendered being gay. I mean you date guys

How do men feel when you tell them
If the transgendered individual is a woman, and she dates men, then she isn't gay - she's heterosexual.

Not only referring to you, but it takes effort to try and understand instead of clinging to personal prejudices and fallacies because it's about accepting that people are complex and the world isn't as black and white as many of us (myself included) were raised to believe because it's what's convenient. An LGBTQ activist came to campus and presented a seminar that cleared all of that confusion up. I went in with a similar ignorant thought processes as some of the posters here and I left more enlightened. The trick is to go in assuming you're wrong and ask questions correct yourself.
A man born chemically as a man is a man. If he gets surgery he's closer to being a woman but not a man, so yes the person with him is not gay, because he's having sex in a vagina

But the man is still a man. His DNA hasn't changed only the superficial parts

He can act more woman than a woman but biologically he's still a man
click to expand

What do you mean "born chemically"? That's both reductive and incorrect. Do you think gender and sex are one in the same?
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?


"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with your notion that that is what defines a woman.
What defines a woman? Please do tell, since ignorant is so prevalent in you
click to expand

THAT is the point - I don't get to define that for you. You don't get to define that for the OP. Society doesn't get to define that for any of us.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by saweetz1988
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
Man the giving birth part and raising a child.. it takes a real woman... and I wish I can be a man on my next life that's for sure
So a woman who has had a C-section or who can't have babies, isn't "a real woman"? Or is she a "real woman" once she's adopted and raised a child? Or does that not count either?
You sound stupid a hell. Hmmmmm gonna argue why the sky is blue too
I'm challenging the arrogant assumption of what a "real woman" is. There is nothing that makes one sound more ignorant than beginning a sentence with "A real...woman/man" or what have you. No. If a woman can't give birth she isn't any less "real" than a woman who has quintuplets.
Apples and oranges. You're obviously reaching. We're talking about biology difference in women and men

Not womb issues of women.


What aspect of the biology?


I would say physiology and brain chemicals.

If it's not natural it's not natural

Transgendered are gay people who want to be a different gender.

They are not heterosexual wanting to be a different gender.

Chemically they're born gay than they decide i want to be a man or a woman

I think it's a coping mechanism

click to expand

No, because a person can be born with male genitalia, but feel female but still be attracted to men.

If my "brain chemicals" are telling me I'm a man, but I have a vagina - which is it? "Brain chemicals" and physiology can be in conflict. Which gets precedence? I know which one appeases society and protects it from feeling...uncomfortable.

Do you believe sex and gender are the same?
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?


"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with that notion that that is what defines a woman.
what is a vagina and breasts if they do not do what they are meant to do? they are not there for looks, they serve purposes. same with men. i can make myself a trans man and have the whole shebang - penis, testicles, muscles and all. i can have 'the look', but i will never be able to perform like a man. i cannot get erections, ejaculate or produce sperm. i can feel manly and live that way, but some aspects of manhood will forever be lost to me since i naturally am not one. are we just going by how we feel and want things to be? some things cannot be other things, no matter how hard you try to change them.
So you were claiming that that's what defines a woman. Stand by your words.

If a man has erectile dysfunction, is he any less "real"? That argument is false intrinsically. Plenty of women have breast that don't produce milk - so the breasts aren't doing "what they are supposed to do." So, are they not "real women"?
how about you stop trying to twist and make them mean what you want them to mean? anyway, body changes do not make you what you aren't. example, a white woman recently tanned her skin and kinked her hair so she could identify as black. despite what she feels like she is, in truth, her dna says she is a white woman and will always be a white woman. some things do not change. bodily purposes don't either. let's face it, there are things men have that make them men. there are things women have that make them women. a man has erectile dysfunction, but at one point in time he had a working, functioning penis. unlike transmen, who never had and never will have one. unless there is a miraculous breakthrough in technology. so, how, in what way, are they real men? they are not. they are synthetic. i dont care how you dress it up, some things are what they are.

click to expand

Using skin tone to talk about race is also false and, unfortunately, that ignorance is also rampant.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
No not at all. Kids identify their gender at a very young age. Look at Jazz Jennings. Her parents knew she was meant to be a girl from a very young age and she has now blossomed into a beautiful young woman.

