Should religious gatherings be exempt from stay-at-home orders?

Profile picture of _Dazed
Dazed
@_Dazed
6 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 9549 · Posts: 12626 · Topics: 250
From yesterday's Open Phones session on C-SPAN

https://www.c-span.org/video/?471062-2/washington-journal-news-headlines-viewer-calls

As somewhat of a constitutionalist, I'm struggling with the idea of keeping folks from practicing their religion. With today's technology, it's not difficult to have church services broadcast/live streamed, but for some, the people ARE the church. There is no alternative to sitting in the house of God with others.

Thoughts?
Profile picture of justagirl
SelenaKyle
@justagirl
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 6657 · Posts: 25221 · Topics: 77
Posted by Black-Mamba
Posted by justagirl

Hasn’t there been several linked cases of COVID spreading, ties directly back to services?

Case in point a choir meetings in Whatcom County up north to practice. There are probably over 30 to 4o people in attendance

they follow all the rules social distancing, they sat or stood 4 feet apart, had sanitizers, etc blah blah

but guess what when you're singing your fuking phlegm goes everywhere

about half got covid-19 and many died
click to expand


Exactly.

I’m all for eligion and whatever ones beliefs are but no I do NOT think they should be exempt

Stay at home means STAY AT HOME. What the fuxk is so hard to understand about that.
Profile picture of DMV
DMV
@DMV
15 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 294 · Posts: 28989 · Topics: 654
Posted by _Dazed

From yesterday's Open Phones session on C-SPAN

https://www.c-span.org/video/?471062-2/washington-journal-news-headlines-viewer-calls

As somewhat of a constitutionalist, I'm struggling with the idea of keeping folks from practicing their religion. With today's technology, it's not difficult to have church services broadcast/live streamed, but for some, the people ARE the church. There is no alternative to sitting in the house of God with others.

Thoughts?


It's a stubbornness and selfishness that needs to change.

Cant have any church members if they're all dead.
Profile picture of Romz-
Romz-
@Romz-
6 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1859 · Posts: 1253 · Topics: 15
Churches and religious organizations are exempt from taxes and they receive many more perks.....not to mention their wealth, land tax and much more is footed by their members.

They don’t contribute to the constructs of society via social services or any other public funded service that assists people yet they have insane profits annually.

What they offer to in need members is very little....

So no- they should not be allowed to congregate during a pandemic. They’re knowingly putting lives at risk and causing even more strain on a collapsing healthcare system. If the Muslim’s can not visit during Ramadan, then Christian’s can stay out of the churches.

Everyone has to make these sacrifices.
Profile picture of Endless
Endless
@Endless
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 573 · Posts: 1765 · Topics: 0
Posted by _Dazed

As somewhat of a constitutionalist, I'm struggling with the idea of keeping folks from practicing their religion. With today's technology, it's not difficult to have church services broadcast/live streamed, but for some, the people ARE the church. There is no alternative to sitting in the house of God with others.

Thoughts?

I doubt that's the scope the constitution went for, anyway, that has been settle already in Reynolds v US, where polygamy was outlawed no matter religion belief, the court said that "Congress was deprived of all legislative power over mere opinion, but was left free to reach actions which were in violation of social duties or subversive of good order." so you can believe in whatever you like, but you can do whatever you like because of it.

there's a reason why Iran has 9 of every 10 cases of covid in the Middle East, is the only country that refused quarantine, Saudi Arabia quarantined, Afghanistan quarantined.... how that's working for them.

heck even in Italy the amount of priest the catholic church loss is impressive, I wonder how they gonna recover from that now.
Profile picture of Whorpio
I can suck the bullet out of a glock on safety.
@Whorpio
8 Years5,000+ PostsScorpio

Comments: 2583 · Posts: 6184 · Topics: 141
Posted by Black-Mamba

I think pastors opening up churchs aren't doing it for religion, but to keep their coffers from emptying.

I think its dangerous for society for people to attend any gatherings with other people.

I agree.

