Which of the guys in the astrology signs is most manly? (Page 2)

You are on page out of 2 | Reverse Order
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by bmoon8
Posted by Parkourler
Posted by DMV

Aries women fit the mold of what society deems as most masculine.

They’re more masculine than the men and there’s nothing wrong with it.

That wasn`t the question. Pisces man are the manliest.

My Pisces brother is bi-romantic and is involved with a gay man. They are both manly. My brother has many masculine planets helping him to be manly though. Aqua moon, Aries Venus, Mars Sag … not counting any outer planets.
click to expand



yes, I didn't mention this in my post, but your other chart placements definitely can help determine if you're more masc or fem like. I'd say Pisces, Cancer and Libra stereotypically and as the signs itself are feminine. But that can all change depending on your chart and other external factors. And like you said, your brother has masc placements like Aries Venus, for example 🙂

and for the record, about Aries women, I think you Aries women are quite lovely people actually, but I wouldn't associate you guys with masc. I think of Aries people as very brave and outwardly confident go getter people. But those aren't qualities I use to define masculinity.
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by ozzzy

Sagittarius is the manliest, aka the most masculine zodiac, that is well known. Just research, a lot of sources are there about it. 😉 How can some funny animal be more masculine than the half man half centaur? Sagi is the Archer/Hunter. Archers are masculine and can kill any animal. 😄 Green Arrow, yeah.

interesting. Well I would put Sagittarius in the middle of the spectrum, but on the more masc side for sure, but I wouldn't coin them the MOST masculine. The ones I've met and seen online are huge chaotic, free spirited jokesters, I always laugh around them that's for sure.
Profile picture of Jumpin_Jupiter
5 months without a single dip
@Jumpin_Jupiter
6 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 4219 · Posts: 8451 · Topics: 103
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter

Yeah you'll have to define manly for me because in a case like this when I think of manly for a woman I think in terms of looking and acting like a man. I don't know any man that's manly but I do know some women that might be deemed as manly. This Libra lady I know is indeed one of them that falls in that category. She even said she can handle a big mack truck with ease better than most men and I believe her. For a start she grew up around boys and she has no sisters. She's married to a Capricorn dude born on Christmas day and she's the man in their relationship. While he play as the woman. I think air signs got it. Fire signs can forget it cus their really mostly all talk that actually can't be about being manly. Earth signs are too womanly so that's out of the equation for them.

Yes we Libra women definitely have a masculine side. We are cool under pressure, not very emotional when everyone else is in tears, can drive anything, athletic, and brave, not afraid of a fight. All while having perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and looking great! LMFAO!

Are you a tomboy? Not saying that being manly is a tomboy thing for the ladies. I actually do know some feminine Libra women who fall under that latter category in your post. My right hand Libra lady (if you will) is exactly that. Perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and I might even substitute that looking great for cute in her case. She don't take no shit from people regardless. She may not be manly but she is a little rough around the edges ie straightforward, blunt, can be rude even towards me etc.

Yes I'm a Tomboy. I'm the only girl with older brothers and grew up on a farm. But I've always had a passion for fashion and after school (in Ohio) I moved to Los Angeles to start my life and become a big city girl. Now I'm back on the my Dad's farm in VA where we built a house and plan to stay.

Ohhh makes sense. I myself done been into farming almost my whole life on and off hence where most of my muscles come from. I currently own two goats and milk them on occasion. Had three goats but I'm not gonna say what happen to that one. I don't want to get attack by sensitive dxpers so it's best to keep quiet. Although according to my chart I am masculine heavy but somehow I still don't feel masculine.

The Libra lady that I know is the oldest. According to what she told me she helped raised her siblings and again I believe her. Having being around her for so long she proves her toughness day after day so ain't no need for me to not believe her. Everybody keep saying Libra is soft and overlook them but what most people don't know is that Libra can be a sign that's not to be denied.

I love goats they are so cute and smart. I've had to go across the map just to realize that back on the farm is where I belong. My Dad told me it would happen. Even when I lived in L.A. I always came home for the hay season to help. I just love it and will never leave again. I was fortunate to marry a city guy who always dreamed of living the country life so here we are.
click to expand



Ooh gurrrrrl I was always a country squire all my life. I actually started life in the trashy ghetto where we grew up having little to nothing and to be honest I didn't like it. You'll be surprise how far I come to where I am now. Word has it that country people in general are manly goes for both men and women. I don't want to talk bad about the city life but the city life is what got people soft and spoil now. I grew up struggling and had to do my own earning. Couldn't do that in the city where I'll be getting everything handed to me hand and foot on a silver platter.
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by MareInfame
Posted by allrounder

And yeah, you can take it from your own experiences just from the guys you've seen about and met over the years.