As for me, when I came out to my mom that I was transgender, she said "I knew already"... I think its one of those things as parents - they know if their child is gay or for this instance, transgender. Its just a matter of how accepting the parent is of knowing this knowledge and their support/love for their child.
Isn't being Trans gendered being gay. I mean you date guys

How do men feel when you tell them
If the transgendered individual is a woman, and she dates men, then she isn't gay - she's heterosexual.

Not only referring to you, but it takes effort to try and understand instead of clinging to personal prejudices and fallacies because it's about accepting that people are complex and the world isn't as black and white as many of us (myself included) were raised to believe because it's what's convenient. An LGBTQ activist came to campus and presented a seminar that cleared all of that confusion up. I went in with a similar ignorant thought processes as some of the posters here and I left more enlightened. The trick is to go in assuming you're wrong and ask questions correct yourself.
A man born chemically as a man is a man. If he gets surgery he's closer to being a woman but not a man, so yes the person with him is not gay, because he's having sex in a vagina

But the man is still a man. His DNA hasn't changed only the superficial parts

He can act more woman than a woman but biologically he's still a man
What do you mean "born chemically"? That's both reductive and incorrect. Do you think gender and sex are one in the same?
I mean brain chemistry has alot to do with how you see yourself.
click to expand

Okay, so if my brain chemistry is telling me I'm a man, but I have a vagina - then what?

As heterosexuals who were born with our gender and sex matching, we will NEVER truly understand what it means to have that struggle.
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
You're a man. That makes sense. Something off about your pic.

Wow


Sir, your comments are not nice and unnecessary. Your words are very ignorant and judge mental - As a black person, you'd think you would be more sensitive as transgender folks today are going through similar issues that blacks went through. I am not saying race is the same topic here, but sir, practice what your supposedly preach!

Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by -elle-
I have to agree with Mona on her stance, and I'm not being rude or disrespectful. Why go to such great lengths (medication and physical surgeries)?

I understand societal pressures and the need to fit in but isn't this taking it to the end degree?

I also really don't understand the hypocrisy of this.

When someone speaks against ignorance of those having issues with this....this woman comes to mind.....

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2017/02/26/rachel-dolezal-white-woman-who-identifies-as-black-now-jobless-may-soon-be-homeless.html

Image Not Found

....and it takes me back the thread where people were bashing her.

Why do we pick and choose who gets "accepted" into society or not?

When everyone should just live their life and not give two cents of what other people are choosing to do with theirs.

Personally, I do not care what anyone has in their pants, who they are screwing, who they identify with...it's all their own personal life journey. *shrugs*
Societal pressures?

Society pressures transgendered to shut up and to NOT go through such lengths to feel at peace with themselves.

The fact that people go through so much and risk so much hate, intolerance, judgement, and violence speaks volumes to how important it is to them to live their lives as they choose.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
No not at all. Kids identify their gender at a very young age. Look at Jazz Jennings. Her parents knew she was meant to be a girl from a very young age and she has now blossomed into a beautiful young woman.

As for me, when I came out to my mom that I was transgender, she said "I knew already"... I think its one of those things as parents - they know if their child is gay or for this instance, transgender. Its just a matter of how accepting the parent is of knowing this knowledge and their support/love for their child.
Isn't being Trans gendered being gay. I mean you date guys

How do men feel when you tell them
If the transgendered individual is a woman, and she dates men, then she isn't gay - she's heterosexual.