I told my bf some churches are still operating and he replied “Put the donation basket under quarantine and then see if they still wanna hold service” 🤣🤣

I was moreso just thinking we should tax them if they want to consider themselves “essential”.
Profile picture of Astrobyn
Astrobyn
@Astrobyn
11 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 593 · Posts: 4512 · Topics: 128
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn

God's will...

You worship in your community obeying gods will, and if you die because said will, you die of god's will, not the corona's.

Like Catholics and procreation spin the wheel and see how many babies you have, or grandparents you lose.

Them dying is not the issue.

Them infecting others that had nothing to do with the church service....the unsuspecting soul who picks up the apple that Chuch Choir Kelly fondled and put back.....is the issue.

If they are that dedicated they can all quarantine at the church until this is over.
click to expand


Gods will, is not a rational argument that you can argue. If god will'ed me to pass it on to someone who then died, then god only used me as a vessel of his will
Profile picture of Astrobyn
Astrobyn
@Astrobyn
11 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 593 · Posts: 4512 · Topics: 128
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn

God's will...

You worship in your community obeying gods will, and if you die because said will, you die of god's will, not the corona's.

Like Catholics and procreation spin the wheel and see how many babies you have, or grandparents you lose.

Them dying is not the issue.

Them infecting others that had nothing to do with the church service....the unsuspecting soul who picks up the apple that Chuch Choir Kelly fondled and put back.....is the issue.

If they are that dedicated they can all quarantine at the church until this is over.

Gods will, is not a rational argument that you can argue. If god will'ed me to pass it on to someone who then died, then god only used me as a vessel of his will

So, murder should be okay if I say it was God's Will?
click to expand


Oh god yes! have you read the bible?

“You are my battle-ax and sword,” says the LORD . “With you I will shatter nations and destroy many kingdoms. With you I will shatter armies— destroying the horse and rider, the chariot and charioteer. With you I will shatter men and women, old people and children, young men and young women. "

... it goes on from there, more of the same stuff.
Profile picture of Endless
Endless
@Endless
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 573 · Posts: 1765 · Topics: 0
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn

God's will...

You worship in your community obeying gods will, and if you die because said will, you die of god's will, not the corona's.

Like Catholics and procreation spin the wheel and see how many babies you have, or grandparents you lose.

Them dying is not the issue.

Them infecting others that had nothing to do with the church service....the unsuspecting soul who picks up the apple that Chuch Choir Kelly fondled and put back.....is the issue.

If they are that dedicated they can all quarantine at the church until this is over.

Gods will, is not a rational argument that you can argue. If god will'ed me to pass it on to someone who then died, then god only used me as a vessel of his will

So, murder should be okay if I say it was God's Will?
click to expand


ignoring the fact that you're engaging a troll....

isn't that what muslin terrorist believe when they commit jihad?

so. there's precedent in abrahamic religion for that kind of attitude.
Profile picture of Endless
Endless
@Endless
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 573 · Posts: 1765 · Topics: 0
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Endless
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn

God's will...

You worship in your community obeying gods will, and if you die because said will, you die of god's will, not the corona's.

Like Catholics and procreation spin the wheel and see how many babies you have, or grandparents you lose.

Them dying is not the issue.

Them infecting others that had nothing to do with the church service....the unsuspecting soul who picks up the apple that Chuch Choir Kelly fondled and put back.....is the issue.

If they are that dedicated they can all quarantine at the church until this is over.

Gods will, is not a rational argument that you can argue. If god will'ed me to pass it on to someone who then died, then god only used me as a vessel of his will

So, murder should be okay if I say it was God's Will?

ignoring the fact that you're engaging a troll....

isn't that what muslin terrorist believe when they commit jihad?

so. there's precedent in abrahamic religion for that kind of attitude.

Robyn isnt a troll, she has been here as long as I have. She is just playing devil's advocate.

Yes, I would liken it to muslim terrorists belief when they commit jihad.