In my opinion, Leo, Taurus, Capricorn and Scorpio guys 100% . From who I've seen and met.

and I'm just posting this for fun and entertainment, so please don't start some random war up in here lol

I can’t name one sign, because I’ve seen men of all signs act a bit feminine.

I’ve seen a few Aries men, Leo men, Sag men, Aqua men cry in front of me, because of me.

I’ve played around with Aqua, Gem, Libra, Leo and Cancer men… and put make-up on them, even swapped clothes with them.

I’ve seen vain Scorpio, Taurus, Aries, Leo, Gemini, Virgo and Libra men. Much more on top of fashion than me (and no, they are not gay)

I usually take the lead and get a bit bossy with Virgo, Sag, Gems and Leo’s… get a little sexy and you pretty much own Caps.

To me manly is:

Image Not Found

Played very well by a Scorpio 🤷🏻‍♀️… but, never met one quite that manly.

Most men now at days have glimpses of manly ways.

The most manly I’ve seen so far are of my parents generation - Aqua, Scorpio and Taurus are the signs of the men that come to mind, BUT I know men of the same sign to be much less manly.
click to expand



fair evaluation haha and definitely depends on your birth chart and whether it has more masc or fem ruling signs. I have a looot of masc and 2 feminine placements, but I'm a female Virgo Sun haha

and I feel when it comes to fashion, everyone has a different view of what they define as fashionable since we all have our own style s of fashion. Like I've seen them trash bag dresses on Runway, but those people call that fashion 💀
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by pooface222
Posted by Parkourler
Posted by DMV

Aries women fit the mold of what society deems as most masculine.

They’re more masculine than the men and there’s nothing wrong with it.

That wasn`t the question. Pisces man are the manliest.

I was wondering if someone was going to say Pisces. They are soft and feminine but in a manly way.

Its so sexy.

They are able to express their feelings without feeling embarrassed..and that to me is manly.
click to expand



I wouldn't say they are most manly however. They are one of the most feminine ruling signs, and they are crowned that in official astrology info as well alongside Cancer signs. The Pisces guys I've met are more feminine like compared to the other astrology sign guys I've met, but it does depend on your whole birth chart and whether you have more masc or fem ruling signs too! 🙂

I will say I met a Pisces guy with the most ethereal, dreamy crystal blue eyes that I thought I was gonna drown in them lool
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by LadyNeptune

Certainly not anyone here. We are all arguing with each other on an Astro forum 😂

Also I love how the op asked for which ‘guy’ and half this thread is an in-depth back and forth on whether Aries gal’s fit the bill. Well done!


lolol true! but oh well, like I said, this legit is just for fun and entertainment and to not turn this post into a random war if possible which people on the Internet struggle to NOT do these days so yeah, just for fun 🙂

I like Aries women, they're lovely, brave and caring women.
Profile picture of allrounder
allrounder
@allrounder
4 Years500+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 631 · Topics: 32
Posted by SassyKiwi

Stop all this nonsense! I have a masculine sun, moon, merc and mars and I'm cute as a button!


chill lol like I stated this post was for fun and entertainment and to not turn this post into a random war which people on the Internet struggle to not do these days. And I asked about guys/men who are manly outwardly and inwardly and what their astrology Sun signs are, not about women. Not about the whole birth chart, though yes, the whole chart is supposed to be considered and is what makes a whole person.

This post is for f u n. If you get offended easily, don't comment, move on with your day past this post, simple as that 🙂
Profile picture of SassyKiwi
Un petit pamplemousse
@SassyKiwi
10 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 1465 · Posts: 6967 · Topics: 126
Posted by allrounder
Posted by SassyKiwi

Stop all this nonsense! I have a masculine sun, moon, merc and mars and I'm cute as a button!

chill lol like I stated this post was for fun and entertainment and to not turn this post into a random war which people on the Internet struggle to not do these days. And I asked about guys/men who are manly outwardly and inwardly and what their astrology Sun signs are, not about women. Not about the whole birth chart, though yes, the whole chart is supposed to be considered and is what makes a whole person.

This post is for f u n. If you get offended easily, don't comment, move on with your day past this post, simple as that 🙂
click to expand


How on Earth did you take my post so serious... you should be ashamed of yourself.