Not only referring to you, but it takes effort to try and understand instead of clinging to personal prejudices and fallacies because it's about accepting that people are complex and the world isn't as black and white as many of us (myself included) were raised to believe because it's what's convenient. An LGBTQ activist came to campus and presented a seminar that cleared all of that confusion up. I went in with a similar ignorant thought processes as some of the posters here and I left more enlightened. The trick is to go in assuming you're wrong and ask questions correct yourself.
A man born chemically as a man is a man. If he gets surgery he's closer to being a woman but not a man, so yes the person with him is not gay, because he's having sex in a vagina

But the man is still a man. His DNA hasn't changed only the superficial parts

He can act more woman than a woman but biologically he's still a man
What do you mean "born chemically"? That's both reductive and incorrect. Do you think gender and sex are one in the same?
I mean brain chemistry has alot to do with how you see yourself.
Okay, so if my brain chemistry is telling me I'm a man, but I have a vagina - then what?

As heterosexuals who were born with our gender and sex matching, we will NEVER truly understand what it means to have that struggle.


You're a gay man who will eventually wear high heels and get something done to your woooo ha
click to expand

Since you agree that gender and sex are different - if I'm mentally male (gender) and I'm born with a vagina (sex) but I'm attracted to women, then I'm heterosexual when I get surgery to align my gender to my sex.
Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
I can remember my repressed and uptight mother saying that all gay people "did it on purpose for attention"

I can remember my open minded father explaining that life wasn't so black and white and there are grey areas. He also pointed out that sometimes x and y chromosomes at conception become undefined

The difference between my Mum and Dad was a matter of intelligence.......



Luckily for my sister and I one of them possessed it
Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
IMO I think doing permanent physical changes before 18 is not advisable. Let your kid dress in the way they feel best, sure. But don't let them damage themselves irreversibly. Hormones are going crazy at those ages...best to wait until they grow into adulthood first.
Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
Posted by LadyNeptune
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
IMO I think doing permanent physical changes before 18 is not advisable. Let your kid dress in the way they feel best, sure. But don't let them damage themselves irreversibly. Hormones are going crazy at those ages...best to wait until they grow into adulthood first.
click to expand



Exactly what our son and I were saying Lady
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?


"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with that notion that that is what defines a woman.
what is a vagina and breasts if they do not do what they are meant to do? they are not there for looks, they serve purposes. same with men. i can make myself a trans man and have the whole shebang - penis, testicles, muscles and all. i can have 'the look', but i will never be able to perform like a man. i cannot get erections, ejaculate or produce sperm. i can feel manly and live that way, but some aspects of manhood will forever be lost to me since i naturally am not one. are we just going by how we feel and want things to be? some things cannot be other things, no matter how hard you try to change them.
So you were claiming that that's what defines a woman. Stand by your words.

If a man has erectile dysfunction, is he any less "real"? That argument is false intrinsically. Plenty of women have breast that don't produce milk - so the breasts aren't doing "what they are supposed to do." So, are they not "real women"?
how about you stop trying to twist and make them mean what you want them to mean? anyway, body changes do not make you what you aren't. example, a white woman recently tanned her skin and kinked her hair so she could identify as black. despite what she feels like she is, in truth, her dna says she is a white woman and will always be a white woman. some things do not change. bodily purposes don't either. let's face it, there are things men have that make them men. there are things women have that make them women. a man has erectile dysfunction, but at one point in time he had a working, functioning penis. unlike transmen, who never had and never will have one. unless there is a miraculous breakthrough in technology. so, how, in what way, are they real men? they are not. they are synthetic. i dont care how you dress it up, some things are what they are.


Using skin tone to talk about race is also false and, unfortunately, that ignorance is also rampant.
uh genius, the woman was white. she wanted to live as a black person. instead of being like a fly stuck on shit, go tell that to the person who wrote the news article. dont bitch at the messenger.

click to expand

Using a weak argument to try and justify your even weaker argument...

Why the hate? Feel threatened? Let the OP live her life. This thread was about asking her questions, not about coming in here and clinging stubbornly to the ignorance you were raised to believe.