I would like for someone to explain that to them. They are basically terrorists.
click to expand


the devil's a troll in most religion, being its advocate is trolling in my book, wouldn't care how much time someone has been here, HES has been here since god know when, and he trolls all the time, by his own admission so what gives.... moving on.

morality is a very complex issue, and you, like most westerners immediately correlate the word terrorism with "bad", but for a muslin extremist, the idea of creating terror in the non-believers would be a "good" thing (is what we deserve), so explaining to them that they are terrorist is by no means a deterrent, you can't solve that conundrum on morality grounds alone (I think)
Profile picture of Endless
Endless
@Endless
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 573 · Posts: 1765 · Topics: 0
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Endless
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Endless
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Astrobyn

God's will...

You worship in your community obeying gods will, and if you die because said will, you die of god's will, not the corona's.

Like Catholics and procreation spin the wheel and see how many babies you have, or grandparents you lose.

Them dying is not the issue.

Them infecting others that had nothing to do with the church service....the unsuspecting soul who picks up the apple that Chuch Choir Kelly fondled and put back.....is the issue.

If they are that dedicated they can all quarantine at the church until this is over.

Gods will, is not a rational argument that you can argue. If god will'ed me to pass it on to someone who then died, then god only used me as a vessel of his will

So, murder should be okay if I say it was God's Will?

ignoring the fact that you're engaging a troll....

isn't that what muslin terrorist believe when they commit jihad?

so. there's precedent in abrahamic religion for that kind of attitude.

Robyn isnt a troll, she has been here as long as I have. She is just playing devil's advocate.

Yes, I would liken it to muslim terrorists belief when they commit jihad.

I would like for someone to explain that to them. They are basically terrorists.

the devil's a troll in most religion, being its advocate is trolling in my book, wouldn't care how much time someone has been here, HES has been here since god know when, and he trolls all the time, by his own admission so what gives.... moving on.

morality is a very complex issue, and you, like most westerners immediately correlate the word terrorism with "bad", but for a muslin extremist, the idea of creating terror in the non-believers would be a "good" thing (is what we deserve), so explaining to them that they are terrorist is by no means a deterrent, you can't solve that conundrum on morality grounds alone (I think)

I think telling American Evangelical Christians they are behaving like terrorists in a formal and unified manner may deter them. Not all, especially not those whose motive is cash driven....but the mom and pops in the general public may think it thru....I would hope.

I can't speak to this "for a muslin extremist, the idea of creating terror in the non-believers would be a "good" thing (is what we deserve)" because that isn't what I personally know about Islam. Anyone I've ever come across doesn't subscribe to that way of thinking, so that gets lost on me.

These Christians are acting out of priviledge and perceived entitlement. The US is supposed to separate church and state. They shouldnt have exceptions that endanger public safety.

I am willing to bet that if Ramadan came before Easter, this would be an entirely different discussion.
click to expand


yes, you can try telling them that, but will they believe you more than their own religious leaders?, not every single one of those leaders are there for money, possibly a good chunk are, but there are genuine radical people out there, the amish don't reject technology for money, the mormon shun their own family member that leave their church, heck what about the Jonestown massacre? nope, you can't always argue with them, not on the basis on morality at least.

and if they believe you were sent by the devil to misguide their path.... they would hear nothing.

"that isn't what I personally know about Islam, anyone I've ever come across doesn't subscribe to that way of thinking"

what you know of Islam or christianity has nothing to it, those would read whatever they want to interpret in their holy books, so defending Islam in general is unnecessary when I already used the word "extremist", referring to a) a persona and b) not the average, so you not crossing paths with one of those should be assumed, and considered a blessing tbh

I don't assume most American are bigots, nor are most I know, but who's the president again?, what many ayatollah say out there, would be considered hate speech in the states.

they manage to both baffle and fascinate me (along with whom believe them).
Profile picture of Endless
Endless
@Endless
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 573 · Posts: 1765 · Topics: 0
Posted by sagaciouscorp

You got trump stating is state to state you guys deal with you supplies the. He’s like I say when it’s over. Nope you can have both ways

well, kinda.

it's mostly how laws can superpose each other, trump can impose a national quarantine, states can suspend classes and put in effect other measures, if trump start the quarantine, states "shouldn't break that" but if trump lift it off, states could still keep classes suspended along the other measures, that's their right, and even so, even if the states lift all measures, business are not forced to open, and so and so on.... LMAO right and duties from the top, to the bottom.