Image Not Found
Profile picture of LadyNeptune
LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Comments: 11076 · Posts: 35718 · Topics: 110
Posted by bmoon8
Posted by LadyNeptune

Certainly not anyone here. We are all arguing with each other on an Astro forum 😂

Also I love how the op asked for which ‘guy’ and half this thread is an in-depth back and forth on whether Aries gal’s fit the bill. Well done!

I think I made my point very well. Since Aries women have this rep, it’s natural that Aries men are the manliest men.
click to expand



I'd say whichever sun sign is most likely to have elephantiasis of the balls gets the manliest man title lol
Profile picture of DMV
DMV
@DMV
15 Years25,000+ PostsSagittarius

Comments: 294 · Posts: 28989 · Topics: 654
Posted by bmoon8
Posted by DMV
Posted by bmoon8
Posted by DMV
Posted by xiongmao
Posted by DMV
Posted by xiongmao
Posted by DMV

Aries women fit the mold of what society deems as most masculine.

They’re more masculine than the men and there’s nothing wrong with it.

What does society deem as most masculine?

Aggressive

Assertive

Domineering

Strong

Tough

Direct

Etc etc



What ever is in the Old Spice Commercial.

You see it

I think there are plenty of Aries women who doesn't fit this list.

An Aries woman would win against an Aries man in a heartbeat.

No competition

Aries men are very competitive when it comes down to it.

My brother in law can beat anyone at Cornhole.

Please stop with your blanket statements!

Being masculine isn’t a negative trait.

It’s not like you grow a beard and 5 o clock shadow

Also, if the shoe don’t fit, don’t wear it

Omg. You do not get it, do you? You really can’t be this dumb, can you? Why do I feel like I am talking to a damn brick wall?

Please G_d.

It’s like nailing jello to a tree.
click to expand



Triggered much
Profile picture of DonnaLibra
DonnaLibra
@DonnaLibra
8 Years1,000+ Posts

Comments: 3 · Posts: 3164 · Topics: 7
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter

Yeah you'll have to define manly for me because in a case like this when I think of manly for a woman I think in terms of looking and acting like a man. I don't know any man that's manly but I do know some women that might be deemed as manly. This Libra lady I know is indeed one of them that falls in that category. She even said she can handle a big mack truck with ease better than most men and I believe her. For a start she grew up around boys and she has no sisters. She's married to a Capricorn dude born on Christmas day and she's the man in their relationship. While he play as the woman. I think air signs got it. Fire signs can forget it cus their really mostly all talk that actually can't be about being manly. Earth signs are too womanly so that's out of the equation for them.

Yes we Libra women definitely have a masculine side. We are cool under pressure, not very emotional when everyone else is in tears, can drive anything, athletic, and brave, not afraid of a fight. All while having perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and looking great! LMFAO!

Are you a tomboy? Not saying that being manly is a tomboy thing for the ladies. I actually do know some feminine Libra women who fall under that latter category in your post. My right hand Libra lady (if you will) is exactly that. Perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and I might even substitute that looking great for cute in her case. She don't take no shit from people regardless. She may not be manly but she is a little rough around the edges ie straightforward, blunt, can be rude even towards me etc.

Yes I'm a Tomboy. I'm the only girl with older brothers and grew up on a farm. But I've always had a passion for fashion and after school (in Ohio) I moved to Los Angeles to start my life and become a big city girl. Now I'm back on the my Dad's farm in VA where we built a house and plan to stay.

Ohhh makes sense. I myself done been into farming almost my whole life on and off hence where most of my muscles come from. I currently own two goats and milk them on occasion. Had three goats but I'm not gonna say what happen to that one. I don't want to get attack by sensitive dxpers so it's best to keep quiet. Although according to my chart I am masculine heavy but somehow I still don't feel masculine.

The Libra lady that I know is the oldest. According to what she told me she helped raised her siblings and again I believe her. Having being around her for so long she proves her toughness day after day so ain't no need for me to not believe her. Everybody keep saying Libra is soft and overlook them but what most people don't know is that Libra can be a sign that's not to be denied.

I love goats they are so cute and smart. I've had to go across the map just to realize that back on the farm is where I belong. My Dad told me it would happen. Even when I lived in L.A. I always came home for the hay season to help. I just love it and will never leave again. I was fortunate to marry a city guy who always dreamed of living the country life so here we are.