Live and let live. That's at the heart of Native American cultures, yes?
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by -elle-
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by -elle-
I have to agree with Mona on her stance, and I'm not being rude or disrespectful. Why go to such great lengths (medication and physical surgeries)?

I understand societal pressures and the need to fit in but isn't this taking it to the end degree?

I also really don't understand the hypocrisy of this.

When someone speaks against ignorance of those having issues with this....this woman comes to mind.....

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2017/02/26/rachel-dolezal-white-woman-who-identifies-as-black-now-jobless-may-soon-be-homeless.html

....and it takes me back the thread where people were bashing her.

Why do we pick and choose who gets "accepted" into society or not?

When everyone should just live their life and not give two cents of what other people are choosing to do with theirs.

Personally, I do not care what anyone has in their pants, who they are screwing, who they identify with...it's all their own personal life journey. *shrugs*
Societal pressures?

Society pressures transgendered to shut up and to NOT go through such lengths to feel at peace with themselves.

The fact that people go through so much and risk so much hate, intolerance, judgement, and violence speaks volumes to how important it is to them to live their lives as they choose.
Society pressures such as defining what a man and woman are 'supposed' to look like.

Society pressures that say men wear pants and women wear dresses.

Society pressures that say girls play with dolls and men play with tonka trucks.

THOSE societal pressures. if they weren't there...people wouldn't go to great lengths to look like society expects them to look as a man or woman.
click to expand

Wouldn't it be easier to just conform and NOT go to such lengths? Society would much rather beautiful trans people did not exist. Wouldn't it be easier to not do the very thing that puts one at risk of being targeted and astrocized and abused? It baffles me how few people ask: Why do they still do it when the world makes it so hard for them?

I agree wholeheartedly with the defining of what makes a real man or woman - but your comment is aimed in the wrong direction. Have you noticed that everyone against the OP are the ones using the "real men/women..." argument?
Profile picture of TaurusBull1977
TaurusBull1977
@TaurusBull1977
16 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 4771 · Topics: 30
Posted by MilaniKisses


Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
I support your decision to be a transgender.

No judgements there.

However, being a transgender does not equate to being Black.

Being a transgender is a choice.

Being a Black isn't, regardless of gender identity.

Whether a Black person is transgender, male, female, straight, gay, bi....same discrimination rule still applies.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MagicMona
i'm trying to articulate my thoughts without coming across as rude. i believe in people living as they want, but i disagree with "woman" and "man" being used so loosely. in your mind, you are a woman, and i'm not here to tell you how to feel or think. but in my small opinion, men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part. you got the opportunity to surpass a lot of what cis females had to endure in order to grow into women. it's kind of hard to accept you as an equal.
This comment is meant for the OP, but I just want to step in and point out that there are plenty of women who can't have children, who don't have uteruses, or who have had early onset menopause and so don't have periods either. To say that that's what defines a woman is to deny them their womanhood.
that's the thing. i never said that defines women. are you comprehending or just looking to respond?


"men can never really change themselves into women. you don't have a menstrual. you do not have a womb. you cannot give birth. you don't experience a lot of what natural born women go through physically. i'm not saying this in any bad way; i just feel like being a woman is more than a "feeling" and shaping one's body to look the part."

^^^^^^

Based on what you said above, I'm inferring that you are saying that a vagina and breasts aren't what make a woman: menstrual cycles, wombs, and the act of giving birth do.

I am also disagreeing with that notion that that is what defines a woman.
what is a vagina and breasts if they do not do what they are meant to do? they are not there for looks, they serve purposes. same with men. i can make myself a trans man and have the whole shebang - penis, testicles, muscles and all. i can have 'the look', but i will never be able to perform like a man. i cannot get erections, ejaculate or produce sperm. i can feel manly and live that way, but some aspects of manhood will forever be lost to me since i naturally am not one. are we just going by how we feel and want things to be? some things cannot be other things, no matter how hard you try to change them.
So you were claiming that that's what defines a woman. Stand by your words.