but they all should be help responsible to their decision (which they won't obv 🙄)
Profile picture of SagInTheSun898
SagInTheSun898
@SagInTheSun898
5 Years

Comments: 514 · Posts: 454 · Topics: 6
Again. If this was a physical flesh eating virus everyone could see no one would care about " The Economy " or

" Way Of Life " and have no problem staying in their home. People need to start accepting a day is gonna come where YOU have to depend on yourself for survival. Learn how to tie knots and read a compass before worrying if your favorite restaurant will open in a week
Profile picture of Anomalous
Anomalous
@Anomalous
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 953 · Posts: 1662 · Topics: 2
Well, on one hand I respect free will. On the other hand, god said have wisdom. There is no wisdom in joining hands in prayer when you could catch Covid. Some churches choose a different route of gathering by cars. Like a drive in movie theater. I think that's the safest way to do it besides online viewing.

You're not fighting evil by congregating without precautions. You're making it worse and sending a horrible message. You might as well tell everyone to drink poison.

Now on the flip side to that, I think they're trying express that nothing will happen to them because of whom they worship. Which doesn't make complete sense because otherwise what's the point of having wisdom bestowed upon you?
Profile picture of Astrobyn
Astrobyn
@Astrobyn
11 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 593 · Posts: 4512 · Topics: 128
Posted by Chimichanga
Posted by Romz-
Posted by Chimichanga

I'm going to start a religion where the services are just people sitting on video chat getting shit faced on whiskey and eating barbeque.

Sign me up ✅

Except I’m drinking tea and judging peoples home decor whilst on cam 😎

That cult is the next door on the left. Bye 👋
click to expand


@Romz, welcome have a seat... we will begin shortly, I'll have someone bring you a snack.
Profile picture of Romz-
Romz-
@Romz-
6 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 1859 · Posts: 1253 · Topics: 15
Posted by Astrobyn
Posted by Chimichanga
Posted by Romz-
Posted by Chimichanga

I'm going to start a religion where the services are just people sitting on video chat getting shit faced on whiskey and eating barbeque.

Sign me up ✅

Except I’m drinking tea and judging peoples home decor whilst on cam 😎

That cult is the next door on the left. Bye 👋

@Romz, welcome have a seat... we will begin shortly, I'll have someone bring you a snack.
click to expand



Thank you 🙏

I’m back on the gluten wagon 🍪 so I’ll take one if everything 😌

Also it’s hilarious Rabbit thinks he doesn’t belong in this cult 💅🏽....that bish judges people deli meat choices ffs
Profile picture of Ram416
Ram416
@Ram416
9 Years10,000+ Posts

Comments: 4530 · Posts: 12486 · Topics: 56
Posted by HearttofTopazz

My mom has been telling me stories about some of her church friends, and how they still went to service. She said don’t expect to see me there anymore, and they said Jesus would protect them and then a few caught the corona. One died last week.


Why are these churches still holding services though?

Over here and in some parts of the US the Catholic church has suspended all services, to it's detriment. Some people are pissed off about it and don't realize its for their own safety.
Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
Posted by Chicadee
Posted by MrsElleCappysnatch
Posted by Chicadee
Posted by Solaristic
Posted by Chicadee

Im for it but don't want to say why

So the die hard bible thumpers will die off?

something to that effect...

to quote Jeff Bloomberg in Jurassic park, "Nature finds a way"

If I didn't have children and grandchildren.....I would carpool those fuckers to their service myself.

might be worth reflecting how having kids (/grandkids) would change my POV on a lot of this 🤔
click to expand



Putting her life at risk?
Profile picture of MyStarsShine
MyStarsShine
@MyStarsShine
9 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 37529 · Posts: 41243 · Topics: 331
"Religion is for those who are scared of going to hell

Spirituality is for those who have already been there"

Hopefully people will opt for the latter and ditch the

money making, power crazy, brainwashing of the former

I've experienced both....religion wrecked my family and

what my mother thought was helping to keep us on the

straight and narrow, had the opposite effect. Spirituality

saved me ❤️