I’m in love with two guys

This topic was created in the Aquarius forum by Cherry123 on Monday, August 12, 2019 and has 30 replies.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Profile picture of leooox
@leooox
7 Years500+ Posts

choose neither, i was in a similar situation and im not with either. instead met a different person who is much well suited for me that i wouldnt be able to have these thoughts when im with him

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

I love my Cap sooo much, the Cancer isn’t even somebody I can imagine a relationship with anymore. My cap is just so serious that’s what I hate and the cancer is loose no strings attached but his drive is Zero and he’s selfish. Does are the pros and cons. But I’ve been keeping this secret from my boyfriend of talking to my ex, I guess I’m also wondering should I ever tell him or will being honest just make things worst?

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Brittnie

Nooooo... Surely you dont love both equally? Make a list of all the pros and cons of each lmfao

-Virgo SN


I love the cap the Cancer sex was just fun and no strings attached just a hook up

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Cancer wants to meet up

I want meet up too and see what happens, but I feel so bad it will hurt my Cap If ever found out. I don’t want him to know I cheated. I want to marry my Cap one day but I need to make sure the Cancer guy is truly not met for me.

Profile picture of Brittnie
@Brittnie
9 Years1,000+ PostsAquarius

Posted by Cherry123

I love my Cap sooo much, the Cancer isn’t even somebody I can imagine a relationship with anymore. My cap is just so serious that’s what I hate and the cancer is loose no strings attached but his drive is Zero and he’s selfish. Does are the pros and cons. But I’ve been keeping this secret from my boyfriend of talking to my ex, I guess I’m also wondering should I ever tell him or will being honest just make things worst?

Yea it definitely sounds like you need to be with someone else. My ex was too serious like that but now I have a man who can be serious when need be, he has lots of drive, responsible but we can also be goofy as fuck and make each other laugh. With those two extremes, I def recommend finding someone else. Someone who's in the middle like some of the other comments have mentioned

Profile picture of LadyNeptune
@LadyNeptune
10 Years25,000+ Posts

Posted by Cherry123

So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

IDK if I would call it love if your thinking about fucking an ex behind his back and have been in communication with said ex this whole time.

Miss me with that kinda love...

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

FYI I’m a Aquarius. I told my Cancer ex we couldn’t keep doing this anymore, the lies and secrets are messing with head and heart, at first he was like ok I understand, then he started accusing me of playing with his mind and emotions, but when I asked him does he even love he said I have love for you and i really really like you. WTF. I think he’s trying to manipulate me into feeling guilty for cutting him off. I always kept it honest with him that we were only hooking up because the sex was good and I had feelings for him, mostly the feeling part. And yes I still end up having had sex with him and I also had sex with my Cap on the same day. But it wasn’t the same with the cancer it wasn’t anything, I felt just pressure and then laying there I felt just regrets. My Cap felt good and safe and he lasts longer and he genuinely knows how to please me. I am just a selfish low life, I really cry now and I can’t imagine how i made such a stupid decision. My ex wasn’t who I was meant to be with and I cheated the one who I am supposed to be with playing a games.

I’m stuck with keep my secret and hope it never gets out and be the best girlfriend and one day wife.

Or tell him everything now.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Erinelda
Posted by Cherry123

Cancer wants to meet up

I want meet up too and see what happens, but I feel so bad it will hurt my Cap If ever found out. I don’t want him to know I cheated. I want to marry my Cap one day but I need to make sure the Cancer guy is truly not met for me.

I'm pretty sure that you are Kittens at this point.

click to expand


No I’m 1000% sure I’m not who ever that is

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Neno2
Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Whats your venus?

Gemini?😂

click to expand


Venues is Pisces

Profile picture of VenusAquarius
@VenusAquarius
14 Years10,000+ Posts

Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Let this learn ya to multi-date and not be too keen on commitment.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Koinu

Why not do two at the same time?

Kidding aside, Cap finds out about this and you will discover a new object in this universe colder than ice.


I would kill my self if he treated me like that. It’s stupid decision I made, I’m 19 he’s 26 I’m sure he’s made bad decision too. But I’d forgive him

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Impulsv
Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Hey pass up you Capricorn

A Scorpio woman will appreciate him better.