If a man has erectile dysfunction, is he any less "real"? That argument is false intrinsically. Plenty of women have breast that don't produce milk - so the breasts aren't doing "what they are supposed to do." So, are they not "real women"?
how about you stop trying to twist and make them mean what you want them to mean? anyway, body changes do not make you what you aren't. example, a white woman recently tanned her skin and kinked her hair so she could identify as black. despite what she feels like she is, in truth, her dna says she is a white woman and will always be a white woman. some things do not change. bodily purposes don't either. let's face it, there are things men have that make them men. there are things women have that make them women. a man has erectile dysfunction, but at one point in time he had a working, functioning penis. unlike transmen, who never had and never will have one. unless there is a miraculous breakthrough in technology. so, how, in what way, are they real men? they are not. they are synthetic. i dont care how you dress it up, some things are what they are.


Using skin tone to talk about race is also false and, unfortunately, that ignorance is also rampant.
uh genius, the woman was white. she wanted to live as a black person. instead of being like a fly stuck on shit, go tell that to the person who wrote the news article. dont bitch at the messenger.


Using a weak argument to try and justify your even weaker argument...

Why the hate? Feel threatened? Let the OP live her life. This thread was about asking her questions, not about coming in here and clinging stubbornly to the ignorance you were raised to believe.

Live and let live. That's at the heart of Native American cultures, yes?
hmm...my argument is weak but you cant help but to quote everything i say. hmmm. me thinks if my words and beliefs were so ignorant and weak, surely a mental giant like you could easily skip over my nonsense. hmmm. attention seeking much? or are you that self centered and utterly stupid that you really will attempt to derail OP's thread by wrongly attacking everything i say just because you dont like it? triggered much, or are you really that stupid, narcissist, or childish? why the hate Lily? are you feeling threatened by opinions that don't match up with yours? you want to talk about live and let live, yet your hypocritical ass stay doing the opposite every time you get a stick up your ass from differences of expression and opinion. get your life bitch.
click to expand

*smiles*

Live and let live. Our ancestors knew so much. Cheers!
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by Effervescent
Posted by -elle-
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by -elle-
I have to agree with Mona on her stance, and I'm not being rude or disrespectful. Why go to such great lengths (medication and physical surgeries)?

I understand societal pressures and the need to fit in but isn't this taking it to the end degree?

I also really don't understand the hypocrisy of this.

When someone speaks against ignorance of those having issues with this....this woman comes to mind.....

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2017/02/26/rachel-dolezal-white-woman-who-identifies-as-black-now-jobless-may-soon-be-homeless.html

....and it takes me back the thread where people were bashing her.

Why do we pick and choose who gets "accepted" into society or not?

When everyone should just live their life and not give two cents of what other people are choosing to do with theirs.

Personally, I do not care what anyone has in their pants, who they are screwing, who they identify with...it's all their own personal life journey. *shrugs*
Societal pressures?

Society pressures transgendered to shut up and to NOT go through such lengths to feel at peace with themselves.

The fact that people go through so much and risk so much hate, intolerance, judgement, and violence speaks volumes to how important it is to them to live their lives as they choose.
Society pressures such as defining what a man and woman are 'supposed' to look like.

Society pressures that say men wear pants and women wear dresses.

Society pressures that say girls play with dolls and men play with tonka trucks.

THOSE societal pressures. if they weren't there...people wouldn't go to great lengths to look like society expects them to look as a man or woman.

This is me x10000000000

I see where the OP is coming from and respect her life and views but I live by this.

So because I'm a man I have to dress a certain way? Be good at sports? Do "manly" things? Not wear what I want to wear? And because you're a woman you have to be "ladylike," a housewife, a chef, a professional cleaner, etc and god forbid you don't wear make up or dress "the part" of being a woman.

So if you don't fit into society's label of what a man or a woman should be then you're not a real man or a real woman—?? So you must transition?

This is my belief

click to expand

If transitioning is what society wants? Then why the societal backlash?