Ooh gurrrrrl I was always a country squire all my life. I actually started life in the trashy ghetto where we grew up having little to nothing and to be honest I didn't like it. You'll be surprise how far I come to where I am now. Word has it that country people in general are manly goes for both men and women. I don't want to talk bad about the city life but the city life is what got people soft and spoil now. I grew up struggling and had to do my own earning. Couldn't do that in the city where I'll be getting everything handed to me hand and foot on a silver platter.
click to expand


Yeah I've been working hard since I was 6. Don't know another way. Up at dawn, rest on Sundays only.
Profile picture of Jumpin_Jupiter
5 months without a single dip
@Jumpin_Jupiter
6 Years5,000+ Posts

Comments: 4219 · Posts: 8451 · Topics: 103
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter
Posted by DonnaLibra
Posted by Jumpin_Jupiter

Yeah you'll have to define manly for me because in a case like this when I think of manly for a woman I think in terms of looking and acting like a man. I don't know any man that's manly but I do know some women that might be deemed as manly. This Libra lady I know is indeed one of them that falls in that category. She even said she can handle a big mack truck with ease better than most men and I believe her. For a start she grew up around boys and she has no sisters. She's married to a Capricorn dude born on Christmas day and she's the man in their relationship. While he play as the woman. I think air signs got it. Fire signs can forget it cus their really mostly all talk that actually can't be about being manly. Earth signs are too womanly so that's out of the equation for them.

Yes we Libra women definitely have a masculine side. We are cool under pressure, not very emotional when everyone else is in tears, can drive anything, athletic, and brave, not afraid of a fight. All while having perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and looking great! LMFAO!

Are you a tomboy? Not saying that being manly is a tomboy thing for the ladies. I actually do know some feminine Libra women who fall under that latter category in your post. My right hand Libra lady (if you will) is exactly that. Perfectly manicured nails, perfumed and I might even substitute that looking great for cute in her case. She don't take no shit from people regardless. She may not be manly but she is a little rough around the edges ie straightforward, blunt, can be rude even towards me etc.

Yes I'm a Tomboy. I'm the only girl with older brothers and grew up on a farm. But I've always had a passion for fashion and after school (in Ohio) I moved to Los Angeles to start my life and become a big city girl. Now I'm back on the my Dad's farm in VA where we built a house and plan to stay.

Ohhh makes sense. I myself done been into farming almost my whole life on and off hence where most of my muscles come from. I currently own two goats and milk them on occasion. Had three goats but I'm not gonna say what happen to that one. I don't want to get attack by sensitive dxpers so it's best to keep quiet. Although according to my chart I am masculine heavy but somehow I still don't feel masculine.

The Libra lady that I know is the oldest. According to what she told me she helped raised her siblings and again I believe her. Having being around her for so long she proves her toughness day after day so ain't no need for me to not believe her. Everybody keep saying Libra is soft and overlook them but what most people don't know is that Libra can be a sign that's not to be denied.

I love goats they are so cute and smart. I've had to go across the map just to realize that back on the farm is where I belong. My Dad told me it would happen. Even when I lived in L.A. I always came home for the hay season to help. I just love it and will never leave again. I was fortunate to marry a city guy who always dreamed of living the country life so here we are.

Ooh gurrrrrl I was always a country squire all my life. I actually started life in the trashy ghetto where we grew up having little to nothing and to be honest I didn't like it. You'll be surprise how far I come to where I am now. Word has it that country people in general are manly goes for both men and women. I don't want to talk bad about the city life but the city life is what got people soft and spoil now. I grew up struggling and had to do my own earning. Couldn't do that in the city where I'll be getting everything handed to me hand and foot on a silver platter.

Yeah I've been working hard since I was 6. Don't know another way. Up at dawn, rest on Sundays only.
click to expand



I been working hard all my life. Retired. And I'm fed up with working now.

So I guess manly can be define as many ways. And I'm gonna face facts here. I don't think I ever come across nobody who's actually manly. Being strong certainly don't make one manly and if you believe in the beta and alpha thing, alpha don't make you manly either. I think I'm gonna just stick to my gut instinct and believe country people in general are the manly types. I bet some of these dxpers wouldn't survive if they had to live in the country alone. And if they could, they manly.
Profile picture of SitusInversus27
SitusInversus27
@SitusInversus27
4 Years

Comments: 142 · Posts: 218 · Topics: 1
Posted by pooface222
Posted by Parkourler
Posted by DMV

Aries women fit the mold of what society deems as most masculine.

They’re more masculine than the men and there’s nothing wrong with it.

That wasn`t the question. Pisces man are the manliest.

I was wondering if someone was going to say Pisces. They are soft and feminine but in a manly way.

Its so sexy.

They are able to express their feelings without feeling embarrassed..and that to me is manly.
click to expand



Interesting how you're the first person here on Dxp with such an unique and new way of looking at Pisces.