Probably the worst betrayal talking to ex while he’s working hard at work to provide with you

Go back to the cancer

click to expand


No he’s my man, you guys do better with cancers

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by VenusAquarius
Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Let this learn ya to multi-date and not be too keen on commitment.

click to expand


Is this a Aquarius thing am I doomed to forever have little crush’s then kick guys to the curb. Is it bad to want my cake and eat it too as long as nobody is really getting hurt aside from ego and trust. Like I would be fine if he was sleeping with other girls as long as I didn’t know. Or he wasn’t in my face with it.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by Aquaman2

Cancer and cap deserves a better woman. 🙂


How when the cancer wouldn’t let me move on, knowing I was in love with him. Then kept playing with my feelings. I was planning on breaking with my Cap but after time I fell in love with and got stuck in love triangle with two guys.

It happens your probably guilty of it time at one time.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Look everybody I came here for advice. I’m hurting and I feel already like a penny with a hole in it that worthless. But I really want be able to live in my on own hell of a decision of not wanting to tell him.

Profile picture of justagirl
@justagirl
12 Years25,000+ Posts

Posted by Cherry123
Posted by VenusAquarius
Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Let this learn ya to multi-date and not be too keen on commitment.


Is this a Aquarius thing am I doomed to forever have little crush’s then kick guys to the curb. Is it bad to want my cake and eat it too as long as nobody is really getting hurt aside from ego and trust. Like I would be fine if he was sleeping with other girls as long as I didn’t know. Or he wasn’t in my face with it.
click to expand

This has nothing to do with astrology. Poor life choices is a person issue, not an astrology thing. Also, you are tagged for multi accounts, I doubt you are even an Aqua.

Profile picture of Cherry123
@Cherry123
6 Years

Posted by justagirl
Posted by Cherry123
Posted by VenusAquarius
Posted by Cherry123

Had up and down relationship with a cancer guy for 2 years sex was good and he really loved me, Met a stable Capricorn guy he’s fun sex is good, cares about me, hard worker we’ve been dating for a year. But I’m still talking to Cancer guy behind my Capricorn boyfriends back while he’s at work. I’ve been lusting the Cancer on and off for months. So The cancer wants me to meet up with him after work should I go? Just to get it out of my system. Or should I just end it forever. Or break up with the Capricorn guy who I love and I know he loves me.

P.s similar experience would help.

Let this learn ya to multi-date and not be too keen on commitment.


Is this a Aquarius thing am I doomed to forever have little crush’s then kick guys to the curb. Is it bad to want my cake and eat it too as long as nobody is really getting hurt aside from ego and trust. Like I would be fine if he was sleeping with other girls as long as I didn’t know. Or he wasn’t in my face with it.

This has nothing to do with astrology. Poor life choices is a person issue, not an astrology thing. Also, you are tagged for multi accounts, I doubt you are even an Aqua.

click to expand


Feb 14 that is aqua,I had few issues logging in and out its making me reset password in my email. I had two Accounts for 2 days Flowers123 and Blossom133 but it kicked does out

Profile picture of Gemitati
@Gemitati
11 Years25,000+ Posts

Posted by Cherry123

Cancer wants to meet up

I want meet up too and see what happens, but I feel so bad it will hurt my Cap If ever found out. I don’t want him to know I cheated. I want to marry my Cap one day but I need to make sure the Cancer guy is truly not met for me.

Profile picture of sweetpea2977
@sweetpea2977
7 Years1,000+ Posts

Posted by blvckphvse
Posted by Cherry123

I love my Cap sooo much, the Cancer isn’t even somebody I can imagine a relationship with anymore. My cap is just so serious that’s what I hate and the cancer is loose no strings attached but his drive is Zero and he’s selfish. Does are the pros and cons. But I’ve been keeping this secret from my boyfriend of talking to my ex, I guess I’m also wondering should I ever tell him or will being honest just make things worst?

If you loved the Cap you wouldn't be lusting after an old flame that you can't even imagine being with.. Like listen to yourself.. You should be alone and figure your shit out.

click to expand

👏👏👏