Transitioning is the fight AGAINST societal expectations of what "a real man/woman" is.
Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
Posted by LillyPetal
@MilaniKisses

You are beautiful. You are a woman. You define who you want to be. Don't let anyone steal your shine - especially not people on DXPnef. Thank you for being an example for how to live one's truth and how to stand strong against hatred and ignorance. ❤


+1

and for those of you who don't have the heart to be so compassionte as this lady, God help any children you bring into the world. In fact, please don't have any unless you can be totally accepting
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MyStarsShine
If we don't accept people for who they are, how they look, choose to live etc, we are choosing to be prejudice. This is reverting back to the 60's and the 'no blacks, no dogs, no Irish' mentality

Offensive, small minded and cruel and gives angry people an excuse to vent their frustration on others
"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." - Dr. King

Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by MyStarsShine
If we don't accept people for who they are, how they look, choose to live etc, we are choosing to be prejudice. This is reverting back to the 60's and the 'no blacks, no dogs, no Irish' mentality

Offensive, small minded and cruel and gives angry people an excuse to vent their frustration on others
"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." - Dr. King

click to expand



AMEN to that Lilly

You will be a very caring and compassionate mother. < 3
Profile picture of TaurusBull1977
TaurusBull1977
@TaurusBull1977
16 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 4771 · Topics: 30
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by MilaniKisses


Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
I support your decision to be a transgender.

No judgements there.

However, being a transgender does not equate to being Black.

Being a transgender is a choice.

Being a Black isn't, regardless of gender identity.

Whether a Black person is transgender, male, female, straight, gay, bi....same discrimination rule still applies.


It's even worse for black transgendered .
click to expand

Thank You.

Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by MyStarsShine
Posted by LadyNeptune
Posted by MyStarsShine
A woman i know has allowed her teenage daughter to transition from female to male....the op didn't go too well. He is 15. Do you think that is too young to make such a huge change?

She tells me, he has started to wear eyeliner....
IMO I think doing permanent physical changes before 18 is not advisable. Let your kid dress in the way they feel best, sure. But don't let them damage themselves irreversibly. Hormones are going crazy at those ages...best to wait until they grow into adulthood first.


Exactly what our son and I were saying Lady

click to expand

I know in some other countries, in order to get funds through insurance for operation, you go through intense and thorough psych evaluations before your granted the funds. I think in England and Australia...maybe new zealand. Can't remember where exactly tbh.

That should be the norm though. Talk to a specialist and make sure that it's something you'll want for forever.

Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by MilaniKisses


Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
I support your decision to be a transgender.

No judgements there.

However, being a transgender does not equate to being Black.

Being a transgender is a choice.

Being a Black isn't, regardless of gender identity.

Whether a Black person is transgender, male, female, straight, gay, bi....same discrimination rule still applies.


It's even worse for black transgendered .
Thank You.



click to expand

It seems her original commment was edited while being quoted. She said

"As a black person, you'd think you would be more sensitive as transgender folks today are going through similar issues that blacks went through. I am not saying race is the same topic here, but sir, practice what your supposedly preach!"

So she did say she's aware there is a distinction.
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by LillyPetal
OP, is my following statement incorrect? Please correct me if I'm wrong. ?

"Since you agree that gender and sex are different - if I'm mentally male (gender) and I'm born with a vagina (sex) but I'm attracted to women, then I'm heterosexual when I get surgery to align my gender to my sex."
Right - If you identify as male (born as a female) and your female partner sees you as a man - then yes, you are heterosexual. Genitalia does not define one's gender identity.
Profile picture of LillyPetal
LillyPetal
@LillyPetal
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 33 · Posts: 5490 · Topics: 118
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by LillyPetal
OP, is my following statement incorrect? Please correct me if I'm wrong. ?

"Since you agree that gender and sex are different - if I'm mentally male (gender) and I'm born with a vagina (sex) but I'm attracted to women, then I'm heterosexual when I get surgery to align my gender to my sex."
Right - If you identify as male (born as a female) and your female partner sees you as a man - then yes, you are heterosexual. Genitalia does not define one's gender identity.
click to expand

Understood, thank you! You need to say it again for those in the back. 😄
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by MilaniKisses


Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
I support your decision to be a transgender.

No judgements there.

However, being a transgender does not equate to being Black.

Being a transgender is a choice.

Being a Black isn't, regardless of gender identity.

Whether a Black person is transgender, male, female, straight, gay, bi....same discrimination rule still applies.


It's even worse for black transgendered .
Thank You.




It seems her original commment was edited while being quoted. She said

"As a black person, you'd think you would be more sensitive as transgender folks today are going through similar issues that blacks went through. I am not saying race is the same topic here, but sir, practice what your supposedly preach!"

So she did say she's aware there is a distinction.
click to expand

Thank you Lilly for clarifying this for Caramel.
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by LillyPetal
@MilaniKisses

You are beautiful. You are a woman. You define who you want to be. Don't let anyone steal your shine - especially not people on DXPnef. Thank you for being an example for how to live one's truth and how to stand strong against hatred and ignorance. ❤
Thank you Lilly!

I did have some expectation of ignorance even though I stated in my original post "... as long as they are respectful"

Being a woman and transgender, I've learned that you can not take anyone's negative opinions to heart. However, the beauty of people's ignorance is that it has made me stronger and thicken up my skin. :-)
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by Fun4Life
Posted by MilaniKisses
Posted by LillyPetal
OP, is my following statement incorrect? Please correct me if I'm wrong. ?

"Since you agree that gender and sex are different - if I'm mentally male (gender) and I'm born with a vagina (sex) but I'm attracted to women, then I'm heterosexual when I get surgery to align my gender to my sex."
Right - If you identify as male (born as a female) and your female partner sees you as a man - then yes, you are heterosexual. Genitalia does not define one's gender identity.
O-M-G.

You've been fed and drank, the entire water tower of kool-aide. Spiked

Rationalization is the 2nd most powerful human drive.

click to expand

Wait - I cant tell if that is a positive comment or negative?
Profile picture of metalaquamonkey
metalaquamonkey
@metalaquamonkey
11 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 765 · Posts: 1610 · Topics: 5
I have some transgender friends and acquaintances. One of my friends while transitioning dealt with a lot of flack from her manager at work. It was a very difficult time for my friend as she transitioned and sadly after a few filed complaints against the manager the employer stood by him instead of my friend.

My question Op is, while transitioning or even now did you face adversity in the workplace?

I find it very unfortunate and unfair how the trans community gets treated by many in society and how it's even sadder that some justify or encourage such mistreatment.
Profile picture of MilaniKisses
Milani
@MilaniKisses
8 YearsVirgo

Comments: 16 · Posts: 487 · Topics: 93
Posted by Dastardly
Posted by TaurusBull1977
Posted by MilaniKisses


Similar Issues as blacks experienced:

*Bathroom Issues

*Judgement By Society

*Society judging straight men who date transgender women (Like the whole interracial issue from back in the day)

* Everyday hate crimes - Transgender folks get brutally murdered or beaten up for no reason except for the fact that they are transgender

* Being looked at as a lower part of society

* Constant torment from IGNORANT people who are closed minded and "stuck in the south"
Being a transgender is a choice.

Being a Black isn't, regardless of gender identity.



Isn't this like saying being gay is a choice?
click to expand

TaurusBull - If you had fully read my comment, and not just the cutout Caramel put - I stated that I understand that race is different, however, there are some relations to what Transgenders are facing today.
Profile picture of P-Angel
P-Angel
@P-Angel
20 Years25,000+ PostsPisces

Comments: 0 · Posts: 44084 · Topics: 685
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by P-Angel
Posted by LillyPetal
Posted by P-Angel
Your soul is androgynous ... the only thing you've accomplished is satisfying the ego consciousness.

How you appear to others, in form ..... has no meaning to the true self.
It is very important to have harmony between our inner selves and our outward existence.

or whether it's to become physically a woman so that society treats you as you are.


Every person's inner self is both males and female ... the harmony existed before you were even born.

My thoughts remain ... I see no point in changing your gender to satisfy the ego, and especially not for the purposes of acceptance by society.

I've not met a person yet, who doesn't feel both feminine and masculine at certain given times and situations .. and that's because the soul isn't specifically gendered one way or the other.

I just don't see a rational reason for it, other than to prove something to others. If you know who you are, but, you're not going to live by that ... then what's the point of even having your life? ... if you're not going to live by the knowing of who you are, and you have to prove shit to other people to feel valued?



::::: shakes head ::::::



In the scheme of what's important in life ... gender is not one of them, specifying a particular gender is irrelevant.


I believe our inner selves deal with energy, both the masculine energy and feminine energy. It is not the same as how we predominantly feel. I mostly feel feminine, and so I am physically woman and it aligns and is in harmony. I can't speak about what it's like to feel feminine, yet have my outward appearance conflict with that. The only thing I can relate it to is the cognitive dissonance I experience any time I do something that goes against my inner moral values. Or, when people misjudge me based on my appearance - it is everyone's desire to correct someone else's misconception of him or her because it is important to humans to be seen as they wish to be seen and to be treated as they want to be treated. Heck, people are even proud of their astrological placmements and go through a process to know excalty what they are. Why not just choose the sign you most feel like and live by that? Why the need to correct people if they call you a Gemini when you're an Aries, for example? Identity is a powerful thing. Satisfying ones ego (ego has been stigmatized to being a dirty word) is part of human psychology and we all do it.

Dismissing how society treats us as being irrelevant is reckless because, whether we like it or not, we are social animals and our identity isn't entirely our own. Part of our identity is shaped by how society treats us and the expectations it has of us. So, if an innocent man goes his entire life being treated as a criminal, he will carry a strong desire for the world to know he's innocent because only knowing it himself is not enough because how he's treated isnt in harmony with his inner knowledge of his innocence.

What do we say to people who have been born with both sexual reproductive organs? I can't pretend to begin to understand what the transgendered community goes though because I will never have to make such a tough decision. I'm sure most people would choose the easier path, the path that doesn't lead to societal outrage and discrimination or negative familial backlash. I certainly don't remember being asked if I wanted to be a heterosexual female.

click to expand



I disagree and believe you just want to hear yourself talk.

Who cares what you can or cannot pretend to begin to understand?
Profile picture of TaurusBull1977
TaurusBull1977
@TaurusBull1977
16 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 0 · Posts: 4771 · Topics: 30
Posted by CaramelizedCoffee
I'm a woman and not a sir and i believe in trans rights and that you should do what you feel. I will always support minority groups especially when it concerns injustice not because I'm Black but because I'm human.

But my opinon on this is.

you're not a woman, i don't care how much estrogen you take, the boob job, etc

I have a right to my opinion.

And don't try to use race cause gay ppl are racist as hell.

So you can stfu

@LilyPetal,

This was her opinion.

CC wasn't desensitized to the OP's decision to be transgender.

She just didn't agree with the OP's biological, scientific definition of a 'woman.'

Discrimination would be throwing the dogs at her, rocks, name-calling, bullying ,and taking away her civil rights....the list goes on.

To be honest, no one attacked the OP for being a transgender so far....just offered their own opinions as to what a biological woman vs a transgender woman entails.

I have seen much worse in regards to discrimination and bullying....and the OP has not witnessed any of it on this thread.

Trust me.

I have met racist people who couldn't give a rats ass about minorities. Do I care? No.

Why?

I don't crave acceptance from people.

As long as you're not attempting to take away away my Civil Rights, throwing dogs at me, or unlawfully arresting me, who cares what you think?

The OP, unfortunately, cares what people think....

Thus the reason for this thread.